top of page

Psychiatry Lets Us Keep Functioning. Psychedelics Offer an Entirely Different Solution

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Aug 18, 2021
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

What's the difference between Lexapro and LSD? What are the core differences between psychiatry and psychedelics? And why is the effect of psychedelics so much more fundamental?

A psychiatrist, a drunk and a shaman walk into a bar. "How are you doing?" the bartender asks the drunk. "I realized I live alone and I'll die alone, and nothing I do will change that," the drunk answers. "So give me something that'll help me not think about it" — and the bartender pours him a double whiskey.

The bartender turns to the psychiatrist and asks, "How about you?" She answers: "I had a hard day. I realized I live alone and I'll die alone and nothing I do will change that. So just bring me a glass of water." As he hands her the water, she swallows a pill for depression and anxiety along with it.

"And you?" the bartender finally asks the shaman. "I had a wonderful day," the shaman answers. "I realized there's no difference between me and you, or between me and them." He points at the psychiatrist, who's already starting to relax thanks to her pills, and at the drunk, who's already starting to forget his troubles and ordering another double whiskey. "We're all connected," he adds, "so the only thing you can really do for me is tell me how you're doing."

I made up this little parable to explain, briefly, the difference between the answer psychiatry gives to the distress of human existence, the answer psychedelics and meditation give to it, and the common escapist solution. The distress itself, in the framing I'm using here, is rooted in the feeling that each of us is a single unit moving alone through the world, one to which all the existential truths apply: there will always be an unbridgeable gap between us and every other unit in the world; nothing will give our existence meaning; we will die alone; and after our death we'll be forgotten, and ultimately our lives will be meaningless to those who come after us.

Within a modern worldview, these insights are hard to live with, and they push us toward depression and anxiety. We cope with that depression and anxiety in all kinds of ways, the two central ones being escapist repression and medication. Escapist repression can wear many masks, from drug use all the way to building the pyramids. Solutions like these help us cope with the terror of our own inevitable, bitterly-known fate by suppressing that terror with substances that let us set aside what frightens us, or delude ourselves into thinking it won't happen to us.

The traditional medication-based treatment that exists today in psychiatry offers to calm our nervous system down in a way that lets us keep functioning. That is, we still see ourselves more or less as a crystal glass balanced at the edge of a table, one that will fall and shatter into hundreds of pieces the moment something disturbs its delicate balance — but that no longer makes us want to stay in bed and hide under the covers until this frightening thing called life passes us by. Thanks to the medication, we manage to go to work, start a family, run errands, and be productive, ordinary citizens.

The third path, by contrast, offers an entirely different solution. This path, which you can walk either through meditation or through psychedelics, helps us see the whole picture completely differently. In this picture, the differences between me and another person exist the same way that, in a photo on my iPhone, the pixels that make up the image of me are different from the pixels that make up the image of the watermelon I'm eating. Meaning: they're not really different at all. It's only their color, and their position relative to other pixels, that causes distinct images of a woman and a watermelon to appear on the screen from a human point of view, under very particular conditions.

From this vantage point, there's no logic in the woman's image in the photo being any more anxious about her individual fate than the watermelon is troubled by the prospect of shattering on the floor and getting eaten by ants. There's really no difference between the pixels within the image, and there's no meaning to identifying the woman's image and the watermelon's image as separate, as far as the pixels themselves are concerned.

Of course, this answer resolves the distress from a completely different angle. In fact, it largely dissolves it, because it rejects the basic premise the distress grows out of — the premise that we're all disconnected and have to face our inevitable annihilation alone.

Since all of these paths are paved, at least in part, in our brains, it's interesting to compare the brain processes at work in each one. To that end, I want to sketch out the differences between them — admittedly in a rough, simplified way, but still one that can serve as food for thought, or a starting point for further discussion, for anyone who finds this subject close to their heart.

Psychiatry Lets Us Keep Functioning. Psychedelics Offer an Entirely Different Solution - illustration

How Do Anti-Anxiety and Antidepressant Medications Work, and Why Do They Affect Our Mood?

Let me briefly explain how medications from the SSRI family, known as antidepressants, work. These medications act on the neurotransmitter serotonin. If we think of the brain as a party, we can imagine serotonin as those cool guests who really get the party going. Every such guest has a point where they go home — because their partner's waiting for them, because they have an important day at work tomorrow, or simply because they're tired. Antidepressant medications work by preventing serotonin from clearing out of the system at its usual speed. In other words, they're a mechanism that keeps the guests who "get things going" at your party longer, and the party is more easily able to take off. Of course, the scientific picture is more complex than this, and not all psychoactive medications work the same way, but this is one of their central mechanisms.

How Does Alcohol Work, and Why Does It Help Us Forget Our Troubles?

Alcohol has plenty of negative effects in the long run, but to explain how it works in the short run, let's imagine our brain as a small independent shopkeeper who, for the sake of argument, owns a store. Now let's bring another neurotransmitter into the picture, called dopamine. We could say dopamine is the brain's currency. Absent some truly, truly exceptional circumstances, our shopkeeper will tend to repeat any action that brings in money. Alcohol is like a wealthy tourist — doesn't matter from where — who walks into the store and spends money with total abandon. It's easy to understand why a customer like that, at the end of a hard day, completely changes our shopkeeper's mood.

How Do Meditation and Psychedelics Work?

The existential truth that underlies the common emotional distress I described at the start of this column — our existence in the world as a complete, unique, separate unit — isn't, as far as the brain is concerned, based on fact. It's based on a hypothesis. In an earlier column, where I wrote about the Bayesian model for understanding the brain, I laid out the idea that the brain is a machine whose purpose is to produce predictions. The existence of a separate, unique "self" is one such hypothesis. You could call it a hypothesis, but you could just as well call it a hallucination. Let me try to illustrate this with the following image:

What do we see in this image? Do you see a face in it? Of course you do. Our brain is built to recognize faces based on the smallest possible amount of information. Can you, at the same time, also see that this is really nothing more than one large circle containing two smaller circles, a triangle and a curved line? Sure you can. Is one of these descriptions the correct one? No. In that sense, the face we see when we look at this particular cluster of shapes placed in proximity and in specific positions is an example of our prediction machine's most efficient hypothesis. That's also why we can say that we're hallucinating this face more than we're seeing it with certainty through some unmediated encounter with the raw sensory information reaching our brain from outside. Our experience of "self" is, in large part, very much like the way we see the face in this image.

In terms of brain activity, both meditation and classic psychedelics (like psilocybin, the active compound in magic mushrooms, as well as LSD) jam a piece of gum into the prediction engine, reducing the activity of the "hallucination projector" that continuously projects the brain's ceaseless predictions onto its surroundings.

You could describe it a bit like the difference between how a toddler experiences their home environment and how an adult experiences that very same environment. The toddler will be enchanted by things that, to an adult, are utterly mundane, because their brain doesn't yet predict them in advance ("Look at this, when you pick up a pea and let go, it falls to the floor — whoooaaa"). And in the context we're discussing here, under the influence of meditation practice (especially nondual meditation, which emphasizes the lack of distinction between a person and their surroundings), and under the influence of psychedelics, the brain's self-hallucination is weakened.

The effect that this weakening has on our mental well-being can be illustrated like this. Under ordinary conditions, we're like people handed a small box containing a delicate sugar-lace decoration, the kind placed next to a dessert at a fancy restaurant. We're told that this delicate decoration is us, and that its fate is our fate. Now we have to guard this box at all costs.

We start pouring all our energy into protecting this box — looking for ways to pad it, finding high shelves to place it on, working hard to identify people who might shake the box and keeping our distance from them, and so on. Psychedelics and meditation are like someone who talks us into daring to open the box — and then we discover, to our astonishment, that it's empty. There's no sugar decoration inside. There never was. We poured all that energy into protecting an empty box. That realization is the foundation of the liberation that comes from this third kind of intervention.

By the way, this explanation is also connected to the fact that insights gained under the influence of psychedelics are so often tagged as an unforgettable truth. They were experienced while the hallucination machine was disrupted, so it's fair to say they really were based on a more direct encounter with reality. In other words, to a real extent, they were closer to truth, or to reality — the same way a child is closer to reality than an adult is. It's ironic, then, that these very substances are the ones called hallucinogens.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page