Our Era Has No Tolerance for Flawed Figures. So How Do We Still Take the Good From Them?
Updated: Oct 22
There are people I learn enormous amounts from, who help me grow and, indirectly, help my patients too. But what do you do when dark sides of their character come to light?
I have a crush. My crush is a British man, extremely charismatic, with a wonderful voice and a marvelous way of talking about Zen. My crush's name is Alan Watts. He's dead, by the way. Well, you know — "dead" in Western terms. But that's not actually my problem, because if Watts were alive today he'd be 105. I was born a few months after he passed, and I suspect the age gap would have made it hard for us to actually make our love work.
If you're into Zen, you don't need me to introduce him to you. You already know his wonderful lectures, which you can listen to on YouTube or on the site one of his sons built in his honor. I assume you also own a few of his books in translation. Humor and lightness are among the qualities that define Watts's teaching style, and they come through especially clearly when you listen to him. Sometimes he actually cracks himself up out loud, and it's hard not to fall under his spell. When I listen to him, I want to accept the gospel of Zen completely. I feel like he truly understands the kind of people who can remind me that there's no door actually closing us in, and nothing stopping us from simply walking out of our inner prison into freedom.
Watts and I lived an idyll together for a while — until I made the mistake. Instead of being content to just read him, I started reading about him on Google. That's how I discovered he'd been married three times and fathered seven children — a move that raises the odds one of your descendants will eventually consolidate your entire body of work onto a single website, but that maybe also hints at a certain restlessness. That's also how I learned that Watts was a heavy smoker his whole life, that he hit the bottle pretty hard too, and that he died of complications from alcoholism.
That information clouded our relationship a bit. His heavy, self-destructive drinking exposed, to my mind, the fact that he probably didn't actually practice much meditation. It's fairly clear that meditation and heavy drinking — a bit like cooking and ballet, say — are fields that compete for your attention, and it's hard for a person to master both. Looking back at Watts's lectures, this really shouldn't have surprised me. Watts never treated meditation the way it's understood in the Zen community. His view, as it comes through in his texts, is one where enlightenment is achievable through insight alone, without any practice. In one of his lectures he even described Zen practice this way: "A cat sits until it's tired of sitting, then it gets up, stretches, and goes on its way."
And the question I keep asking myself is: is that a problem? Is there a meaningful contradiction between the messages in Watts's lectures — the importance of the connection between humanity and nature and the environment, the importance of the connection between the ancient and the contemporary, between East and West, the illusion of the separate self — and his own personal example, or lack of one? As my friend D., who knows far more about Zen than I do, put it to me: "Jesus and Muhammad surely meditated a lot more than Alan Watts did — and think about how much damage came in their wake, compared with the minuscule amount of damage Watts caused." His answer put my mind at ease.
I'm still drawn more to meditation, and I believe less in the possibility of reaching lasting personal transformation through insight alone — but I'm glad that a cool guy like Watts is the one who gets to symbolize that possibility.

Which brings me to a harder question: the question of Sadhguru. Sadhguru is the name used by Jaggi Vasudev, an unusually charismatic Indian mystic who founded the Isha Foundation, which offers yoga programs around the world; its flagship program is called "Inner Engineering," and it includes an introduction to meditation and spiritual development. I first came across Sadhguru's name while listening to a podcast with Gabor Maté. When Maté mentioned that he starts every morning with a 50-minute Isha yoga practice, I decided I should give it a try too. Since then I've listened closely to Sadhguru's full introductory lecture series, and I try to practice his meditation.
My immediate experience was, on the whole, excellent. My sense is that Sadhguru found a fantastic way to make the core ideas of Buddhism accessible. His phrasing is sharp, surprising and incisive, and the whole package is built so that you can keep moving down the path without worrying that, at the end of it, you'll be asked to shed all the trappings of this world and join a cult (though, come to think of it, maybe that's exactly how entry into every cult is built). By the end of Sadhguru's meditations I felt enormous joy. During some of them I cried from sheer emotion — something that had never happened to me before.
Only at the edges of my awareness did a faint buzz of unease bother me, coming from two sources. First, Sadhguru speaks with total confidence about a huge range of subjects and presents many claims as scientifically valid, but in some cases — when they were subjects I happen to know a little about — I could tell that a fair number of errors had crept into what he was saying. Second, Sadhguru has a tendency to joke at the expense of relations between the sexes in a way that carries a whiff of misogyny. Sometimes women are described as angry creatures who make their partners' lives hell, and sometimes it's a kind of misogyny that's entirely unaware of itself, because it describes women as more delicate and sophisticated creatures than men — which is, of course, just as problematic a stance. Still, neither of these two things bothered me enough to keep me from enjoying the rest of the content.
And then I made the same mistake I'd made with Alan Watts, and did a bit of digging about Sadhguru on Google. A very short search led me to a deeply disturbing story about his late wife, Vijaykumari. According to Sadhguru's own website, his wife was a person of an extremely high spiritual level, and in fact met the strictest possible criteria for sainthood. Her most dramatic miracle was the manner in which she left her body. According to Sadhguru, his wife told him in advance the exact date on which she intended to leave her body, and then did so entirely of her own will, without resorting to any violent means — meaning she didn't take her own life, and didn't bring illness upon herself either.
I don't know how you're receiving this story, but after ten days of unease, I sat down at Google and typed, in English: "Did Sadhguru kill his wife?" You're welcome to try that search yourselves and see that, unfortunately, the question turns up no shortage of results. This story isn't settled. I have no idea whether he killed her, and I obviously much prefer the version in which he was married to the one true saint of the modern age. As an environmental activist, I imagine he's also made plenty of enemies who are only too happy to smear him all over the internet. And still, the question nags at me: can I take certain things from the spiritual meal Sadhguru offers, even when the quality of some of the ingredients is in serious doubt?
I don't have an answer to these questions. In an era ruled by cancel culture, it isn't simple to sit with ambivalence. Watts and Sadhguru are people I learn enormous amounts from, and I feel that they help me grow, both as a person and as a therapist. When I bring some of their wisdom to my patients, I feel like we all come out ahead. But each of them leaves a remainder that doesn't divide evenly. With Watts it's smaller, because unlike Sadhguru, Watts may have understood whiskey better than he understood meditation, but he also never claimed to be telling anyone how to live. In that sense, Sadhguru is his mirror image. Except that sometimes even that spiritual mirror goes dark — and the question that stays open for me is what you're supposed to do with it when it does.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com



