top of page

Not by Force, by Empathy: The Method That Always Surprises My Patients

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Dec 15, 2022
7 min read

In emotionally focused therapy, we treat harmful behaviors as ways of coping with uncomfortable feelings. So instead, we try to treat the emotional pain those behaviors are trying to soothe – in the hope that once that pain starts to heal, there'll be no more need to cover it up with them

"I just have to stop losing my temper like this," Oren (all names have been changed) told me. "I have to count to ten, or a hundred, or a thousand – whatever it takes." The truth is, Oren was right. His outbursts weren't dangerous, but they poisoned the atmosphere at home, and over time increased the odds that he'd hurt his children emotionally.

Oren, who grew up in conditions of real scarcity, is a sharp, driven man who became a highly successful businessman. He gave his kids a life of abundance, and every time he saw them behaving "like little pigs," as he put it – say, grabbing the most tempting piece of chicken off the serving plate, or starting to eat before the whole family had sat down at the table – he'd flare up and explode at them.

Oren wanted to stop losing his temper. In a similar spirit, Shira had also told herself she absolutely had to make progress on her doctorate. Usually, when she sits herself down to work, she starts to get confused, doesn't know which part to focus on, and very quickly starts yawning, her eyes close, and she almost always collapses into an afternoon nap. The sleep does put some distance between her and the stress, but she wakes up from it feeling guilty and low (the shift to winter time only made this worse). "No more excuses," Shira announced to me: from now on, three times a week, she's simply going to sit down at the table, open her laptop, and start working.

Karen, too, is making a similarly resolute plan to stop drinking so much. "I've quit before," she says, trying to build up her own confidence, after showing up again to a session with a terrible hangover that made it hard for us to do much work together. "I can do it again. This drinking isn't good for me, it's not even fun anymore, and the mornings after get harder every year."

What do Oren's temper, Shira's falling asleep, and Karen's drinking episodes have in common? On the surface, these are three problematic behavioral tendencies: Oren's anger creates tension at home and scars his children; Shira's sleepiness and confusion leave her professionally stuck, without a doctorate; and Karen's drinking is unhealthy, harms her work, and makes it hard for her to sustain a romantic relationship over time.

So it's easy to understand why all three of them are trying to eliminate these behaviors. And with various therapeutic approaches, they could probably achieve some kind of change. Oren could take an "anger management" course, Shira could go to a coach to help her make progress on her PhD, Karen could try various methods for quitting alcohol.

But in emotionally focused therapy, we don't spend much time trying to eliminate these behaviors as such. This approach usually surprises patients the first time they hear about it, because they themselves are usually the ones suffering most from their own behaviors. Sometimes their own suffering, and the suffering of the people around them, is so great that it's exactly what pushed them into therapy in the first place. Oren's wife threatened to leave him if he didn't "get a grip on himself." Shira's parents aren't going to keep funding many more years of her life as a PhD student. And Karen's biological clock is ticking. So when they (and many others in similar situations) start therapy, they usually genuinely disapprove of their own problematic behaviors, and simply want to be rid of them.

That's not what's on offer in emotionally focused therapy, or in closely related schools of therapy. Not because therapists in this approach are backing the anger, the procrastination, or the drinking, or denying the damage they cause – but because we see these behaviors as three different ways of coping with uncomfortable feelings. What's more, these three coping strategies, which certainly create problems in the long run, do solve some kind of problem in the short run for the person displaying them.

So instead, we try to treat the emotional pain these behaviors are trying to soothe, in the hope that once that pain starts to heal, Oren will no longer need his temper, Shira won't collapse into sleep, and Karen won't need that drink.

Not by Force, by Empathy: The Method That Always Surprises My Patients - illustration

Among other things, this means our approach to the parts of our patients that engage in these ineffective coping strategies is an empathic one. Oren's angry part, Shira's sleepy part, Karen's drinking part – all three are parts the therapist approaches with a great deal of curiosity and compassion. Again, that doesn't mean the therapist encourages or nurtures them. But she also doesn't attack them or judge them right away.

Do you know the children's story about the sun and the wind, who competed over which of them was stronger? They saw a nobleman riding by wrapped in a cloak, and made a bet over which of them could get him to take it off. The wind blew hard on the nobleman, trying to strip the garment off him, but the harder it blew, the more tightly the freezing man clutched his cloak, trying to stay warm.

The sun, by contrast, warmed him so much that he took the cloak off of his own accord, in order to go bathe in a lake. The analogy is clear: the cloak is the protective behavior. The more we attack a person, the tighter they cling to it. The warmer we are toward them, the more likely they are to be able to shed that defense on their own – because they'll need it less.

Empathic inquiry helps us understand together: what pain is this behavior protecting the person from? In Oren's case, his children's greedy behavior reopened the wound of a childhood of scarcity, brought back difficult memories from his own upbringing, and filled him with a feeling of humiliation.

In Shira's case, the blank page on her computer screen brought back scenes from her childhood, when she'd try to get help from her father with schoolwork and be met with impatience and sarcasm, which left her with deep wounds to her self-image.

In Karen's case, social situations stirred up the sense of being an outsider she'd felt as a new immigrant, and filled her with anxiety.

Oren's anger wasn't pleasant, but it fully conveyed his sense of humiliation. Shira falling asleep left her feeling down, but not right away – in fact, the sleep itself provided immediate, soothing relief. And that first drink, or even the second, certainly eased Karen's social anxiety. The deeper we dug into the history of these behaviors, the more we could see that, on the whole, they'd been a smart adaptation, one that had actually served each of them well in the past, and sometimes continued to serve them well in certain contexts.

Oren's anger channeled him into a combat unit that functioned like a socioeconomic elevator, letting him climb the skyscraper of Israeli society. That same anger has won him plenty of results in his current profession too. Shira's ability to disconnect and shut down let her survive her father's violence, and Karen's drinking, in her youth, let her build a rich social life. It took time for the price tag on these behaviors to finally come due.

Even if this therapeutic approach looks like the most serious way of treating maladaptive behaviors, it isn't right for everyone. Plenty of people arrive in therapy at a stage where these defensive strategies have already exacted a heavy toll from the people around them, and they're impatient, longing for a faster process where someone simply "tells them what to do." Others understand that they need to touch the pain, but can't bring themselves to do it, and prefer a form of therapy that focuses on changing how they interpret their triggers, along with behavioral interventions.

These choices are understandable, and here and there you'll find truly exceptional people who manage to achieve long-term results through what we call "top-down" change – meaning change that originates in the more sophisticated parts of the brain and influences the more primitive parts, or in other words, emotional change that originates in changes to thinking and to "rational" decisions. But in most cases, deep and lasting change requires "bottom-up" work – that is, work on the deeper feelings, which in turn eventually shapes our thinking and our decisions.

Recommendations

Supplements: comparing dosages

I'm often asked to recommend specific supplement brands. I don't usually do that, but I'd like to offer a certain way of thinking that, for me, serves as one measure for choosing a vitamin or supplement manufacturer – at least in financial terms.

By this measure, it's important to check how much active ingredient is actually in the whole jar, and calculate the price accordingly. For example: say I want to buy a bottle of the supplement alpha-GPC (recommended for memory and energy), and the recommended dose is 300 mg. Browsing online, I find that a bottle of 60 capsules from the quality brand California Gold Nutrition costs less than 60 shekels, and appears to supply the required dose. Meanwhile, a bottle of 60 capsules from NOW Foods costs about 90 shekels. On the face of it, there's no real dilemma – if both brands are of similar quality, I'd rather buy the cheaper one.

Except that on closer inspection, I discover that in the first bottle, each capsule contains 150 mg, so reaching the required 300 mg dose takes two capsules. In the second manufacturer's bottle, on the other hand, each capsule contains the full 300 mg. That means the first box gives you 30 doses of 300 mg, while the second gives you 60 doses of 300 mg – but the second one costs only 50% more, not double. So it turns out that the seemingly pricier bottle is actually the better deal.

Podcast: Tell Me About Your Pain

I heard about this podcast from a patient coping with chronic pain. It helped him so much that he rations out the episodes, listening to them sparingly, as if they were a miracle medication that might run out. The hosts, Alan Gordon and Alon Ziv, discuss the struggles of various people living with chronic pain in every episode, and present listeners with important techniques and promising scientific developments in the field.

Book: Friends, Lovers and the Big Terrible Thing

Reading Matthew Perry's memoir – yes, Chandler from Friends – wasn't a uniform experience for me. I read the first 70% of the book closely, and toward the end I found myself skimming. And even though there's a bit of a sense that the book was written by an algorithm, I found real value in the account of Perry's brutal addiction to a wide range of drugs, in the raw candor with which he talks about his hunger for fame, and in how he connects all of it back to his own childhood.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page