top of page

No Empathy, Enjoying the Chaos, No Fear of Consequences: The Protest Movement Brought the Trolls Back to Life

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Mar 16, 2023
8 min read

Updated: Oct 22

WhatsApp groups organizing against the judicial overhaul are a huge magnet for trolls, who'll stop at nothing to get attention. How do you spot them, what can you do about them - and are you sometimes acting like a troll yourself?

You know them - they pounce on you from the metaphorical bushes of your neighborhood WhatsApp group the moment you ask an innocent question. They flood the protest movement's WhatsApp group with the same identical message, sent more than 20 times. They spread fake news and respond with feigned innocence when they're exposed - these are the trolls. The protest movement against the judicial overhaul has supercharged WhatsApp groups, and along with them, our exposure to trolls has grown proportionally.

Trolls are characterized by a lack of empathy. They struggle to consider the feelings of others in the group, or to imagine how things look from someone else's point of view. They devote themselves to their harmful behavior even though they know others are being hurt by it, and on the surface, at least, they don't appear to feel any remorse.

Trolls crave attention. They genuinely yearn for engagement and work very hard to provoke strong reactions in others. One of their favorite ways of doing this is putting out inflammatory, controversial statements.

The combination of all these traits produces antisocial behavior - what we used to call "sociopathic." Trolls disregard social norms, or more precisely, they're intensely aware of them and enjoy defying them. The underlying psychological assumption is that trolls suffer from low self-esteem, and trolling is a maladaptive but short-term effective coping mechanism, because the reactions they get from their surroundings make them feel more important.

There are several reasons online forums attract trolls, but broadly speaking they break down into two: a) the absence of consequences for one's actions, and b) the existence of a captive, engaged audience.

As for the first reason, the main component here is, of course, anonymity. The idiot who trolled the "Parents for Democracy" WhatsApp group in Tel Aviv ultimately remained anonymous. Maybe we could track him down if we really wanted to, but at the surface level of group interaction, there's no information about him beyond his WhatsApp profile picture. And as we've known since the days of the Inquisition, and through the social-psychology experiments of the 1960s, anonymity encourages aggression.

A person who doesn't need to fear being identified and held emotionally or practically accountable for their actions may be more tempted toward violent behavior. The sheer physical distance between people belonging to the same virtual group makes it easier for trolls to ignore the impact their behavior has on others. And maybe that's the heart of the matter: the absence of consequences for their actions makes it very easy for trolls to hurt others. And incidentally, this may well be a question the legal world will need to grapple with in the future.

As for the second reason, trolls are driven by the desire to draw attention to themselves, and a WhatsApp group provides plenty of audience. Far more than a one-on-one conversation or waiting in line at the grocery store. In addition, since online forums frequently discuss - and certainly do these days - controversial, emotionally charged topics, trolls know that in such groups they're likely to get a lot of attention for their outrageous behavior.

In this sense, there's a similarity between the psychology of the troll and what's known as "mob mentality." In both cases, a feeling of anonymity, or of belonging to a large enough group, triggers a loss of inhibition and a suspension of social norms (like someone farting in a crowded elevator or in a large crowd).

In other words, the person trolling you on WhatsApp may behave differently in the real world, where he isn't anonymous, and where there are real consequences to his behavior. Although, as we see at the demonstrations, here and there are trolls who crave negative attention in the world outside their phones too.

The phenomenon isn't new. You could say Jacob trolled his father Isaac back in biblical times, when he took advantage of his father's blindness to impersonate Esau and profit from it. But the term in its current sense has existed since the earliest days of the internet, certainly since the 1990s. Even then, a need arose to identify and deal with people who deliberately posted provocative or offensive messages in chat rooms and online forums, with the aim of disrupting and harassing.

By the way, for years I thought the term came from those cute, naked trolls with the wild hair, but as I understand it, the real origin is a fishing technique called "trolling" - meaning the troll is the fisherman, the provocative statement is the bait, and we, with our furious reactions, are the fish. The most famous troll, it seems to me, is Elon Musk, and Twitter is the ocean where he fishes for us with his provocative, misleading tweets.

But even if the phenomenon is old, the current period is certainly bringing it to a new peak. That makes sense, given trolls' need for attention. Since discussions about the future of the State of Israel are a lethal combination of two things trolls crave - politics and current events - the protest movement's WhatsApp groups are a magnet for trolls. Trolls can't resist the temptation to try to provoke others by putting out inflammatory statements or spreading misleading information. Similarly, religion is a divisive subject that trolls are drawn to. Not to mention race and ethnicity, gender and sexuality.

No Empathy, Enjoying the Chaos, No Fear of Consequences: The Protest Movement Brought the Trolls Back to Life - illustration

What's the Difference Between Trolling and Cyberbullying?

Which leads me to wonder whether there's even a difference between trolling and cyberbullying. And despite the significant overlap between them, I think there is. Cyberbullying is behavior in which a person uses the internet or other digital technologies to harass, frighten or humiliate another person. Prominent examples of this include spreading lies and rumors about the victim, posting hurtful comments targeting a specific person, and threatening the victim. In other words, the ultimate goal of cyberbullying is to cause harm or distress to the victim.

But the trolls' goal is slightly different. They're trying to disrupt the conversation, create chaos in a community or group, and above all, draw attention to themselves. Even if they end up hurting specific individuals, that isn't necessarily their original intent.

So what do you do about them? Let's start with the obvious. Since trolls need attention in order to thrive, the way to get rid of them is to ignore them. But truly ignore them. Or as they say, "don't even ignore them" - meaning, don't ignore them in an explicit, forceful way that shows how angry you are.

Remember that when you genuinely stop engaging with trolls, you're taking away their power, and causing them to lose interest in your group. Alongside that, it's important to set boundaries and make clear to the troll that their behavior is unacceptable and will lead to their removal from the group, or to whatever other sanction the group has agreed on. And if for some reason the troll is a significant member of the group, it may be worth considering reaching out to them privately and finding out what's bothering them and why they're behaving this way, in the hope that attention and support will help stamp out the trolling.

This implies that, theoretically, it's possible for someone to troll without realizing they're doing it. For example, someone who posts or responds with messages they think are funny, but which others find offensive.

Something similar can happen if someone "migrates" from one group, where more aggressive discourse is the norm, to another group where the discourse is more refined. In such cases, it's worth trying to give the troll feedback and hoping they can leave the troubling behavior outside the boundaries of your group.

An old joke about poker games says, "If you don't know who the sucker at the table is, it's probably you." Accordingly, if you're not sure, or you're worried you might be a troll, here are a few questions you can ask yourself:

  • Do you deliberately post provocative, triggering or offensive comments or messages often?

  • Do you enjoy getting a reaction out of others and trying to provoke them through your comments or messages?

  • Do you often find yourself arguing in groups or in the real world, feeling that winning the argument matters more to you than the value of holding a constructive conversation?

  • Do you tend to attack others personally and insult them rather than engage with the substance of their arguments?

  • Has anyone ever told you that you're trolling?

  • Have you ever been removed from a group for trolling?

If you counted up how many "yes" answers you got, then no matter how many you got - the answer is that you are (at least sometimes) a troll. Assuming you've read this far because you're looking for a new strategy to build your self-confidence, it's worth being less spontaneous (not to say impulsive) in how you phrase your messages, and trying to avoid using provocative or offensive language.

Try to listen to others, respect their boundaries, avoid personal attacks, and if someone asks you to stop communicating with them directly, respect their request and let them go. In short, consider the impact of your behavior on others before every message you post or comment you send. Are you about to add to and contribute to the conversation, or are you likely to upset others?

And finally, it's worth making sure you're well informed about the topics you're discussing, and that you're drawing on reliable sources of information. Spreading false information or conspiracy theories doesn't go over well in many groups.

Recommendations

Ever since the start of the attempted judicial overhaul, my only escapism has been crime fiction. Which means that in the past month alone, I've plowed through about six detective novels. Here are my recommendations for now, and here's to basic narrative satisfaction.

"The Humanities," by Pablo De Santis. Tesha Neshamot Publishing, noir series

"The Humanities" is a detective novel, a gothic novel, fantasy literature, and a few other things I can't quite put my finger on right now, but together they produce the "perfect bite" of detective fiction for people who love literature more than they love whodunits. Inside a library on the verge of collapse, a lazy literature scholar gets tangled up in the schemes of an obsessive group searching for the manuscript of a mysterious author. You won't be able to explain the plot to anyone, but you might enjoy every moment of it.

"The Silver Swan," by Benjamin Black. Am Oved Publishing

Benjamin Black is the pen name of Irish author John Banville, and in "The Silver Swan" he unspools another chapter in the career of Dublin pathologist Quirke, who, like any self-respecting detective hero, has difficult relationships with the people closest to him and struggles with his bad habits. There's a lot more atmosphere here than plot, but what atmosphere. Between all the Irish fog, I sometimes couldn't quite make out the words. I especially love the fact that the Quirke series is written as period fiction without making a big deal of it - meaning it feels like you're reading a book that was simply written during the historical period in which its plot takes place, and somehow its language hasn't aged.

"Moonlight Mile," by Dennis Lehane. Arie Nir Publishing

Dennis Lehane wrote "Shutter Island" and "Mystic River" - do you really need any more reasons to read this book?


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page