Narcissists: What Pain Are They Hiding Behind Their Successful Mask?
Updated: Oct 22
The narcissist doesn't actually love himself, the controlling woman feels helpless, and the perfectionist is terrified of failure. How do familiar behavioral defense mechanisms serve as an outer shell for emotional pain — and why don't they actually bring relief?
Eden, 24 (all names have been changed), is driven crazy by her brother Aner, who, at 35, displays narcissistic behaviors that suck the fun out of every family gathering. At every meal, the family ends up talking only about Aner and whatever new drama is unfolding in his life. "He's so in love with himself," she says. But I, of course, think Aner probably isn't in love with himself at all. Like many other therapists, I tend to see the vulnerable child behind the mask.
The links between the emotional pain a person carries and the ways they try to cope with it are, of course, many and complicated, and every life story is its own. But sometimes there's a tight connection between a person's coping mechanism and the emotional pain it's covering for — a connection that repeats itself often enough that you can practically guess the pain from the defensive style.
Narcissistic Defenses and the Invisible Child
Like Eden's brother Aner, people with narcissistic defenses pressure others into giving them constant attention and admiration. Although Eden thinks her brother loves himself without limit, there's a good chance Aner actually feels invisible. His defensive style may have taken shape after childhood experiences in which he didn't feel his real needs were seen, and felt lonely. According to Eden's account, Aner got plenty of attention as a child because he acted in TV shows from a young age, and was a source of pride for his parents.
But there's no contradiction here, because it's entirely possible that Aner felt he was being noticed for his achievements — for his ability to give his parents something to boast about — which is a different kind of attention from having his more vulnerable needs met, and from feeling his parents were there for him through failures and embarrassing moments too.
To cope with the pain caused by feeling invisible and by loneliness, children like Aner develop narcissistic traits and go looking for constant validation. Over the years, this can show up as grandiose behavior, a sense of entitlement, and a relentless drive for attention. Like Aner, the adult may go on to project an image of superiority and self-importance, while actually carrying an inner sense of inadequacy and vulnerability.
Controlling Behavior and Helplessness
Mai (35) runs the lives of the people close to her with an iron fist. She's the one who decides, for her siblings, her parents, her children, and her husband, how they should handle their health, their personal safety, their livelihoods, and their social relationships. But although Mai and people like her come across as very self-assured, they're often, underneath it, dealing with deep anxiety. Controlling behavior of this kind frequently stems from a sense of powerlessness and lack of control that may have been present far too often in childhood. In Mai's case, for instance, she grew up with a mother who had borderline personality disorder, whose behavior was erratic and dangerous.
Her mother drove recklessly, drank to excess, and ran her finances irresponsibly. Mai's father was an anxious, passive man who was never able to calm her mother down or insist that she take care of herself. He'd let her, for instance, drive wildly even while young Mai and her sister were throwing up in the back seat.
As an adult, by exerting excessive control, Mai tries to tamp down her anxiety and create for herself an illusion of security and an ability to predict the changes around her. This coping mechanism involves meticulous planning, a rigid routine, and a reluctance to delegate or trust others. These behaviors do give her a fleeting sense of order and safety, but they often generate a great deal of tension in her surroundings. The need anxious, controlling people have for control can lead to conflict with others, since they impose their own standards and expectations on others without regard for their autonomy.
The Perfectionist Terrified of Failure
Shiri (48) succeeds at nearly everything she does. In her youth she was a top student at university. Now, as a lawyer, she gets outstanding results for her clients and for her firm's partners, and on top of all that she manages to stay fit, keep a beautiful home, and raise her kids well. She looks simply perfect. But Shiri, like many others who display perfectionist defenses, is dealing with a deep fear of failure and a persistent sense of falling fundamentally short of expectations.
Shiri's parents raised her in an atmosphere where her sense of self-worth was tightly bound up with her achievements and successes. They praised her only when she excelled, and every mistake or failure was met with criticism or disappointment. Although it looks as though Shiri is the one setting the bar high for herself, and enjoying her extreme drive to achieve, this is actually a defense mechanism meant to reduce the anxiety tied to potential failure and the fear of not being good enough. Shiri does appear to get satisfaction from her achievements, but her therapist knows that what she's mainly experiencing is a temporary sense of relief at having once again dodged harsh self-criticism and the wave of guilt that hits her whenever she fails.

The People-Pleaser Afraid of Rejection
Oron (30) is a guy who consistently puts other people's needs ahead of his own. On the surface he seems easygoing and accommodating. He looks like he simply doesn't mind. He even has a whole worldview that justifies his sweeping concessions, which often go as far as self-harm. He lends friends money he can't really afford to lose, with no guarantee he'll ever see it again; he's stayed for years with an unfaithful partner; and he isn't compensated at work in proportion to what he contributes.
Although he seems to have no problem with any of this, anyone who really knows Oron knows there's something else behind his easygoing manner: a deep fear of rejection and abandonment. As a child, he only felt loved and worthy in his parents' eyes when he was obedient and supportive. He grew up in an environment where affection and approval weren't unconditional, but depended on Oron's ability to preserve the harmony his parents expected of him.
When Oron consistently puts other people's needs and wants first, that's also, in practice, an expression of a defense mechanism trying to secure him a sense of acceptance and spare him the emotional pain of feeling rejected. His people-pleasing is meant to guarantee his place across his different circles — social, family, professional — which leads to a pattern of neglecting his own needs, suppressing his real feelings, and repeatedly landing in situations that undermine his own well-being.
The "Sinning Priest" Mechanism
In recent decades, the Church around the world has faced a flood of horrifying cases in which priests abused children in their care. This is an extreme metaphor for the fact that someone whose coping mechanism is excessive judgment and moralizing may be wrestling, deep down, with profound shame and guilt. This defensive style often grows out of chronic experiences that left the person feeling flawed and morally inferior.
Sometimes the sense of shame is rooted in a harsh, punishment-heavy upbringing; sometimes in an extreme religious upbringing; and sometimes both occurred together with real, significant moral failings of the person's own. The result is an unbearable sense of shame, somewhat eased by a defense mechanism that applies rigid moral standards to other people and zeroes in on their supposed moral failings. Fixating on other people's moral failures gives such people temporary relief from their own painful feelings, by distracting them from their sense of worthlessness and preserving an appearance of moral superiority.
A Few More Decoy Mechanisms
Without going into too much detail, I'll also mention the insecure macho type — there's no shortage of men around us who use aggressive behavior to try to soothe their own insecurity and the fragile self-image that haunts them. Another familiar pattern is the perpetually stoned guy who's afraid of failure: that friend who always seems bored and indifferent, but who's actually dealing with a deep fear of failure, often because he grew up in an environment where his parents shut down every expression of curiosity and exploration.
And last but not least on this list: the passive-aggressive person whose boundaries were never respected. People whose defense mechanism runs to procrastination, dodging responsibility, and buried resentment were, in many cases, children whose surroundings never let them refuse what was expected of them, and who learned it was very dangerous to object openly. Their passive-aggressive coping style taught them there was another, seemingly safer way to draw a line.
These defensive behaviors didn't develop arbitrarily, and they certainly aren't what they claim to be. The narcissist doesn't love himself; the controlling woman feels helpless; the judgmental person feels morally flawed; the stoner and the people-pleaser aren't really content with so little; the perfectionist isn't baking cupcakes at midnight for the fun of it.
Our defense mechanisms are intricately bound up with the emotional pain we're trying to cope with, and they usually bring us only the most partial relief. Even when we manage to put them to work for a living, they often chip away at our quality of life and our relationships. The core problem is that they don't actually resolve the original emotional pain.
Treating the root causes of emotional distress can bring far more meaningful relief for many people. Processing Aner's childhood pain will do more to calm him down than another appearance on a reality show; working through the terrifying voice in Mai's head will bring her far more relief than constantly insisting her kids eat only organic food — and both of them will surely go on to enjoy healthier relationships as a result.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




