top of page

Listen Up: Five Listening Mistakes You Might Be Making Too

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Oct 24, 2024
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

If you interrupt people mid-story, wave away what they're saying, compete with them over who's had it worse, or dish out advice nobody asked for, welcome to the bad listeners' club. The good news: you can get better

Hearing comes naturally, but listening is one of the hardest things people do. I see this over and over — when I sit with couples, when I talk with the people closest to me, and even when I myself am the one trying to listen.

It's not an exaggeration to say that in most conversations, we don't respond the way we mean to, despite our good intentions as listeners. We often cut people off before they've finished their story, dismiss or downplay what they're telling us, compete with them over who's suffered more, or blurt out advice on impulse — when all they wanted was someone to listen.

Here's a rundown of some of the most common ways we listen badly — along with more effective ways to respond to the people whose trust, as listeners, you're trying to earn.

Ooh, That Reminds Me...

The mechanism: interrupting the speaker.

"You're not going to believe what happened to Shira — she was flying back from Switzerland, and her flight...", a friend says, launching into a story she's been dying to tell you.

The attuned response: In a case like this, the best response is simply to listen until the story is over. But if you really have to say something, try: "So what happened to her?" That kind of response reflects your interest in the story and your wish to hear how it ends. It lets the speaker keep talking without being cut off, and gives her the sense that what she's saying matters to you.

The unlistening response: "Ooh, that reminds me — the supermarket started carrying that Swiss chocolate you like again." This is an unlistening response because it cuts the speaker off and steers the conversation somewhere else. It tells her that what the listener wants to share matters more to him than what she's trying to share with him, and leaves her feeling like she isn't getting the attention she deserves.

That said, chances are the bad listener was simply excited to share something that felt relevant, and thought it would make the speaker happy (after all, it's the chocolate she loves) — without realizing that in practice, he was hijacking the conversation for his own needs. Another version of this misstep is guessing the punchline too soon, something like: "What happened, did that woman miss her flight again?"

What the speaker might say instead: An unhelpful response from the speaker to the listener would be something like: "Unbelievable, you never let me finish! You always make it about you." It's a natural reaction, but it attacks the listener personally and creates conflict. Instead of improving the conversation, it's likely to make him feel attacked and turn the moment into a fight.

So what works better? "Hang on, I really want to tell you what happened to Shira first, and then I'd love to hear about the chocolate." This response gently pumps the brakes on the interruption and steers the conversation back on track. It acknowledges the listener's enthusiasm, while making clear that the speaker needs to finish what she was saying.

Come On, You Must Be Exaggerating!

The mechanism: false reassurance, or minimizing through forced positivity.

"I wanted to see the new Joker movie, but everyone says it's terrible — I heard people walked out halfway through," a good friend tells you.

The attuned response: "I get why you're torn — you loved the first one, and a lot of people thought it was great. Then again, I've also heard the reviews on this one are pretty rough." This response validates what the speaker is feeling and shows him that the listener understands his dilemma.

The unlistening response: "No way it's bad. The first Joker was amazing, and the cast is incredible. I'm obsessed with Lady Gaga." The unlistening friend may have thought that voicing a positive opinion would help the speaker feel better, but in practice, it's a response that dismisses his concerns and fails to take what he said seriously. Another version of this shows up when someone voices a worry ("I'm scared I'm going to get fired") and the listener offers false reassurance instead ("I'm sure you're just overreacting, there's no way they'd let go of an employee as good as you").

What the speaker might say instead: A natural but unhelpful response from the speaker would be something like: "You're not even listening to me! I just told you people are walking out halfway through." This attacks the listener and creates conflict. A more effective option is to say something like: "I know you loved the first one, but I'm still a little worried, because I keep hearing bad reviews about this one." This response acknowledges the unlistening friend's point of view, while gently steering the conversation back to what's actually on the speaker's mind.

Listen Up: Five Listening Mistakes You Might Be Making Too - illustration

You Know What You Should Try...

The mechanism: jumping to advice too fast.

"I've been really stressed about work lately, and the school year's about to start, and I have no idea how I'm going to keep up with everything," a close friend tells you.

The attuned response: Good listening sounds like: "That sounds tough — what's stressing you out the most?" A response like that lets the speaker say more about how she's feeling, instead of rushing to wrap up the conversation with a solution. It shows genuine interest in what the speaker is going through and gives her room to vent.

The unlistening response: "You should really try meditation. It works wonders for me." Even though the listener wants to help the speaker and offer something that will ease her load, she's offering a solution before understanding the full picture, which can leave the speaker feeling like her feelings are being brushed off and that she isn't really being heard.

What the speaker might say instead: An unhelpful response from the speaker to the listener could be something like: "You always jump straight to advice, I can't tell you anything." A better response is: "That's good advice, but right now I just need to vent a little. Can we talk about solutions later?"

Wait Till You Hear What Happened to Me...

The mechanism: competing over who's suffered more.

"I'm completely wiped out. I've been up every night this week until 2 a.m. with this never-ending project," a friend tells you.

The attuned response: "That sounds exhausting, no wonder you're so tired." This response stays focused on the experience the speaker is trying to communicate, expressing understanding and support without shifting the conversation to the listener's own experience.

The unlistening response: "If that's hard, what do you say about the fact that I was up 24 hours straight this week when my flight got delayed?!" This response shifts the conversation away from the speaker's experience toward the listener's own, and minimizes the value of what the speaker went through. Even if the listener meant to connect with the speaker by sharing a similar experience, thinking it would show he understood, in practice he's turned it into a suffering contest.

What the speaker might say instead: An ineffective response from the speaker here would be: "Has it ever occurred to you that not everything is about you?!" That kind of response is likely to leave the listener feeling misunderstood and hurt. A better option is to say something like: "Wow, that really does sound intense — but right now I'm genuinely exhausted, and I just wanted to tell you how hard my week has been." This response acknowledges the listener's experience while gently steering the conversation back to the speaker, making clear that what he needs is to be heard and supported, without getting pulled into a contest over who's had it worse.

Wait, What Were You Saying?

The mechanism: tuning out or changing the subject.

"I'm really stressed that I won't get everything ready in time for my mom's 70th birthday. There are so many details," a close friend tells you.

The attuned response: "I'm sorry to hear it's stressing you out — want to tell me what's worrying you most right now?" This response shows the listener is paying attention and ready to offer support.

The unlistening response: More and more often, the listener's unhelpful response is simply silence, because he's busy scrolling on his phone the whole time. And if he isn't silent, he might, after a moment, say something like: "Hey, did you hear about that new place that opened up at the market? Want to check it out?" — without acknowledging anything the speaker just said.

Even though the listener may simply have been distracted, or caught up in his own thoughts, rather than deliberately ignoring the speaker — and certainly didn't mean to hurt her — he's still tuning her out in a way that signals total lack of interest. It leaves her feeling like her feelings don't matter, which can stir up frustration and loneliness.

What the speaker might say instead: An unhelpful response here would be: "You clearly don't care at all about what I'm saying." It's better to say: "I'd really appreciate it if we could talk for a minute about what's bothering me." This response is assertive without being aggressive, and gently brings the listener's attention back to the original subject, without making him feel attacked or criticized — while giving him a chance to correct course and focus on the speaker.

Whenever you're in a conversation and unsure how to respond, there are three simple rules worth keeping in mind: first, listen until the speaker has finished — sometimes just listening is all the other person needs; second, reflect back what you heard, to make sure you understood correctly and to let the speaker feel heard; and finally, ask a question that keeps the conversation going, but one that isn't driven by your own personal agenda — rather, one that stays focused on what the speaker brought to the table.

These three principles will help you become a better listener and create more supportive, meaningful conversations — and I'd bet they'll also boost how often you're having sex.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page