Judgmental? That's Not Listening
Updated: Oct 22
Good listening can help the person talking to us understand themselves and find a way out of difficult situations, but sometimes we take a judgmental approach without even noticing. Second column on the subject
Last week I wrote here about how hard it is for us to truly listen: to listen in the deep, Rogerian way that makes our conversation partner feel safe and protected from judgment, and lets them connect with themselves, understand themselves and find their way out of a tangled situation. This week we'll start with two tips for better listening.
When people are dealing with uncomfortable feelings, they start speaking in generalities. In couples therapy you often see people in distress using sweeping, impersonal phrases like: "There's nothing to be done, in situations like this, people tend to..." or: "Obviously a person who has something like this happen to them will want to..."
As a couples therapist I sometimes get tired of this generalized talk, and if the mood is good I might even tease the speaker a little and ask: "Who would do such a thing, some person or you?" But there are obviously better ways to encourage concreteness. The first tip, recommended by all the emotion-focused approaches, is to turn to the person who has just tried to hide behind the statement "in situations like this people tend to..." and ask them which event they're referring to.
The second tip concerns the fact that we all get lost in the content that preoccupies us. According to the Emotionally Focused approach, our thoughts adapt themselves to our emotional response. So the solution to states of embarrassment or emotional distress won't come from clarifying our thoughts, but from a sensitive sorting through of our feelings. The second piece of advice, then, is to turn the spotlight onto the emotions that arise from what our conversation partner is saying.
Say a friend tells me: "I don't know what to do about my boss. Sometimes I share my ideas with her and she responds wonderfully, and sometimes she's so impatient that I tell myself I'll never try to stick my neck out at the office again." A content-focused response would be something like: "Wow, sounds like your boss is really unstable." An emotion-focused response, on the other hand, would be: "It sounds really unpleasant to approach her and share your ideas, because you never know what to expect."
Another example: your adult son has moved to another city and tells you: "It's so much fun in Berlin. Every evening there's a different show you can go to. There's so much new stuff to discover, it's never boring." A content-focused response would be: "Wow, so Berlin is a real happening place," but an emotion-focused response would sound more like: "It sounds like you're really happy in Berlin."

Those two examples are relatively easy, but what do you think the right response is in the following situation? A friend of yours is getting divorced and is complaining to you about his lawyer. Let's add two more variables: (a) as far as you know, he's an excellent lawyer; (b) your friend is emotionally flooded because of the divorce. Now imagine the friend says to you: "I can't stand how unavailable he is. When I call, they make me wait on the line for hours, and even when we finally talk, he makes me feel like he doesn't have time to hear everything I have to say."
Now read the following responses and think about which of them might be yours:
1. "I'm sure it was a one-off. He probably had a hard day at work. I'm sure if you stick with him, the communication between you will eventually improve."
2. "I totally understand how you feel, I hate waiting on the line too."
3. "You need to understand that your lawyer is very busy. You chose a top-tier lawyer, and that means it's hard for him to make time for you spontaneously."
4. "The lawyer you chose is the best in the country. I'm sure he's treating you professionally and isn't looking down on you."
5. "What's really going on with your accountant? And have you contacted the child psychologist yet?"
6. "What did you want to talk to him about? Tell me, maybe I can help you in his place."
7. "I can understand that you're angry; it's really annoying to wait on the line and then also feel that you're being treated with impatience."
8. "Why don't you just tell him how he makes you feel? And listen, you don't have to stay with him. He's not the only lawyer in the country."
9. "Everyone's like you. No one feels their lawyer gives them all the attention and treatment they deserve."
10. "It sounds to me like you feel something isn't flowing well in your communication with your lawyer, and that you don't feel he cares about you as much as you'd like."
Obviously the right answer is the tenth (that's why it's last...). But what's wrong with the other nine? The main problem is that some of the other answers express judgment, even when we don't mean to. When we make the speaker feel they shouldn't worry, for example, we express a judgmentalism that may limit their self-reflection. Similarly, even when we agree with the speaker we're being judgmental, because it shows that we have a scale by which we rate the speaker's feelings as "right" or "justified."
Another thing is that when we hand out concrete advice, we don't help our friend take responsibility for the unresolved emotional parts he's bringing into the situation, and which he's asking to share with us. General reassurance doesn't do the job either, partly because it's an empty promise. It's a generalization that gives the sense that there's nothing special about your friend's emotional struggle, which is hardly a comforting response, and steering the conversation to related subjects he didn't talk about isn't brilliant either.
That said, hand on heart, how often do we, and sadly that includes me, answer our friends in each of the ways listed here? More often than we're willing to admit. Listening is a great art, and next week I'll continue presenting the nuances of active listening according to Rogers.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com



