Johnny Depp vs. Amber Heard: A Clash of Personality Disorders (Allegedly)
Updated: Oct 22
The new series about Hollywood's defamation trial raises troubling questions about relationships where one partner has narcissistic personality disorder and the other has borderline personality disorder. The manipulation and drama that unfold between such couples have long been a wellspring of material for popular culture
The much-discussed Netflix series covering Johnny Depp's defamation suit against his ex-wife, actress Amber Heard, reflects any number of hot-button social and political issues — but it's also a textbook example of the difficult dynamic that can arise between partners when one has narcissistic personality disorder (NPD) and the other has borderline personality disorder (BPD).
The claim that Heard suffers from borderline personality disorder was already raised during the trial, by a psychologist testifying for Depp's side. But Depp — a narcissist? The beloved, adored, talented, handsome actor, the drinker, the romantic, the man millions around the world rooted for and watched through every twist of his trial? The one who spoke with so much composure and self-control, who wouldn't meet Heard's eyes and smirked charmingly here and there? What's the problem with that?
A couple as old as culture itself
That's exactly the point: the very behaviors that make Depp look so normal next to a "crazy" Heard are themselves hallmarks of narcissistic personality disorder, which could just as easily be attributed to him. And he's hardly alone — the borderline-narcissist pairing has supplied material for popular culture for decades. In "Gone with the Wind," there was the grandiose, empathy-deficient Rhett Butler, desperate for admiration, paired with the impulsive, emotionally unstable Scarlett O'Hara. Their relationship was full of manipulation and conflict long before Heard filmed a stoned Depp with ice cream dripping down his hand.
In "Wuthering Heights," Catherine is swept by turbulent mood swings and prone to intense, unstable behavior in relationships, while Heathcliff is empathy-deficient, manipulative, and full of himself — long before Depp showed up an hour and 40 minutes late to his wife's birthday party. I could go on: Robin and Barney in "How I Met Your Mother," the leads of "Gone Girl," "Game of Thrones," Tom and Daisy in "The Great Gatsby," maybe even Popeye and Olive Oyl. In fact, such relationships don't have to be romantic. One could argue that in "Star Wars," Anakin Skywalker suffers from emotional instability, impulsivity, and severe abandonment anxiety, while Emperor Palpatine is grandiose, manipulative, and lacking in empathy.
These examples help sketch the general contours of the emotional defense patterns that harden into a personality disorder: for people with borderline personality disorder, it's a tendency to frequently experience intense emotions, fear of abandonment, and a longing for closeness. For narcissists, the defenses show up as a sense of entitlement, excessive self-importance, and behavior that lacks empathy for others — which makes them appear (and not only appear) self-absorbed and dismissive of other people's needs.
So what draws them to each other? The mutual attraction feeds, among other things, on the borderline individual's tendency to be drawn to what looks like the narcissist's self-confidence. The borderline woman (the disorder is more common among women) seeks validation and immediate emotional affirmation from the narcissist, while the narcissist, for his part, is drawn to the potential to feel dominant and to be admired by the borderline woman. In Depp and Heard's case, of course, this is amplified by the fact that the narcissist is an extremely famous, extremely successful, charismatic man — both in absolute terms and relative to Heard. In return, he gets to feel adored by a beautiful, younger woman, which only reinforces his sense of success.
As each partner acts to get what they're after — validation and closeness for her, admiration and control for him — the borderline partner may act impulsively to capture the narcissist's attention, while he may manipulate and control her to preserve his self-image and the sense of superiority he needs.
The narcissist's need for admiration can intensify the borderline partner's fear, obsessiveness, or jealousy — she lives with constant anxiety about rejection or abandonment — while the narcissist manufactures that very insecurity in order to supply himself with a steady stream of validation and admiration. When the woman is hurt by her partner's behavior, the intensity of what she feels can drive her toward unstable behavior, outbursts, and manipulative actions. In response, the narcissist may escalate into behavior that amounts to genuine emotional abuse and alienation.
Who keeps better control of themselves in the courtroom
In a courtroom — a proceeding filmed and documented from every angle — the narcissist has a much better chance of controlling his conduct than the borderline partner does. That's because, even though narcissists may display a lack of empathy and grandiosity, they still relate to their own emotions in a more controlled, calculated way, especially when what's at stake is preserving their image. The borderline partner, by contrast, often struggles to regulate her emotions, and her emotional reactions are frequently intense and unpredictable.
The borderline partner's fear of abandonment drives her toward unstable behavior, and she struggles to maintain self-control at difficult moments. From the series, one can infer that Depp and Heard's biggest blowups occurred when she felt him pulling away from her — for instance, when he was late to her birthday party, when he wasn't happy to see her after she came home from a month of filming, and of course when he threatened to leave her. The narcissist, on the other hand, is so intensely focused on his own sense of self-importance and on projecting superiority that he can display self-control even in extreme situations — exactly what we saw at trial.
So, in my view, the conclusion to draw from watching the series is that while Heard resorted to physical violence against Depp, he apparently subjected her to emotional abuse. That conclusion fits the toxic pattern seen in borderline-narcissist couples generally. Throughout the trial we see example after example of Depp's manipulative behavior and his disregard for other people's feelings, Heard's in particular (his refusal to meet her eyes is a striking example). He seems to have been very busy spinning emotional manipulations around Heard in order to control her. Meanwhile, it's clear that Heard's emotional instability led to behavior that spiraled out of control into violence.

Public opinion tends to favor the narcissist
High-profile cases naturally draw extensive media coverage. But the media is easily drawn to the borderline partner's complex symptoms and behaviors, which can look distorted and sensational (and there was no shortage of those at trial). On top of that, in a trial pitting a borderline individual against a narcissist, the narcissist has the advantage, since he's more likely to be skilled at managing his public image and engineering media narratives in his favor. The situation gets worse when the broadcast trial exposes deeply personal details and public criticism exacts a heavy emotional toll on the borderline partner.
Even though the judge barred jurors from exposure to public discussion of the case, it was clear to any observer that the extensive media coverage and social-media commentary were skewed against Heard (for all the reasons I've described so far), and that this could have influenced the jury. In that sense, the public spectacle of the trial was, from the start, likely to do far more damage to Heard, in terms of lasting stigma and impact on her personal and professional life.
In fact, one could argue that in any public display of conflict between a narcissist and a borderline individual, social media and the general public are highly likely to side with the narcissist. That's because such forums prize cool composure and control — so the narcissist's controlled behavior can be perceived as more rational and appealing, earning him greater support. This public bias can be even more pronounced when the narcissist is a man and the borderline individual is a woman, as in the Depp-Heard case.
Traits associated with narcissistic personality disorder — control, assertiveness, self-confidence — line up with traditional masculine stereotypes, while borderline traits like emotional intensity and heightened sensitivity line up with traditional feminine stereotypes.
This alignment between these aspects of the two personality disorders and traditional gender perceptions can sway public opinion in favor of the narcissistic man, perceived as "strong," over the borderline woman, labeled "hysterical."
This unfair bias is, of course, reinforced by the media's existing tendency to portray men as rational and in control and women as emotional and unpredictable. Even in 2023, our social biases still favor a male perspective over a female one, especially in situations of conflict.
Who shatters the symbiosis first
In my experience, more often than not, it's the narcissist who first shatters the couple's symbiosis. At the start of the relationship, he asks for endless admiration, and she asks for closeness. In exchange for that closeness, she's willing to serve as his "perfect mirror," reflecting him back to himself as radiant and flawless, exactly as he dreams of seeing himself. In return, she asks that he stay close and never leave, and that he give her a sense of reality and existence through his presence. To both of them, it looks like the perfect deal.
At some point, the narcissist grows tired of the borderline partner's admiration. She and her admiration become familiar, taken for granted, and no longer prove his superiority over everyone around him. Her admiration is like a luxury car that loses value the moment it touches the road. At this stage, the narcissist starts to pull away from her — whether physically, or simply by distancing himself from her mentally (it seems Depp called Heard extremely ugly names long before her outbursts at him). Sometimes he even cheats on her, in search of an even more perfect mirror.
From her side, his withdrawal cancels the deal between them. Once the deal is off, she becomes, for him, a truly dark mirror — because her very ability to be a perfect mirror rests on the same sensitivities that now let her reflect back all of his bad qualities. From this point on, the borderline partner becomes the narcissist's nightmare, and he moves away from her and out into the world in search of other perfect mirrors.
For people who aren't Johnny Depp, that search can come up empty. In such a scenario, the narcissist crawls back to her. At that point, she's willing to do anything to win back his closeness, and the two find themselves heading for another round. In Johnny Depp's case, of course, that's a different story.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




