top of page

Is Timing Everything in Life? How Synchronization Helps Us, and What Happens When It Breaks Down

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Feb 9, 2023
8 min read

Updated: Oct 22

On the one hand, the ability to synchronize — both biologically and socially — is of critical importance to our survival. On the other, history teaches us that supreme synchronization sometimes characterizes precisely the darkest forces, while it's the people who are out of step with social norms and expectations who push humanity forward

Every Saturday night I go out to a protest. The protests matter to me, they move me, and they impress me too — after all, Israelis have such a hard time organizing themselves as a group. I live in a dense neighborhood in Tel Aviv, and if you try driving through it on a weekend you'll see that ten cars and a hundred pedestrians can't manage to synchronize. So how is it that more than a hundred thousand protesters can do exactly that — without road signs, traffic lights, or any clear rules of behavior?

I found myself thinking about this question of synchronization again last week, while walking my son home from school. It was a very hot day, and a woman of about 50 passed us, dressed in a pink tutu over wool tights. She wore heavy shoes, a short, fancy jacket, her hair was bleached platinum, her skin was very pale, and her lips were painted a deep red. She was talking very animatedly with another woman, and came across as quite a "character" — even by the standards of the regulars at the corner of Allenby and Grozenberg.

"How can you guess that she probably has some kind of psychiatric condition?" I asked my son. He shrugged. "Because she's not coordinated," I said, and explained: the tutu didn't match her age, and if it was a costume, it didn't match the time of year; the formality of the outfit didn't match the context — midweek, noon, a street corner, not Björk at the Oscars — and even her body language didn't match that of the woman she was talking to, or of everyone else on that corner. And that's the point: synchronization is a crucial component of human functioning.

In my last column, I focused on our ability to detect changes in our environment, and the decisive effect that ability has on our level of functioning (the Italian physicist Carlo Rovelli would say this is inherently tied to the fact that there are no "things," only "relationships between things"). This time I want to keep developing that idea and argue that the kind of functioning we need more than anything else, built on our ability to detect change, is our ability to synchronize — both biologically and socially — and that this ability is of critical importance to our survival.

At the level of human biology, synchronization refers to the coordination between various biological processes and rhythms, both within our own body and between us and others. The sleep-wake cycle is of course the most prominent process in this context, but the menstrual cycle is naturally cyclical too, as are more flexible behaviors like eating and physical activity. Synchronization in these senses matters because it helps maintain the body's overall balance, or homeostasis. Disruptions to biological synchronization can lead to health problems like insomnia, depression, and metabolic disorders.

But what's the connection between this kind of synchronization and an individual's ability to be in sync with their social environment? Let's start with the nearly obvious part: disruptions to the sleep-wake cycle can make it harder for a person to be alert, or even present, during social interactions. To succeed at work you first have to get to the office, and even if you work from home, you need to manage to answer emails within a reasonable timeframe, attend meetings, and so on.

But syncing up socially demands far more than simply being present and alert. Human beings may not be the most sociable creatures, but ironically enough, they are extremely social creatures, and the ability to synchronize with others is essential to forming and maintaining relationships. There's plenty of research showing that syncing body language, facial expressions, and vocal rhythms can ease communication and understanding.

On a different note, if we run to fast, rhythmic music, it boosts our physical output more than running while listening to a podcast (pathetic how long it took me to discover that fact). The phrase "the drums of war" is probably as old as humanity itself. And as anyone who has chanted "de-mo-cra-cy" together at a protest knows, synchronizing activities like singing, dancing, and even breathing can help strengthen social bonds.

Music activates us through rhythm. It's our perception of rhythm that lets us synchronize — in dancing, in clapping, in chanting "de-mo-cra-cy." Our ability to synchronize to an external beat is unique to creatures like us, who learn to produce their own sounds by listening to members of their own species — parents, relatives, the tribe, neighbors. In other words, the connection between our auditory system and our motor system is significant to our ability to synchronize, and music is tied to that ancient biological wiring.

In a conversation between Dror Globerman and Prof. Roni Granot on the excellent podcast "One a Day," Globerman used the image "music is the matchmaker." It matches us up. Granot and Globerman touched on the way music has coordinated us since the dawn of humanity, both on a technical level and in terms of the sense of belonging to something larger than any one of us. Synchronization is more than cooperation. Synchronization gives us the feeling that we're together.

Consider the stage of synchronization between parent and infant. Touch, gaze, and sounds affect a baby's development differently depending on whether they're coordinated in time or scattered across it — whether we look into each other's eyes, whether we echo one another's sounds. There are some beautiful studies showing that performing actions in sync with strangers increases the odds of cooperating with them later on.

In other words, our ability to synchronize outward, toward our social environment, matters both for our relationships, in the emotional and social sense, and for our ability to cooperate at various levels of abstraction. And this ability is shaped by the history of our own personal biological development, and can also be affected by the state of our internal synchronization — the synchronization of biological processes within the body.

So which emotional problems can show up as difficulties in physiological synchronization? Insomnia, of course. If we think of insomnia as a mental difficulty in its own right, it's clear that trouble falling asleep or sleeping through the night can disrupt the sleep-wake cycle, which can in turn lead to fatigue, irritability, and trouble concentrating.

Depression is another obvious suspect that can disrupt the body's daily rhythms, causing changes in sleep and appetite patterns, which is also tied to the characteristic drop in the ability to experience pleasure or motivation.

Bipolar disorder, what we used to call manic depression, can disrupt the "daily biological rhythm" and affect sleep patterns. And of course there's schizophrenia, in which a person's entire perception of time becomes distorted. PTSD, with or without dissociation, and attention deficit disorder can also affect a person's ability to focus, pay attention, and keep to a schedule.

Those are disruptions in biological synchronization that can make it harder for a person to be in sync with their social environment. In addition, there are mental health conditions that affect the ability to synchronize socially more directly. People "on the spectrum" often struggle to read social cues, a difficulty that leads to problems syncing up with others.

Schizophrenia, which the woman I saw on the street may have had, affects the ability to synchronize socially in many ways — from difficulty correctly interpreting social cues, to the hallucinations, delusions, and disorganized thinking that sit at the heart of the disorder and affect a patient's ability to communicate and cooperate with others.

Attention deficit disorder and social anxiety disorder can also make it harder for those who suffer from them to synchronize their behavior with others. And it's especially interesting — everyone has their own obsessions — that people with borderline personality disorder, who may struggle with emotional regulation, can also struggle to synchronize their behavior with others. That can serve as another way of looking at their tendency to form intense, unstable relationships, and to experience fear of abandonment and overwhelming emotions. And finally, depression, which is always somehow involved. People with depression may experience a lack of motivation and social isolation, which can make it harder for them to synchronize their behavior with others.

In psychology there's a diagnostic concept called "internal preoccupation," used to describe a person who seems as though "their representatives are busy handling earlier requests." That kind of mental state, in which a person is unavailable to what's happening right in front of them — whether because they're consumed by anxiety or hearing voices — is a striking example of a synchronization problem.

At the same time, synchronization isn't a one-dimensional measure of mental health. With all due respect to protest, we don't want to swing so far to the left that we end up back on the far right. The Nazis were perfectly synchronized, and it's well known that fascist aesthetics in music, sports, marches, film, and graphic design are built on supreme synchronization.

Without people who are out of sync, life would be far worse. Marcel Proust ate dinner at midnight, wrote all night, and slept all day. People who are out of step with the prevailing social norms or expectations are as much a part of the human fabric as anyone, and often turn out to be critical to humanity's progress. They're the ones more likely to question and challenge the status quo, which can lead to innovation and advancement. They're also, very often, the ones who support groups pushed to the margins, which can help promote social justice and equality. In other words, they're the reason the protest exists at all.

Is Timing Everything in Life? How Synchronization Helps Us, and What Happens When It Breaks Down - illustration

Recommendations

Book: Why We Sleep

Anyone who follows my column knows that this book, by Matthew Walker, is the bible on my nightstand. It would take me a while to summarize all its many highlights for you, so I recommend reading it yourselves. (Did you know that dolphins don't dream, because if they did, their bodies would go limp during the dream and they'd drown? Or that the first half of the night is when the brain clears out the debris of the day, while the second half is when it builds new connections for the meaningful things we learned?) Anyone familiar with Walker from his many podcast appearances will be able to picture him reading the book aloud, in that wonderful accent of his.

Meditation: Plum Village — Relax with the Buddha, by Sister Dao Nghiem

It's worth mentioning, every so often, that this free meditation app by the Plum Village monastics exists. Since the passing of their spiritual leader, the monk Thich Nhat Hanh, a great many new, slightly less traditional meditations have been added to their library. This particular one runs just under 20 minutes and is fairly out-there, even by meditation standards — but in a good way. Try it and you'll see what I mean.

Protest: scarves and balloons with the Israeli flag

One of the moving things about this protest movement is the reclaiming of the Israeli flag. On the other hand — not everyone, and not at every age, finds it comfortable to walk around carrying a flag.

The solution I found is ordering scarves and balloons printed with the flag. You can find plenty of options online, at party supply stores, or shops that supply preschools and institutions. It runs about 2.5 shekels a balloon and 18 shekels a scarf. See you Saturday night.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page