In Borderline Personality Disorder, Emotional Reality Sometimes Wins Out Over Factual Truth
Updated: Oct 22
Borderline personality disorder is often characterized by emotional volatility, which can come with impulsive, exaggerated statements far removed from reality. The thing is, people with the disorder often relate to what we call "the truth" in a complex way — one based far more on what they think and feel.
Last week I wrote about the way the series about Johnny Depp's defamation trial against Amber Heard represents a difficult and familiar relationship pattern.
This time I want to focus on how the series illustrates the complicated relationship people with borderline personality disorder have with what's called "the truth." The issue is especially prominent in the series, because in a scenario where a narcissist and a borderline are locked in a public battle, you'd expect someone with borderline personality disorder, like Heard, to be more cautious about the risk of being seen as a liar, and more alert about telling the truth.
Borderline personality disorder is typically characterized by emotional volatility and intense feelings, and so it can come with impulsive, exaggerated statements. We definitely see that in the series. The problem is that the public may perceive these emotional reactions as evidence of dishonesty or manipulation, even when they're sincere emotional expressions.
In other words, people with borderline personality disorder have to work harder to maintain credibility — especially when facing a narcissist who uses his self-control to make them look like liars or irrational. All the more so, as I argued in my previous column, when the person with borderline personality disorder is a woman — meaning she belongs to a gender the media already tends to treat with more skepticism.
In the context of a trial, or of comparing accounts, statements from a person with borderline personality tend to be met with near-constant skepticism, especially compared to the treatment given to the narcissist's version of the same events. That's because the emotional shifts a borderline person goes through can lead her to release inconsistent statements that look suspicious, compared to the narcissist's statements, who is more focused on maintaining control and able to present a more complex picture consistently.
On top of that, borderline personality disorder is often accompanied by memory difficulties, a tendency toward dissociation, and cognitive changes under stress. These can produce inconsistent or fragmented memories that look like lies, especially when compared to the narcissist's memory, which typically isn't challenged in the same way.
I Meant to Pay, So That Must Mean I Paid
Let's take one lie Heard was caught in red-handed, and dig into it to learn something more about the disorder she has: Heard claimed she donated the full amount she received in the divorce settlement from Depp — seven million dollars. In fact, she donated less than two million dollars.
To understand this behavior, you need to know that for people with borderline personality disorder, emotional reality sometimes overrides factual reality. If someone with a borderline disorder feels committed to donating money and genuinely intended to do so, they may perceive that emotional intention as an action that has already been carried out. When someone from the outside points out the inconsistency in their behavior, the borderline person may feel genuinely confused, because they experience their emotional reality as true — as if it were factual reality.
This tendency is amplified by the borderline tendency toward dichotomous thinking — that is, seeing life in absolute black and white. Within this binary way of seeing things, the promise to pay can become equivalent to the payment itself. The fact that others see 50 shades of gray between those two actions is what confuses the person with the disorder.
The tendency toward memory difficulties and "dissociations" under stress can cause someone like this to mistakenly remember their promise to pay as though they'd already actually paid, especially if the promise was made within an intense emotional relationship and during a period of stress.
Borderline impulsivity also makes it harder to maintain consistency between statements and actions, since in a moment of impulse, when the person with the borderline disorder wants to please or meet someone else's needs, they may claim they've paid — but once their mood shifts, they may forget what they said earlier.

Fear of Abandonment and Primitive Reactions
Let's move to the lies that came up during the trial regarding the way Heard allegedly staged Depp's physical violence and covered up her own physical violence. Here it's important to understand that all the cognitive challenges I've described so far intensify when the person with the disorder feels their partner is about to leave them — all the more so when the partner is a narcissist.
The deep fear of abandonment can trigger a desperate, panicked reaction in someone with borderline personality disorder, and lead to childish, "primitive" behaviors in an attempt to prevent that abandonment. These behaviors — which, as in Heard's case, can be crude and certainly inappropriate — will later be denied by the person with the disorder, and that denial will, again, look like lying. But it's important to understand that once the emotional intensity subsides, the person with the disorder may not recognize her own emotional behaviors at all, and may genuinely not remember them, beyond simply being unwilling to admit to them.
Beyond feelings of shame and regret, during emotionally intense events, people with the disorder can experience genuine dissociation. During such a dissociative episode, that person may do things they truly won't be able to remember afterward, or that they'll feel so radically disconnected from that it leads them to deny they happened at all.
If we again factor in the tendency toward dichotomous thinking that paints reality in black or white, we can understand that part of the person's denial of their own borderline aggression can also be tied to their difficulty accepting the complexity of their own personality and psychological state. In other words, by virtue of that same extreme, split view of the world as good and bad, black and white, the person with the disorder may completely reject the aggressive part of themselves — leading them to deny their own behaviors, which, again, makes them look like a liar.
At the end of the day, narcissists may come across as arrogant and full of self-importance, but they're not usually stuck with a reputation as liars — even when they lie through their teeth. In fact, that very brazenness is the trait that distinguishes them from people with borderline personality disorder. Borderline individuals, by contrast, are perceived by those around them as deceptive and manipulative even when they're telling the truth.
What got lost in the trial and in the series is that the lying phenomenon among people with borderline personality disorder doesn't usually reflect a deliberate attempt to deceive — but rather a complex interplay of emotional, cognitive, and relational factors (meaning, factors oriented toward relationships) that characterize this personality disorder.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




