top of page

If I Show My Wife My Vulnerable Side, Won't That Just Invite More Attacks From Her?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 21, 2022
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

My wife is relentlessly aggressive and critical, and it makes me shut down and "disappear." Our couples therapist keeps encouraging me to drop my defenses and show my wife how vulnerable I really am, but I think that will only make things worse. Isn't there another way out of this tangle?

Hi Amalia,

My name is Shlomit and I'm married to a woman. My wife and I have been in couples therapy for six months now and we're getting a lot out of it — but lately I feel like the process has "gotten stuck." As I understand it, my partner is usually the "pursuer" in our relationship. That is, after many sessions, I now understand that what feels to me like endless criticism from her is, from her side, an attempt to get closer to me.

I understand I've fallen into the role of "the avoider," and that the way I protect myself when she's raging — going off to my work corner, burying myself in my phone — feels to her like a harsh punishment and being ignored. I get that, but our therapist believes (like you, I gather) that getting out of the negative loop requires exposing your own vulnerability. She's trying to get me comfortable enough to show my wife the pain her criticism causes me — but I just can't seem to do it. I understand why it matters, but honestly, it doesn't feel logical to me.

In that sense, my wife can be quite violent, in my eyes. She says whatever pops into her head and forgets it instantly, while I carry her harsh words around with me for a long time afterward. I understand that lowering my armor could help my wife lower her own aggression, but who can guarantee that this exposure won't bring on an even crueler attack? Maybe I'm just looking for an excuse not to take the risk? Am I "messed up" for not wanting to get hurt?

If I Show My Wife My Vulnerable Side, Won't That Just Invite More Attacks From Her? - illustration

Dear Shlomit,

It's wonderful to hear from someone who takes their relationship as seriously as you do. You're both in therapy, you're thinking about the therapy, reading about the subject, and even writing to me — well done. I've found that people who take responsibility for their relationship's process greatly increase their chances of actually enjoying that relationship.

You've raised a few good questions here. The first: where does your difficulty being less defensive in the relationship actually come from? Is it a fear you need to overcome, a matter of personality structure, or is your partner really the more problematic side here, causing you to shut down? Your second question is really whether there's another way out of the loop — one that doesn't require exposing your vulnerability to your partner.

First, I think you could raise all of these questions with your own couples therapist. If you're hesitant to bring them up in a joint session, it's usually completely legitimate to ask the therapist (and your partner) for an individual session, just you and the therapist. In a session like that, you could share all of this with her.

I'd ask you to treat my thoughts here as secondary to the feedback you get from your own therapist, and I hope there won't be a contradiction between the two, but rather a productive dialogue. To your first question: how much of your difficulty bringing yourself to be vulnerable in the relationship comes from within you, and how much is a "natural" reaction to your partner's aggression? One way to find out is to ask yourself whether you experience this same difficulty in other relationships too.

Take a look at the significant relationships in your life — friends, colleagues, brothers or sisters (but not your children or your parents, that's a different matter) — and check whether, in those relationships, you've been able to be vulnerable, to share your pain, to ask for help, to signal that you were hurt, without withdrawing or blaming. If that reflection leads you to conclude that this isn't actually a pattern that characterizes you in other relationships, then it's quite possible you're dealing with the rare case where your avoidance really is, to a large degree, a realistic response to your partner's behavior.

I didn't write "rare case" by accident: in my professional experience, it's almost always the case that the very defense style that tangles us up in our romantic relationship is the same defense style that actually rewards us out in the world — in our career, with friends, for example. Someone who's very critical toward their partner will often turn out to be very critical at work too; someone who leans toward avoidance within a relationship will often struggle to "show up" in friendships as well. Try thinking about that honestly. I believe you'll find that the "blame" doesn't rest solely with your partner. As deflating as that might be, it's actually good news overall, because it means there's something you can actually do about it.

That said, even if you discover that you're contributing your own share to the negative dynamic between you and your partner, your other question — is there a way out of the loop that doesn't involve exposing your vulnerability? — is still relevant. To answer it, we first need to clear up something of a semantic "bug." When we talk about "vulnerability," we sometimes narrow the conversation and our own understanding of it. We picture two people showing each other their bleeding wounds. But sometimes it's more useful not to think in terms of "vulnerability" at all, but in terms of "shedding your defenses."

In your case, shutting down, disappearing into your phone or into work matters, is your defense. We tend to imagine that shedding that defense means sharing with your partner the pain her outbursts cause you. But the truth is, your disappearing into yourself doesn't only protect you from hurt and sorrow. There's a good chance it's also protecting you from your own anger at her. And I don't mean the kind of rage she directs at you, but healthy, assertive, connected anger — the kind meant to reset our boundaries, and that almost always ends up improving relationships.

If you're someone who's afraid of confrontation, the move that might actually get the two of you out of this loop could be starting to set a boundary with your wife. If that's really the story here, you're probably quite frightened of doing that. It probably feels to you like if you tell her you're not willing to keep being treated with this kind of aggression, spoken to in that harsh tone, and so on, she'll just escalate even further. But in many cases, the opposite turns out to be true.

If she's a classic pursuing partner, then the simple fact that you stop running from her, stay present in the situation, and say how you see things, can actually have a calming effect on her. Most avoidant people are sensitive to criticism. You may well be too, which might make it hard for you to imagine her responding well to being criticized. But she's built differently than you are. On the face of it, it looks like she's far more sensitive to the distance you keep from her than to your opinion of her.

My recommendation is not to give up hope. You can step out of your avoidance, and help stop the escalation between you, not only by exposing vulnerability in the classic sense of sharing your pain, but also by setting a loving boundary with your partner. Wishing you both the best of luck.

Recommendations

Meditation: "Mindfulness of Feelings," by Brother Phap Linh

One app I keep coming back to in my own meditation practice is Plum Village, from the tradition of Thich Nhat Hanh, who passed away not long ago. The free app gathers together many guided meditations, most of them excellent in my view, in a range of lengths — and this particular one is something I find myself returning to often.

Family: Make Summer Rolls With the Kids

Making Vietnamese rice-paper rolls is a fun activity you can do together with kids of any age. The internet is full of recipes, and the principle is always the same: prepare an assortment of ingredients — round lettuce leaves, cucumber strips, carrot strips, mint and cilantro leaves, and so on — so everyone can build their own roll to their own taste. You also make a sauce, or a few different sauces, to dip the rolls in afterward. Cool, vegetarian, not especially messy, and not fattening. As Americans say, what's not to like?

Movie: Minions: The Rise of Gru

If you haven't seen the new Minions movie yet, you don't really need to go dressed in a tuxedo and evening gown, but you really, really should go. The Minions are a model of psychological health. When they're threatened, they work to find shelter until the threat passes; when someone violates their boundaries, they get angry and act to restore justice; when they're sad, they break down and turn to others for help; and when they're happy, they're filled with the urge to share their good fortune with the world. The fact that they're idiots who speak an incoherent language, and yet still manage to communicate wonderfully and effectively with each other, with the reality of the film, and with the audience, beautifully illustrates the power of healthy emotional processing.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page