"I Thought That's What You Wanted Too": The Sweet Method of Narcissism
Updated: Oct 22
What happens when good intentions mask a mechanism for erasing the other person, why it shows up precisely in gestures of kindness — and what role do we play in a dynamic where we end up as extras in someone else's movie?
Three moments, one trap. The first happened at the height of the COVID period. A friend of friends was supposed to come with them to dinner at my place. I had an iron rule: guests take a home antigen test right before arriving. I asked him to do it, and he agreed. The dinner was a success (how naive we were, back in 2019) — but later that same night he sent a message: he'd tested positive. Stunned, I called him. "Did you test right before you left?" He admitted he hadn't. I was in shock — but not as much as he was. He was truly in shock.
Since he was a psychiatrist who worked at a hospital, he made a point of getting tested there every time he came in, and indeed, he'd been tested at the hospital lab the day before. As he saw it, his professional protocol was far more reliable than the home tests I was relying on. Our back-and-forth went on for a while, because it took me time to understand that, from his point of view, he hadn't lied at all. On the contrary — he'd done me a favor by overriding my rule with a better one. The fact that his rule had failed was an unfortunate accident. The fact that he'd told me something untrue was a minor detail I was fixating on because I couldn't see the bigger picture.
The second moment also happened years ago, during a therapy session. A highly talented patient told me, during a session, about having appeared on television programs (back when TV still had cultural programming). A few days after our session, he sent me a link to the hour-long program devoted to him and his work. The link arrived with no accompanying words — it just landed on my phone as is, the way a link to an interesting article might arrive from a close friend who knows exactly what will make you laugh or catch your interest.
In our next session we talked about all sorts of things, and I could see him circling the subject. Finally he asked, genuinely puzzled, whether I truly hadn't watched the full hour on my own time. I answered that I'd been waiting to discuss it in session, so I could understand why he'd sent me the link — whether there was a specific moment in the interview he wanted us to share — and other questions meant to help connect him to his own inner world. But he had real trouble answering them.
What do you mean, why did he send me the link — he genuinely struggled to understand the question, because it hadn't occurred to him that, for me, watching a video falls under the category of "work" rather than "leisure." "I thought it would interest you, as Amalia," he said — and then corrected himself: "I think it should interest you" — and explained that in the interview he talks about important, very interesting things.
The third moment happened after I ran into an acquaintance on the boulevard. I remarked that she looked radiant, and she told me her daughter had just gotten married. A few moments after I continued on my way, I got a WhatsApp message from her that read: "If you'd like to see the video from the wedding canopy, I can send it to you." It was a strange linguistic trap. Why didn't she write, "I'm so proud — mind if I send you the video?" Why did she frame her own need for validation as a favor she was doing for me? I sent her a heart emoji in reply.
It's important to say up front: these situations, in small doses, are familiar to all of us from everyday life. We all sometimes fall into self-centeredness, excessive self-confidence, or a momentary difficulty seeing past our own needs — and none of that indicates a diagnosable mental disorder. So the cases I've described apply to narcissistic personality only when they fit a pattern of similar events, occurring with high frequency — when the incidents described aren't just an isolated "bad day" or a random lapse in tact, but a window into a deeper personality organization. What makes them interesting is precisely that they illuminate the narcissistic mechanism not in its explosive, violent moments, but as a quiet, rigid existential default setting.
Under the Sign of Gemini
What connects these three moments? At first glance, they look like raw material for episodes of Seinfeld: social misunderstandings, communication mishaps, or just the behavior of tactless people. But from my perspective, they're interesting because they illuminate, from a fundamental — and perhaps even tragic — angle, the organization of the narcissistic personality.
We're used to thinking about narcissistic defense mechanisms through the damage they can cause, and seen through that lens, narcissists indeed look like malicious, manipulative, or cold figures. That's why it's easy for us to identify the disorder when what announces it is dismissive behavior or blatant self-aggrandizement.
But these cases show us what's happening under the hood when a person with narcissistic traits is in a relatively neutral state — one where he isn't threatened by competition or direct humiliation, but feels safe enough to try, in his clumsy way, to get closer: my friend's friend wanted to come to my dinner without exposing me to the coronavirus (by his own logic); the patient wanted to share a moment of pride with me; the acquaintance wanted to share her joy. They weren't trying to cause harm — they were trying to do good.
But the paradox is that in extreme cases like these three, even in moments of kindness, the other person doesn't exist as an "other." Beneath the surface of these "good" gestures operates a deep and rigid psychological mechanism known as "narcissistic twinship." In this state, the person facing you doesn't perceive you as a separate person, with your own consciousness, history, and desires — as someone with an independent, differently situated center of experience. As far as he's concerned, if he thinks something, you think it too.
Precisely because he has categorized you, in his mind, in the most flattering way possible — as a smart, good person — there's no reason you'd believe or want anything "less good." If he feels safe in certain circumstances, he assumes you feel safe too. Like rooms in an airport hotel, your inner world is perceived as an exact copy of his — and he's sure he knows exactly where the minibar is and what you'll find inside it. So there's no need to ask your opinion. Your opinion, as far as he's concerned, is his opinion.

The Response: A Bug in the System
In this kind of mental state, when another person behaves in a way that contradicts these assumptions, it isn't simply a legitimate disagreement between two different people — it's an event that looks much more like betrayal or negligence. Their reaction usually falls somewhere between: you're stupid or ignorant (because you don't see the obvious truth); you're hostile (because you're deliberately refusing to agree, just to hurt them); or you're not who they thought you were, because your true face has been exposed as a traitor and an enemy — that is, a real threat to their sense of self and their inner cohesion.
If we go back to the cases described earlier and examine them through this lens, a different dynamic comes into focus. The psychiatrist who came to dinner without testing wasn't trying to infect me. Because he felt his protocol was safer than mine, he automatically assumed I'd understand that he'd made the right call.
When I insisted on my own protocol, he didn't see it as a legitimate boundary, but as a "bug" in the system. When he ignored my request, he wasn't violating my consent — he was "correcting" my reality with his superior logic. When I expressed anger, he didn't feel guilt, only bewilderment that I was too "foolish" to understand that his hospital test was better.
For the patient who sent his video, there's no difference between his pride and my free time. When I didn't watch it, he didn't think, "maybe she's busy" — he thought I must be doing it out of spite. As far as he was concerned, my autonomy was experienced as a hostile refusal to play my part in our shared existence.
The acquaintance on the boulevard couldn't manage to ask, "Can I send you the video?" — because that question would acknowledge that I'm a separate person who might say "no." By hinting that I should be the one to ask her for the video, she was, in her own way, doing me a favor — since to her mind, the more logical thing for me to do was to ask to see the video, rather than have her offer it outright.
Recognizing that all of us sometimes move along the axis between empathy and narcissism is critical, because it lets us understand why we get drawn into these dynamics in the first place. We aren't passive victims of some diagnosed "monster," but human beings who sometimes find, within that very erasure of boundaries, an answer to our own unmet needs.
The difference between everyday human behavior and the pathology in question lies in the rigidity of the mechanism: while an ordinary person is usually able to snap out of it, recognize the other person's separateness, and apologize, that isn't the case for someone whose assumption of "narcissistic twinship" means the other's stepping out of character is always experienced as an existential threat or a betrayal, rather than an invitation to dialogue.
A Two-Way Tunnel
Before I finish, I want to turn the mirror on ourselves for a moment, and ask whether we only recognize "narcissistic twinship" as a discordant note and a pathological problem once we stop being interested in what the narcissist has to offer us. It's well known that in the early stages of a relationship with someone who has these kinds of defenses, the dynamic can feel like a miracle.
Very often there's a striking match between what the narcissist offers and our own hidden unmet needs. It's a tunnel being dug from both sides at once. On the narcissistic side, in an effort to "conquer" us and make us part of his own self, the narcissist runs a quick, intuitive scan of our desires. If he's hungry enough for our attention, he'll spare no effort in manufacturing the illusion of a cosmic match.
But the tunnel is also dug from the other side — the more denied side — namely, our own active participation in this conspiracy. Often the narcissist's traits seem so "dazzling" to us — the sweeping charisma, the outsized self-confidence, the outward success or audacity — that we long to be part of them. We want to merge with this larger-than-life figure, so that some of the shine will rub off on us too, or because under their protection we feel safe.
In those moments, we work hard to convince ourselves that what he wants is exactly what we want. We silence the small inner voice that says, "this isn't quite me," because the cost of silencing it feels negligible next to the enormous payoff of belonging and grandeur.
So the erasure of boundaries doesn't feel like a violent invasion. On the contrary — it feels like romance at its best, or like a rare "soul connection." We wake up from this dream with a jolt only once the evidence starts piling up that he's consistently unable to give us something we need.
Only then do we understand that we didn't find a twin soul who saw deep into ours. In fact, the person never saw us at all. We volunteered for auditions and were successfully cast as extras in someone else's movie. When we dared to step out of character, the director raged — but if this happens within a long-term relationship that wasn't forced on us the way family ties are, then we too bear some part of the responsibility for finding ourselves in that moment.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




