top of page

How to Stop an Argument With Someone Who Has a Personality Disorder

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jun 27, 2024
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

A conversation with someone who has borderline personality disorder or narcissistic traits can easily escalate into a fierce argument — or even spiral into violence. Here's a simple formula to help you manage the tangled situation without getting pulled into manipulation, while holding onto your boundaries, your sanity, and your composure.

Seven years before my mother died, I stopped talking to her while driving. My mother had borderline personality disorder with narcissistic traits, and — as is almost always the case in these situations — all of us suffered right along with her. The core message running through most of our conversations was that her life was unbearable, and that the main reason for that was that my brother and I weren't taking proper care of her.

The moment I stopped talking to her while driving happened on my way to a workshop at the Interdisciplinary Center in Herzliya, when the call escalated into screaming so intense that I nearly got into a car accident.

Two years later, after yet another extreme blowup on the phone, I blocked her number. I still called her a few times a week, and we still saw each other, but she could no longer call me. A few months after I blocked her, she mentioned in one of our conversations that we were going through a good stretch in our relationship. She was right. Once I'd removed her ability to ambush me emotionally, and could prepare myself mentally before every call, the risk of any single conversation knocking me off balance dropped dramatically.

Talking to Someone Who Isn't Listening

Talking with someone who has narcissistic personality disorder (NPD) or borderline personality disorder (BPD) poses unique challenges. In both cases, you're talking to someone trapped inside an intense emotional experience through which they see, hear, and react to everything — which leaves them little room to actually hear the message you're trying to convey.

Narcissists often need admiration and are highly sensitive to criticism, so the moment you try to convey something they perceive as negative, it can very quickly turn into conflict. If you've ever tried to level blunt criticism at someone with a disorder like this, you know how quickly their narcissistic defenses harden, and what kind of emotional drones can come flying back at you. Someone with borderline personality disorder suffers from a terrible fear of abandonment and tends toward intense emotional volatility, which means even a casual conversation can turn explosive and escalate into a fierce argument the moment they feel misunderstood or rejected.

One of the most common mistakes in communicating with people like this — who belong to what's known as Cluster B personality disorders — is failing to validate their feelings. It's an understandable avoidance; after all, these types already take up so much space, and there's no appetite to make even more room for them. On top of that, there's a fear that validating their feelings will put us on a slippery slope toward surrendering to their version of reality and agreeing with the solutions they propose.

Another mistake is trying to convince them to recognize their own flawed thought patterns. That's because it's hard to do so without making the narcissist feel judged or the borderline feel rejected — not to mention how hard it is to stand up to irrational thinking on important matters without risking getting swept up in the emotional whirlwind ourselves. What's more, losing our own composure and stability during a conversation like this can trigger even more intense reactions, and — God forbid — actually lead to accidents or violent outbursts. Understanding this dynamic is therefore essential for navigating these discussions effectively, in a way that minimizes the chance of escalation.

There's a Formula for Containing the Escalation

Over the years — and after many years of my own therapy — I've distilled a formula, for myself and for some of my clients, for containing the breakdown of a dialogue with a narcissist or a "borderline."

Here are a few examples:

  • "It makes me really sad that, even though I'm doing my best, you still feel rejected."

  • "It really scares me that, even though I'm doing my best, you're still so angry."

  • "It really wears me out that, even though I'm doing my best, you still feel disappointed."

  • "It really hurts me that, even though I'm doing my best, you still feel offended."

In other words, the formula is: "It makes me very [negative emotion the speaker authentically feels], that even though I'm doing my best, you still feel [negative emotion the recipient authentically feels]."

As you can see, it breaks down into three parts: the first — what the speaker feels, and the last — what the recipient feels — both allow for some flexibility, while the middle part, stating that the speaker is already doing their best, is a fixed pillar that cannot be moved.

How to Stop an Argument With Someone Who Has a Personality Disorder - illustration

Why Does This Formula Work?

It calms the escalation. Announcing our authentic feelings at the start of the sentence signals a shift away from an argument in which facts and accusations are hurled back and forth, toward sharing feelings. Moving away from accusatory, confrontational language can have a calming effect. Focusing on feelings rather than blame is essential when speaking with someone upset who is prone to confrontation.

It makes the speaker's subjectivity present. As noted, people in Cluster B often struggle to remember that the person in front of them has a center of experience distinct from their own, rather than being an object meant to meet their needs. Placing our emotional experience at the start of the sentence anchors this elusive fact as a given, both for us and for the other person.

It sets a boundary. The statement "I'm doing my best" is critical in situations where the person you're dealing with confuses communication with an opportunity to keep negotiating toward their own goals. Often, people with these kinds of difficulties can wear us down to the point that we stop communicating with them altogether — storming out of the room, hanging up the phone, blocking their number, or switching to communicating through a third party.

Sometimes that's fine, but often, even when it's the reasonable move, it leaves us with the feeling that we acted with excessive force. It's not fair to be left with that aftertaste. By contrast, the statement "I'm doing my best" opens up the possibility of staying present with the other person while making clear that, as far as we're concerned, we're already giving our maximum — and that continuing the conversation isn't likely to yield any bigger "battlefield" gains for the other side. This statement can bring the confrontation to a different kind of ending, one in which the other side loses momentum, without our having had to use force.

The formula also validates the other person's feelings: by acknowledging the feelings of the person in front of us, we validate their experience. People with Cluster B personality disorders often feel misunderstood and fear being dismissed. The "borderline" truly feels abandoned; the narcissist truly feels humiliated. Recognizing their feelings is critical, and it demonstrates that we are attentive and empathetic. That's why it's especially important to phrase the description of their feelings sincerely and authentically within the formula, rather than sarcastically smuggling in criticism.

How Does It Work With Borderline Personality?

In the case of people with borderline personality disorder (BPD), this formula is especially effective because it addresses the following difficulties:

  • Fear of abandonment. People with BPD often have an intense fear of real or imagined abandonment and rejection. When we express our own feelings and acknowledge theirs, instead of leaving the room or the relationship, we demonstrate commitment and show that we remain present within the relationship. Communicating with them clearly in this way sends the message that we're here with them and that the relationship still stands, which can help ease their fear of abandonment somewhat.

  • Emotional sensitivity. People with BPD are typically highly attuned to emotional cues and experience feelings with great intensity. When we validate their feelings, they may feel that we're taking their emotions seriously and at least trying to understand their point of view — which is preferable, for them, to the chronic feeling of being ignored and not understood.

  • Impulsivity and a tendency toward escalation. Conversations with someone who has BPD can escalate quickly because of their impulsivity and difficulty regulating emotion. When we let go of the preoccupation with blame and criticism, we can help them stay at a manageable emotional level.

  • Splitting. These individuals often tend to see things in black-and-white terms, where, for them, everything is either all good or all bad. By maintaining a balanced approach that acknowledges both sides' feelings, we can help moderate this tendency, at least in that moment.

How to Talk to Narcissists

In the case of people with narcissistic personality disorder (NPD), using a structured approach that acknowledges both your feelings and theirs can be especially effective, given the following features of their disorder:

  • Need for admiration. People with NPD often have a deep need for admiration and validation from others. By expressing our feelings honestly but sensitively, we speak to them while also acknowledging their importance to us within the interaction, which can partially satisfy their need for attention.

  • Sensitivity to criticism. People with NPD are typically highly sensitive to criticism and may react negatively if they feel undervalued or attacked. By focusing on expressing our own feelings and carefully acknowledging theirs, without direct criticism, we stand a better chance of avoiding triggering defensive or aggressive reactions. Focusing on emotional impact rather than blame can prevent escalation.

  • Egocentric perspective. Narcissistic people often see situations primarily from their own point of view. Explicitly acknowledging their feelings alongside your own helps balance out this perspective somewhat.

  • Manipulation and exploitation. People with NPD may sometimes manipulate or exploit situations to their advantage. By clearly expressing how their actions make us feel, we set boundaries and communicate the emotional consequences of their behavior. Clarifying the emotional costs can serve as a gentle warning about the impact their behavior has on the relationship.

Even without any illusions that a statement like this will encourage the other person to reflect deeply on their feelings and open the door to discussing solutions, I promise you it's worth memorizing this formula by heart, and finding versions of it that roll comfortably off your tongue — because it's remarkably effective at preventing escalation with those difficult types in our lives whom we nonetheless want to remain in as good a relationship with as possible.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page