How to Listen Like a Psychologist
Updated: Oct 22
Much emotional distress isn't eased by advice but by emotional connection, and that is something you can learn to offer. Third in a series
In my previous column I proposed a thought experiment. Imagine a friend of yours is going through a divorce and comes to you complaining about his lawyer. Let's add two details to the picture: first, as far as you know, he is an excellent lawyer; second, your friend is emotionally overwhelmed by the divorce. Now imagine the friend says: "I can't stand how unavailable he is. When I call, they keep me on hold for hours, and even when we finally talk, he makes me feel he doesn't have time to hear everything I have to say." The question I put to readers was: "Hand on heart, what would you say to a friend in this situation?"
In the film "Avengers: Endgame," Doctor Strange explains that out of 14 million possible scenarios, there is only one in which the Avengers defeat Thanos. Borrowing the idea, though with much smaller numbers, I want to show why so many of our typical responses (mine too, mine too) fall short.
Response #1: "I'm sure it was a one-off. He probably had a hard day at work. If you stick with him, the communication between you will improve in the end."
Why isn't it good? Because false reassurance is still false reassurance. We have no idea whether what we're promising will come true, but we don't admit it. Our intentions are good, and because of them all we end up doing is trying to change the emotional state of the friend who is talking to us, while signaling that we have no patience for what they're feeling. Sometimes, by the way, we respond this way precisely because we are anxious ourselves, and find it hard to feel the other person's worry and helplessness.
Response #2: "I totally understand how you feel, I hate being kept on hold too." Or: "You have to understand that your lawyer is very busy. You chose a top-tier lawyer, and that means it's hard for him to free up time for you spontaneously." Or: "The lawyer you chose is the best in the country. I'm sure he's treating you professionally and isn't being dismissive." Or: "I can understand why you're angry. It's really annoying to wait on the line and then feel that you're being treated with impatience."
Why isn't it good? Because when we tell a friend that, in our view, he shouldn't be worried, we are passing judgment on his worry. In that sense, these responses show that we are measuring what the friend says against our own scale of values. The difference between thinking that the speaker's emotional reaction is unjustified and thinking that it is justified is entirely arbitrary.
Response #3: "So what's actually going on with your accountant? And have you contacted the child psychologist yet?"
Why isn't it good? Because we're changing the subject. There is no better proof that we're not interested in listening to the speaker, that we're struggling to concentrate on him and on the conversation, and that we care more about our own train of thought than about what he is saying.

Response #4: "What did you want to talk to him about? Tell me, maybe I can help you in his place."
Why isn't it good? The speaker tried to share an emotional state with us, and we zeroed in on the plot of what he said. Another problem is that we feed his expectation that if enough information is gathered, a solution will be found. That's the right line of thinking if you want to get rid of a cockroach infestation in the stairwell, but emotional worries of the kind we're discussing here are often not solved by gathering information. On the contrary, if we respond to a friend's emotional concern by trying to collect more information, we signal to him that if he wants to express his feelings and is asking us to lend a listening ear, well, we're not the address for that.
Response #5: "Why don't you just tell him how he makes you feel? And listen, you don't have to stay with him. He's not the only lawyer in the country."
Why isn't it good? Because the best solution to emotional problems lies within the speaker himself. When we hand him advice, we actually make it harder for him to listen to himself. Even if our advice is reasonable (after all, we're neither idiots nor villains), his reliance on us to cope with his problems weakens him. Now he is not only dependent on his lawyer, he is dependent on us as well. And what would he do without gifted, experienced friends like us?
Response #6: "Everyone's like you. No one feels their lawyer gives them all the attention and consideration they deserve."
Why isn't it good? It's true that this response has something normalizing about it (everyone's like you), but it can also be hasty. There's a good chance that we don't quite understand what our friend is talking about, yet we've already decided that we do. And that understanding is so firmly settled that we no longer need to listen to him. Along the way, we're telling him not to make such a big deal of it.
Now consider the last response, in contrast to all of these: "It sounds to me like you feel something isn't flowing well in your communication with your lawyer, and that you don't feel he cares about you as much as you'd like."
Why is it good? Of all the options I've described, this is the only response that shows we truly understand the root of our friend's concern. It is also the only one that conveys to the friend that we understand him, genuinely and sincerely, without judging his feelings or declaring them justified or unjustified. Will it help? In my experience, in emotional situations like the one in this example, a certain level of low mood and worry is natural and to be expected. In such cases, if we can make our friends feel that we are "there for them," that we care and that we are listening, that emotional connection will do them more good than any advice.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com



