top of page

How Getting to Know Our Brain Can Improve Our Relationship

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 8, 2021
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

The way we experience reality is shaped by our personal context, which is necessarily different from our partner's. Understanding this can help us live more within our relationship, instead of in the shadow of the past

In couples therapy, the therapist can often feel like an arbitrator. The request to rule on which side the truth lies with usually isn't about moral questions but, in fact, about factual ones. Partners are asking for confirmation of their perception of reality. Is it true that she just spoke angrily? Did I also just hear the husband threaten to leave?

The answer is almost always: yes and no. The reason is that this is about the perception of reality. And reality isn't caught the way fish are caught in a net, miserable, whole, and regardless of the fisherman's expectations and forecasts. In many respects, our perception is a rolling event governed by the principles of Bayesian inference (named after Thomas Bayes). This is a method of statistical inference, widely used to analyze how a formula used to generate predictions gets updated when the information is dynamically updated.

Despite the fancy name, this is a highly intuitive idea when it comes to psychological perception, and certainly to the process of decoding emotions in interpersonal interaction. The basic idea is that we have a certain prediction about what our senses are picking up, and new evidence in the field is used to update the initial hypothesis. The updated hypothesis about the present situation can serve as the basis for our prediction about the future.

Imagine, for example, that we're approaching our home and see a police car parked on the sidewalk in front of the entrance. The first time we come across this sight, we might get frightened and assume that a crime has taken place in our building. But if we walk into the building and see that a new tenant has moved into one of the apartments, and he introduces himself as a police officer, our hypothesis about the crime will be updated. At some point, after we get used to seeing the new tenant's patrol car near the house, the sight of a police car on the sidewalk in front of our home will no longer frighten us instinctively, and will not raise the hypothesis that something criminal happened. The updated hypothesis will be that the neighbor is home.

I use this example hesitantly. It does illustrate the process of updating a prediction, but it is also misleading about the place and role of conscious interpretation in our perception. So it's important to me to stress that to understand the gap that opens up between us and our partner in perceiving reality, we need to understand that the police car is an example of a slow event, one that unfolds gradually in reality and allows conscious correction of our predictions. Interpersonal emotional communication, by contrast, happens at astonishing speed, and in the vast majority of cases and stages we are entirely unaware that our brain is seeing what it predicts it will see, and that these predictions are shaped to a large degree by our life experience up to that moment, and not only by the objective information reaching our senses at that moment.

Many examples of sensory illusions, the kind that break the internet, demonstrate this. In early June, millions of web users listened to an unclear audio clip. While the clip played, they could read one of nine different sentences, such as "Rotating pirate ship" or "That is embarrassing”. To listen to and watch the clip:

How Getting to Know Our Brain Can Improve Our Relationship - illustration

What made this clip go viral is that for most people, the sentence they read at that moment dramatically affected how their brain perceived the audio they were played. What had been an unclear mix of sound signals became, in their brains, a clear message, once visual or textual information was added to it.

All of this is of course highly relevant to your fight with your partner over how he told your child to clear the table, and it surfaces in that moment in the clinic when you point at your partner and ask the therapist, "Right, she raised her voice just now?!" That's because the "rotating pirate ship" example shows us how something can be two different things. If my brain can hear "rotating pirate ship" in one context, and the moment the context shifts slightly, the brain can hear the words "that is embarrassing" in exactly the same combination of sounds, then surely my brain and another person's brain can hear something different in the same combination of sounds. All it takes to grasp this is to remember that the context in which I experience reality is always different from the full context in which the other person experiences reality.

In the case of the audio illusion, it's easy to put our finger on the difference in context: the sentence we're reading. But differences in context like this exist all the time, because context is built on our life experience so far. And our life experience so far is radically different from our partner's. Not only that, but our life experience isn't tagged in the brain and consolidated into predictions in a way that gives greater weight to the most recent events. Instead, when the brain generates its predictions, it gives greater weight to the predictions that have come true the most times (and that's without even considering the possibility that the brain over-weights predictions that came true early in its existence, because, like any system, the brain is more easily influenced at the start of its formation).

Let's take that into account now and return to our example from the opening. If I grew up with a mother for whom every raised voice meant she was angry with me and that I would soon be punished, then the moment the volume of my partner's voice goes up, my brain instantly synthesizes this sensory information together with the predictions that have proven themselves the most times, and produces the following output: the woman in front of you is angry. This output is not experienced as an interpretation. The feeling "she's angry" is not an interpretation in two different senses, which partly overlap: 1. The feeling is immediate; that is, phenomenologically it is not a serial experience in which first the voice signals are picked up, then the signal is measured against a vast database in my brain, and then the result comes in: she's angry. 2. The feeling is one of "fact" and not of interpretation.

To understand this, think for example about what happens in our brain when we walk past a bakery and smell a burekas or another savory pastry. The perception that arises in us is: "Yum, burekas." That is, our brain knows with certainty that it's a savory pastry. But how does it know that? After all, it was exposed only to smell signals. We didn't put anything in our mouth. In practice, the information that reached our brain came only through the nose. And yet the experience is a certain feeling that this is a savory pastry. The reason is that enough times in the past, every time we tasted a pastry with that specific smell, it also had a savory taste. Those neurons got used to firing together. Now, once the smell neurons kick in, enough of the taste neurons kick in too. A sufficient measure of this combined activity occurs in our brain to produce the output: yum, savory pastry.

With the same speed and naturalness, when my partner raises her voice, my brain can produce the output: she's angry at me. The possibility that perhaps she isn't angry, but afraid or hurt, gets no representation in the initial prediction of my thrifty brain, just as there is no representation in my sensory perception for the possibility that the smell of the burekas comes from a food that tastes like sushi. Theoretically that might happen, but the brain is lazy, and it doesn't allocate much real estate to predictions that haven't proven themselves useful.

How do we get out of this? We return to the process of Bayesian updating. In therapy, we feed the brain new information through several channels: first, we begin to understand intellectually that there is a gap between our experience and the events taking place in reality, and that the difference between our experience and our partner's experience is not a "New Age" matter of honoring each person's experience, but a biological fact. Second, and more important, we work to create new experiences that allow the brain to update its predictions, so that in the future a person can hear their partner raise her voice and immediately sense her distress, and respond accordingly.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page