How Do You Express Empathy Toward a Client Who Wants to Die?
Updated: Oct 22
Expressing empathy relates to the emotional state a person is in and the way they see the world. At the same time, it does not validate faulty reality testing or a problematic way of coping.
Last week I devoted the column to the thinking of the American psychologist Carl Rogers, who held that unconditional positive regard from the therapist toward clients is the basis of change in psychotherapy. Rogers believed that part of our difficulty in expressing empathy lies in the fact that real empathy can lead us to change, and that is something that scares all of us. I'm sure that's part of the reason, but in my experience working with couples who struggle to express empathy to one another, there's another central reason: we confuse expressing empathy toward our conversation partner's emotional state, which is based on a willingness to understand how things (the difficulties in their life) look from their point of view, with validating their worldview and the way they're trying to cope with those difficulties.
Two cases come to mind as I try to sharpen this point. Rani (a pseudonym) suffered from obsessive jealousy toward his girlfriend. During one of his jealous attacks he grabbed her phone while she was in the shower and rummaged through her messages. It was one of the first times that I simply could not express empathy to a client. Emotion-focused couples therapy (EFT) is largely based on Rogers' principle of empathy, and still I sat there mute. All I wanted was to scold Rani and confront him. He was a huge guy and his girlfriend was tiny, he was the son of wealthy people and she had no socioeconomic resources: what was he thinking? In my head it begins with snooping through a phone and ends with a murder in the family. I wasn't capable of being empathic. But I knew that was what I was supposed to do, so I just stammered something.
I waited eagerly for my supervision. My supervisor, the legendary Rita Ventura, a Greek therapist (there were no EFT supervisors in Israel then), who had been a Rogerian supervisor for 17 years before she heard about EFT, showed me the way. Rita made clear to me the difference between empathy for the situation a person has landed in, from their point of view, and validating their picture of the world and their way of coping. In the next session, when we went back to talking about the phone, I was able to say to Rani: I hear that at that moment you were gripped by enormous anxiety, you thought she didn't love you, and it seemed to you that her behavior hinted that she was hiding things from you. You felt so weak, and so ashamed to admit it to her, that it seemed you had no choice but to put an end to this torture and grab her phone, even though this violent act hurts her very much, and you too.
It wasn't hard for me to do it. Once I got the point, I understood the liberation in it. All in all, I truly can understand that if a person feels they're about to be abandoned, and feels helpless, and is certain they're about to experience great pain, then at that moment they may believe that only a certain behavior will prevent the pain. All that this statement contains is agreement to stand in Rani's shoes, and to understand why, from his point of view, there's a logic to this sequence of mental and emotional events. It doesn't validate that the fear he felt in the relationship also reflected the degree of danger posed to him by his girlfriend. What's more, this structure of empathic expression also allowed me to preserve my own outside perspective on his behavior, which was dangerous and unacceptable.

That session was a turning point. Rani cried, he connected with his vulnerability, and was able to reveal to me and to his girlfriend (later his wife) that his jealousy toward her actually sat on top of a fear of karma, a fear that he deserved punishment because of a violent act he'd been involved in as a child. The behavior did not recur, and I'm sure all of this happened much faster than if I had scolded him. I might have stirred up guilt in him, which would have suppressed the controlling behavior, but suppression like that wouldn't have helped over time. That's because Rani's bullying behavior, though it created significant problems for him and for others, was not itself the problem. The macho behavior was an unproductive coping mechanism. The critical point was to examine what he was trying to cope with through this behavior. And that could only be discovered through empathy.
I learned an equally important lesson with Dana (a pseudonym), the first client I met who spoke about wanting to die and about the pointlessness of her life. Dana sat in faded, worn clothes, hunched over and pale. Her partner sat silent and impenetrable, and I sat across from them terrified. At that moment I used everything I could: a suicide risk assessment, agreements about staying in contact, a reminder to go to the emergency room in case of distress, and more. But it didn't feel right. As I was speaking, I could feel Dana drifting further and further away from me.
Again I ran to Rita. "Do you understand why she wants to die?" Rita asked me. "Yes," I told her. "She's a young woman with enormous abilities, personal charm, intelligence and good taste, but if I saw the world and myself the way she sees them, I'd want to die too." "Great," Rita said to me, "so next time you see her, tell her exactly that."
Before the next session my knees were shaking, but I went for it anyway. "You know, Dana," I told her (more or less), "I've been thinking about the things you told me in our last session, and I can understand you." Dana and her partner looked at me in amazement. "Yes," I told her, "if I set aside the way I see you, with all your skills, your charm, your kindness, your intelligence, and the way you've always stood by the weak, and I'm willing to look at things from your point of view, the way you see yourself, I can understand that you want to die. If I thought my world was all bad, that I myself was bad and broken, that no one wanted to be on good terms with me, that I mattered to no one, and in addition, I were certain that the world was completely known and nothing in it could change, I'd want to die too."
I remember to this day how hard my heart pounded, but I also remember what Dana wore to the next session: a white cotton blouse with a wide neckline trimmed with a ruffle. Her hair was washed and styled, and she looked completely different. I also remember what she said, and how well she articulated one of the ways in which compassion from another can awaken in a person a self-compassion that can turn their life around. "The last session changed something dramatically for me," she explained. "The moment you told me you could understand that I want to die, I stopped criticizing myself for having this feeling at all. Once that additional self-attack stopped, it was as if more energy that had been locked up in there was released, and I started to breathe. Yes, it's okay, I told myself, the moment the attack began. People can understand me for feeling this way."
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




