top of page

How Do We Know We're Making the Right Choice in a Relationship (and in Life in General)?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Oct 22, 2021
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Often we try to avoid whatever makes us suffer, or try to ease the pain. But if we deal with what hurts us in the first place, we can improve our situation at a much deeper level

Shira (a pseudonym) stood at the most critical crossroads of her life. At 37, she had two suitors who, at least on paper, were ready to bring her the moon. Shira is a woman with little self-confidence, so the very fact that not one but two men were interested in her was intoxicating. The decision was a hard one.

One of them, let's call him Ron, was a successful businessman who had hit his target: making $20 million by the age of 40. For a woman who had never felt she belonged, life at Ron's side offered substantial compensation for her sense of deprivation. Shira had always felt that life was supposed to offer her more. There was no story she loved more than Cinderella. As a child, after bitter fights with her sister, she would lie in bed fantasizing about how, as an adult, she would come back to visit the house in a big car and fine clothes, with stories about the most fascinating, glamorous people, and show everyone how wrong they had been about her.

With Ron, Shira came very close to that dream. She was invited to the most secret parties, sat in the best spot at the bar, and got to eat at the coolest restaurants just as they opened. Ron was like a secret key that opened every door that had been closed to Shira, who had come to Israel from Central Europe at the beginning of her teens.

Ron, for his part, thought Shira was beautiful and charming, and was very proud when she accompanied him to parties. He knew that her self-image was far out of step with her abilities, and he was glad he could give her the shortcut she deserved to the life she wanted.

The other man who had fallen head over heels for Shira we'll call Itamar. He was no loser by any stretch, but his life was less glittery than Ron's. At 45, he worked with his parents and his uncle in the family business, had contributed significantly to its ability to adapt to changing times, and had become one of the most successful players in his category in Israel.

Still, Itamar's life was one of harder work and far fewer parties, restaurants and flights. Itamar, too, got a glimpse of Shira's low self-image. He heard her agonize before and after a presentation at work, and he knew that from a very young age she had experienced herself as second fiddle to her gifted older sister, at whose feet the whole world always seemed to fall.

Unlike Ron, Itamar had no magic wand that could turn Shira's pumpkin into a carriage, and he couldn't dull her pain with gin-and-hibiscus cocktails on the roof of a new secret hotel in Jaffa. But he was willing to sit with her the night before a presentation at work and listen to her run through the material until the small hours, until she felt sure of herself. And he managed to listen to her many dilemmas about her relationships with her parents and her sister without handing out advice, listening and mediating again and again until Shira connected with her own inner voice and decided what to do.

How Do We Know We're Making the Right Choice in a Relationship (and in Life in General)? - illustration

What would you advise Shira to do? To choose Ron, whose relationship with her seems to have stepped out of her childhood dreams and taken away all her pain? Or to go with Itamar, and choose a life that is less magical for the little girl inside her, but more promising?

I suspect that many of us have an intuition that the relationship with Itamar might be the right one for her. But why, exactly? The reason has to do with the difference between our emotional need and the need of our coping mechanism.

Let me illustrate with Shira's case. Shira's emotional need was for a realistic sense of self-worth, and a higher one than she had. Shira needed to feel trust in her abilities, to dare to make mistakes and take risks without fearing that doing so would expose the "structural" inferiority she had grown up believing in. As a child, in many of the cases where this need went unmet, Shira regulated her pain with those same fantasies of overcompensation. Alone in her childhood bedroom, these fantasies numbed the pain caused when her need for a sense of self-worth went unanswered. That is how those grandiose fantasies (let's call them the Cinderella mechanism) became the foundation of her coping mechanism.

Now let's bring our two men into the picture. We can see that each of them answers a different part of Shira's psyche. Ron answers the Cinderella mechanism. His successful startup is the fairy godmother's magic wand, his Tesla is the carriage, and when she is with him, Shira-Cinderella can find herself at one ball after another. In those moments, she certainly doesn't feel like a scullery maid.

But, and this is a serious "but," when Shira is with Ron, beneath all the magic she still feels like a scullery maid. On the face of it there is no reason for that: assuming their love is real and their relationship good and serious, Shira could keep sailing from one ball to the next. But because Ron is the one who gets her into the ball, in some hidden inner place Shira is still waiting in dread for the moment the clock strikes midnight and her wretchedness is exposed.

With Itamar, by contrast, Shira gets a chance to deal differently with the sense of worthlessness that has followed her since childhood. Instead of joining in the childhood fantasies, comforting as they may be, her experiences with Itamar showed her that he has the ability to make the humiliated child within her believe in herself, dare to express herself, agree to invest in herself, grow, take risks, and gradually build her trust in herself.

In other words, these two worthy men, both well-meaning and sincere, actually matched two different parts of Shira. Shira's suffering came from the fact that, as a child, she routinely did not have her need for a sense of self-worth met. Ron offered a balm for the suffering caused by that basic need going unmet. Itamar, on the other hand, offered to help Shira get the basic need itself met. As in the story attributed to Rabbi Joshua ben Hananiah, Ron is the short road that is long, and Itamar represents the long road that is short.

The important principle here is that we often find ourselves in life at a similar crossroads. The dilemma doesn't have to be romantic at all. Suppose we suffer from nagging anxieties and experience the whole world as extremely dangerous. These days it is easier than usual to believe the world really is extremely dangerous, in a concrete and personal way. So it is very tempting to satisfy our anxiety-coping mechanism, to opt for avoidance or to try to control many details of our lives and surroundings in order to ease the pain. That would be the choice of Ron, so to speak.

But we can also acknowledge that we have an anxiety disorder, and begin to deal thoroughly with the disorder itself, instead of plugging each anxiety that floods us, one at a time. If we treat our anxiety disorder through emotional therapy, meditation or medication, for example, we can improve our situation at a deeper level. If we work to meet our emotional need for a sense of existential security, that is, if we choose Itamar in this case, our coping mechanism, which seeks to control the environment in order to avoid every potential threat, will weaken on its own.

The choice between Ron and Itamar is always open to us. And what about Shira? She chose Ron, hoping that in parallel she could work on strengthening the self-confidence of the diminished little girl inside her. Until that girl grows stronger, she'll be happy for another round of gin and hibiscus.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page