Going to a Therapist? Here's How to Tell if They Love You
Updated: Oct 22
What are we actually paying for in therapy, and how might a therapist's real concern for us show up?
"Sorry for saying this, but honestly, going to a therapist is basically like going to a prostitute," Lilach, 35, told me at the end of a CrossFit session, when I'd asked to go first in the shower so I wouldn't be late for my own therapist. As I tried not to take offense, Lilach tried to soften the thought: "I stopped seeing my therapist once I realized that, as far as she's concerned, our relationship depends on money. If I stop paying her, she'll stop caring about me."
I stepped into the shower stall and found a long-antennaed cockroach waiting for me, which didn't exactly leave room to mull over this important question. But on my way to my own therapist, I opened up the debate with myself. The worry that payment makes a therapist's caring inauthentic is fairly common. But as someone who knows quite a few therapists, and even more sex workers, I can say that beyond the fact that sex workers also, incidentally, provide something like psychological services to their "clients," the two professions don't have much in common. Still, Lilach's harsh comment came from real pain, and it cost her the therapy she'd been in. So, despite its vulgarity, I think it deserves an answer.
So what are we actually paying for in therapy? Simply put: we're paying for the therapist's expertise and their time. In that sense, psychological treatment costs money exactly the way dental treatment costs money. Even though I like to think I'm great company, and over the years I've even made an effort to floss, it's never once occurred to me that if Dr. Masot — my lovely dentist since I was 17 — really, truly loved me, he wouldn't ask to be paid at the end of my appointments.
But we're not paying for the love and concern our therapist feels toward us. I love many of my clients. Genuinely. I think about them outside of session hours too. I'll be reading a book and come across a quote that fits a particular patient; when a patient of mine runs into trouble, I feel sad. When a patient falls in love, I get excited. And if someone breaks her heart, sometimes I feel like breaking something of his in return.
But all of that misses the real point, which is that a therapist's love shows up in the fact that they always hold, in their heart and in their mind, the shining core that exists inside their patient. It's a love that never forgets the patient's potential for growth, that believes the patient is the real expert on their own life, that sees the wounded child inside them, that isn't fooled and knows their thorns are a form of protection, that understands they're simply trying to survive. You can buy my time, and my professional guidance — but you cannot buy my love. And I believe many of the men and women I'm lucky enough to meet in my clinic know that.
There are plenty of other points relevant to this discussion — among them the fact that payment frees patients from any responsibility for their therapist's own emotional wellbeing, and so on. But as an EFT therapist, working in the light of thirty years of attachment research, my own view is that when this question comes up in therapy, it's usually less a sign of genuine doubt about the therapist's feelings, and more a sign of the patient's own difficulty accepting love.

The Capacity to Receive Love
The psychologist Diana Fosha, who developed Accelerated Experiential Dynamic Psychotherapy, or AEDP, gives central importance to this key capacity, which she calls Receptive Capacity. A therapist's ability to have their empathy actually land and benefit the patient sits right at the heart of AEDP's model of change, as it does in other approaches grounded in attachment research. The psychologist Leigh McCullough Valliant, whose book "Changing Character" I've already dug into here at length, likewise stresses that the ability to take in positive emotional signals coming from the people around us is the foundation for sensitivity, openness, emotional connection, empathy and intimacy.
Fosha explains that this capacity results from perceptual, cognitive and emotional processes. In other words, at its core, this is about our ability to accurately assess our emotional environment. An accurate assessment like that is the bedrock of mental health. In certain patients, like Lilach, this capacity has been damaged, and they feel threatened when they have to acknowledge that other people affect them. Our working assumption, as therapists focused on attachment, is that difficult emotional experiences in childhood led Lilach to dull her own ability to recognize empathy directed at her. She suppressed her capacity to feel and be moved by expressions of love toward her, in order to protect herself from painful feelings that were, apparently, too often bound up with that emotion.
In other words — I obviously don't know exactly what happened in Lilach's previous therapy. It's entirely possible she really did end up with a cynical therapist, and maybe that therapist simply didn't love her. But in reality, in my estimation, there are far more patients who struggle to receive empathy than there are therapists who struggle to give it.
I bought a coffee and drank it outside my own therapist's door, waiting for the clock to hit thirteen past eight. In the two minutes I had left, I thought about Lilach. I wasn't offended anymore. I understood that when she told me it felt like going to a prostitute, she was really speaking to her own difficulty feeling loved. Her therapist's affection for her had run into a gatekeeper who refused to let it all the way in, into Lilach's heart. That gatekeeper was posted there in childhood to protect Lilach from pain. But in adulthood, that same gatekeeper keeps telling Lilach, "You're not really worthy of love, and your therapist doesn't actually care about you either — only about your money." The most painful part of what Lilach said wasn't that she compared her therapist to a prostitute. The real sting was that she compared herself to the person visiting one — that she pictured herself as that same poor soul, trying to force, with money and with violence, a cheap imitation of love.
At quarter past eight I knocked on the door, and my therapist opened it with a smile. "I was just thinking about how much you love me," I told her. She smiled back at me, her eyes smiling too. "I'm glad you know that," she said.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




