top of page

From South America to Japan, Different Cultures Have Their Own Unique Mental Disorders. What About Us?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Aug 10, 2023
8 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Young Japanese people who withdraw from the world at home for years, Malaysian men convinced their genitals are retracting into their bodies, and in South America the belief that intense fear can cause the soul to leave the body: different countries recognize mental syndromes unique to specific cultures, and they're no less legitimate than disorders like depression and anxiety. Here are a few more that ought to make it into the diagnostic manual

One of the fascinating facts in the study of the mind is that there are mental illnesses that exist only within a specific cultural context. These are often called "culture-bound syndromes," and they combine psychiatric and somatic (physical) symptoms. They have unique characteristics, a specific history, and social interpretations that come along with them - and, for the most part, "Western" professionals don't find it easy to recognize them.

For example, Koro syndrome - a phenomenon reported mainly in Southeast Asia, especially Malaysia and Singapore - causes men to experience intense anxiety that their genitals are retracting into their bodies in a way that will lead to their death; a condition called Dhat, reported mainly in India, is characterized by anxiety about semen loss and changes in urine color; Susto is an illness that develops after an event so frightening that the soul leaves the body during it, causing misery and sickness; and perhaps the most familiar is a condition called hikikomori, a Japanese syndrome that causes sufferers (often young people) to withdraw from the world and shut themselves in at home, or in their parents' home, for months or even years.

What makes all of these culture-bound mental illnesses, rather than a variation on a recognized universal mental disorder (that is, one whose definition was established in the West)? Beyond the fact that these involve different cultural interpretations (we, for instance, tend not to think in terms of a soul leaving the body during a frightening event), some of these disorders are characterized by unique symptoms that generally don't accompany the common, universal psychiatric disorders.

The intense fear that one's genitals will retract into the body and endanger one's life isn't really present in generalized anxiety disorder as we understand it, or in other known states of psychological distress. In addition, there's the matter of prevalence: the severe social withdrawal of hikikomori is documented primarily, or only, in Japan, and that specificity goes beyond what we'd expect in conditions like social anxiety disorder or agoraphobia.

These syndromes are often recognized and accepted in the countries where they develop. That is, the symptoms, the course of the illness and its outcomes are understood and accepted within the local community, and include specific rituals and agreed-upon healing methods. This is an important distinction, because if you try to treat culture-bound disorders using methods considered effective for universal disorders (depression, anxiety, etc.), the results will often be worse than those achieved through traditional healing methods, or ones that developed within the same culture the syndrome comes from.

And after all this, the question arises: do we - "Westerners" that we are - have culture-bound syndromes of our own? Are there behaviors that could fit the definition, that we simply haven't thought of that way? In my opinion, these are the leading candidates:

Orthorexia nervosa. The term is based on anorexia nervosa, of course. The word "anorexia" is made up of the Greek prefix "an," meaning negation, and the word "orexis," meaning "appetite." Orthorexia combines the word "ortho," from "orthodoxy" ("correct" or "right"), with the word for appetite - and refers to an extreme fixation on eating food perceived as healthy or "pure." The word "extreme" means that this fixation harms the person's quality of life or functioning.

A person suffering from orthorexia will systematically avoid foods they view as unhealthy or impure; symptoms include compulsively checking ingredient lists and nutrition labels, growing concern about the healthfulness of ingredients, increasing avoidance of entire food groups (sugar, carbohydrates, gluten, dairy, meat, all animal products, and more) even without any medical justification, and narrowing the list of "permitted" foods down to a short, sparse list. Such a person will feel great distress when "healthy" or "safe" food isn't available. Naturally, this kind of disorder is far more common in affluent societies, which can afford to obsess over food types, health, fitness and beauty.

Burnout. I probably don't need to explain this to you, but burnout is characterized by feelings of depleted energy or exhaustion, expressed mainly in relation to work. A person suffering from burnout will experience growing mental distance, negative feelings and cynicism toward their work - and their professional effectiveness will decline. Burnout is especially common in cultures with a strong emphasis on work and productivity.

Affluenza. A state of chasing wealth and being entirely focused on money and the material aspects of existence, to the point of neglecting other aspects of life. This sometimes leads to dissatisfaction, but even more so to unethical behavior, irresponsibility and other problems.

The "quarter-life crisis" is also something worth considering. I mean, of course, that period of insecurity, self-doubt and disappointment around career, relationships and one's financial situation, which tends to occur sometime during that dreadful stretch between the mid-20s and early 30s. It's similar to a midlife crisis, but it happens earlier.

"Impostor syndrome" can also already be put on the table as far as its prevalence in the West goes. Anyone who hasn't experienced it, raise your hand. This is a psychological pattern in which a person doubts their skills, talents or achievements, and suffers from a persistent fear of being exposed as a fraud. People suffering from this syndrome can have an abundance of external evidence of their success, yet continue to feel afraid anyway.

Complex post-traumatic stress disorder (C-PTSD) doesn't yet appear in professional diagnostic manuals, but it will surely get there soon. This disorder characterizes people who experienced prolonged, repeated trauma in childhood, and includes variations on the familiar post-trauma symptoms: difficulty regulating emotion, a distorted perception of the abuser, and a chronic feeling of emptiness or hopelessness.

Alongside all these, I think there are a few more culture-bound disorders that will become more present in therapeutic discourse in the future. For example, digital disorders (or internet-related disorders): the profound effects of gaming, social media and internet use in general haven't yet been fully identified. There's also eco-anxiety (or climate anxiety) - stress, anxiety and despair about the future of the planet - which isn't officially recognized as a distinct disorder, but there's growing recognition of the impact of the whole subject on mental health.

The Fine Line Between Validation and Overdiagnosis

What's the advantage of thinking about such states as specific syndromes? First, labeling a cluster of symptoms as a specific syndrome can give us a useful framework for understanding the experiences of people suffering from those symptoms. Such labeling can help people understand themselves, reduce their sense of isolation, and encourage them to seek help.

In addition, such definitions can give clinicians and researchers a shared language that allows discussion of specific mental health conditions, and improved communication can lead to more fruitful collaborations. Defining a cluster of symptoms as a disorder can also help expand research, and the development and promotion of effective, targeted treatments or prevention methods; official recognition of a disorder can raise public awareness of it, reduce the stigma attached to it, promote social change, and create a better support network for those who suffer from it. For instance, in order for a particular treatment to be recognized by health insurance, the condition being treated needs to be officially recognized as a disorder. In other words, recognizing new syndromes can ease access to treatment.

On the other hand, it's also important to be aware of the potential risks inherent in over-pathologizing ordinary human experiences. In such cases, people may receive a diagnosis even when their symptoms are actually a normal response to life stressors - that is, symptoms that fall within the range of ordinary human behaviors or experiences.

Overdiagnosis can also lead to overmedicalization and excessive reliance on pharmaceutical treatments (instead of holistic approaches that include therapy, lifestyle change and intervention at the social level). In addition, just as a diagnosis can reduce stigma and validate a person's experience, it can also have the opposite effect, leading to increased stigma and discrimination.

Another problem that can develop is a focus on symptoms rather than core issues. When we place too much emphasis on labeling and classification, we can end up overlooking the underlying problems contributing to psychological distress, and factors like poverty, discrimination, trauma and social pressure. This can lead to a misallocation of resources, which is really the last thing we need.

From the perspective of emotion-focused therapy, the biggest drawback of identifying new syndromes is that it carries no clinical or interventional significance whatsoever. A patient grappling with a terrifying inner voice is a patient grappling with a terrifying inner voice, and it makes no difference at all whether that terrifying voice tells them the planet is cooking, that their genitals are retracting into their body, or that white rice will cause irreversible harm to their children. A patient haunted by a violent, critical inner voice needs the same kind of clinical work, whether that voice makes her shut herself in at home and never go out, makes her feel like a fraud at work, or makes her obsessively chase status symbols to restore her sense of self-worth.

From South America to Japan, Different Cultures Have Their Own Unique Mental Disorders. What About Us? - illustration

Recommendations

Drink: Cold-Brew Tea

Another recommendation courtesy of my good friend Tzvika T., whose recommendations are always good. Cold-brewed tea is made by steeping tea leaves in cold water for 12 to 24 hours. You can use almost any kind of tea for this. The longer the steeping, the stronger the flavor. Here's how it's done: place the tea leaves or tea bags in a pitcher or jar. Pour in cold or room-temperature water, cover, and let it "cook" in the fridge or at room temperature. Once the tea reaches the strength you want, strain out the leaves or bags. Cold brewing tends to produce a smoother, mellower flavor profile compared to hot-brewed tea. The process often extracts fewer bitter compounds, producing a sweeter brew. Cold brewing also typically pulls less caffeine out of the tea than hot brewing does.

Sun: Tinted Zinc-Based Sunscreen

Surfers use zinc-based sunscreen for several reasons: zinc oxide is a physical sunscreen agent that sits on the surface of the skin and reflects both UVA and UVB rays. It also tends to be more water-resistant than many chemical sunscreens. That's essential for surfers who are constantly in and out of the water. These physical sunscreens are preferable for people with sensitive skin, or those who want to avoid certain chemicals, since zinc oxide is a natural mineral and is less likely to cause skin irritation or allergic reactions. In addition, zinc-oxide-based sunscreens are generally considered more coral-reef-friendly.

But they have another great bonus: some of the companies that make these sunscreens also offer a zinc-based option with a dark pigment that can match your skin tone. And that's a real winning trick: if you have stretch marks, scars, prominent veins, pigmentation changes, or any other story you tell yourself about your skin's imperfections at the beach, tinted zinc-based sunscreens can help "smooth out" your skin tone and make all those frustrating things less noticeable, while offering very strong durability - and of course, you can use them outside the pool too.

Building Kids' English: ChatGPT

To my delight, my son became interested in the exploits of the explorer Ernest Shackleton, and in the heroic voyage of the ship Endurance. This was an opportunity to combine his natural curiosity with my acute need to strengthen his command of English. At first I thought we'd read the English Wikipedia together, but then I saw the information didn't answer his questions and the English was too advanced for him.

That's when I remembered that artificial intelligence, which still works for us and not the other way around (supposedly), could be the private tutor we needed: I opened ChatGPT and asked it to explain, in English suited for a 10-year-old, who Shackleton was, what was special about the Endurance expedition, and what the expedition's high points were. Afterward we naturally wanted to move on to the subject of aliens and the congressional hearings, but since the chatbot doesn't cover such current material, we had to find videos on our own.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page