From Freud to Thich Nhat Hanh: Even If Only One Shard of the Clinic Remains, It Contains Everything
Losing objects and memories is also part of the mourning process, and it is precisely their impermanence that allows the psyche to reinvest its emotional energy in whatever comes next
Two weeks ago, which feels like two years, I parted with an enormous number of books. I may even have written about it here, but I can barely remember whether I ate breakfast, let alone things that happened before the start of the current war.
Anyway, on the same Saturday when I sent the books on their way, when I came home and looked at the friends who remained, I was seized by a fierce urge to run outside and bring every one of those books back home. But one mantra stopped me from doing so. I looked at the books that were left and told myself: in everything, there is everything.
On the first day of the war, the blast from the missile that fell in central Tel Aviv more or less lifted my clinic into the air. As I thought about moving to another office, I asked myself what from the original office I would take with me. What matters, and what matters less? After all, I had chosen every item with care.
The wallpaper was ordered from Italy and I waited four months for it during Covid, the mobile came from a Scandinavian shop, even my tissues are the softest three-ply available (you had no doubt). And no matter what I can take, so much will be left behind. And although I don't want to part with them (and who knows, maybe I won't have to), in trying to cope with these thoughts I do my best to remind myself: in everything, there is everything.
Impermanence Hurts
Not long ago a friend complained to me that instead of going to sleep, she found herself spending the entire night watching videos about a particular drawing technique that interested her. I told her I could easily understand her: it's hard to remember that we know enough. Not in the sense that there's nothing left to learn. Obviously there is, and we will never know everything we want to know, but we know enough in the sense that even if we never learned anything new again, we would still be nowhere near exhausting the uses of the knowledge we've already acquired.
I went over ideas for a creative project with another friend. She's an exceptionally talented young woman, and every idea gave birth to another idea in her. At some point I stopped her and said: we have to focus on our three main ideas and know that they're good enough.
These reactions of my two friends are intimately familiar to me from my own life experience. Not only is my attempt to cling to the books or to the items in the office no different from their attempt to hold on to more knowledge or more ideas, but I myself often need someone from the outside to tell me to stop collecting books, lectures, classes, ideas, and tools of one kind or another.
For all they seem so real in what they promise, they are often also attempts to escape the pain of partiality and impermanence. But if I truly believe that "in everything there is everything," then when I let go of the need to "know everything," I'm not giving up curiosity, but remembering that within what I already know lies all the truth I need.
One of Sigmund Freud's most beautiful texts, in the view of many, is called "On Transience," in which he describes a conversation with the poet Rainer Maria Rilke during a shared walk. Freud relates that Rilke was deeply saddened in the face of nature's beauty. For the poet, the fact that all the beauty spread out before them on the walk would vanish: the flowers would wither, the landscape would change. The knowledge that winter is inevitable spoiled the beauty for him.
For the poet, transience is a reason for despair. Freud uses this anecdote to present the opposite position, that transience is the quality that gives beauty its value. The fact that something is fleeting not only doesn't diminish its worth but makes it precious. Just as it's hard for us to appreciate how wonderful it is to breathe through the nose until we catch a cold, so beauty, too, takes its value from its inevitable fading.

A Shard That Contains the Whole
My mantra draws encouragement from Freud. Every item in the clinic, from the Italian wallpaper to the pillow a patient knitted for me, is valuable not because it was promised to me for all eternity, but because of its presence in the moment I experienced it.
I remember sitting alone during Covid for days on end in the office, thinking about how to make it homier and more pleasant. I remember what time each patient arrives by the way the sunbeams fall on the couch when they sit on it. And the fact that I parted with my books doesn't mean they no longer matter to me, but is an acknowledgment that they have fulfilled their purpose.
And perhaps slightly differently from him, the idea that "everything contains everything" isn't exactly a resignation to the world's disintegration, to what is missing, but a search for the whole within what remains. Even if only one shard of the clinic or one book from the library remains, whether things vanish by force or by choice, in especially clear moments (not all the time, let's not exaggerate), I try to remember that this shard contains the essence of everything that was there before.
This mantra also echoes the concept, which I will translate here as "bein-havaya," inter-being, of the spiritual leader Thich Nhat Hanh. His meditations remind us that when we look at a tomato, if we look deeply enough into its tomato-ness, we can see in it the sun, the earth, the rain, and even the farmer who grew it.
Nothing truly stands on its own, and nothing is separate. Anyone who manages to take shelter in the shade of this perspective surely feels that "we are all one fabric," and that no object is separate and therefore none is erased. Every being is composed of an infinite number of relations within an entire web of connections. Someone who manages to hold this focus can loosen their grip. Say that this means he stops loving, and they'll answer that on the contrary, it only shows that his love doesn't depend on the physical presence of the object.
Freud, Buddhism, in everything there is everything: it seems to me there's no contradiction between the insights. Freud himself, writing about a healthy process of mourning, emphasizes that when we part with a beloved object, our psyche goes through a process that ultimately allows it to reinvest its emotional energy in new objects.
If "everything is in everything," it means that the love invested in choosing the cups in the office or the plants on the balcony, or the passion and imagination invested in the books I gave away, does not evaporate. It remains imprinted within me. It is what lets me see the whole even within what remains, and within what is yet to come. Perhaps even in something new, something different, that I haven't yet met.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




