top of page

Even When Your Partner Refuses Therapy, There Is a Way Out of the Crisis

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Oct 7, 2021
8 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Couples sometimes get stuck in a negative loop and may feel trapped in a kind of maze. But even when couples therapy is off the table, one partner can still reach results alone. A reply to a reader

"Hello Amalia,

My husband and I live in his aunt and uncle's yard. We fought this week because he chose to go to work at the time when the kids need to be bathed and put to bed (I should stress that we've already fought about this before, and he promised to make sure he's home for bath time), and he said he would send his mother, who happened to be at his aunt's house, to help me. It may sound fine to you, but I don't like her helping me, because it comes with things she does or says that I don't agree with. He knows this, and still he called her to help me with the kids.

I got angry with him, but I didn't say a word. He ignored me completely, and while I was going to sleep I heard him leave the house. He didn't say anything about where he was going, etc. The day after, I decided to talk to him. I asked if he was willing to talk. He said he had to get up early and asked if we could talk in the morning. I refused and told him it was important to me that we talk now. He agreed and asked what I wanted to say. I asked him why he hadn't respected my request and had asked his mother to come anyway. He said it came from a desire to help me. I answered that I appreciate that very much but would rather not.

And then he hurled accusations and very harsh words at me: he said I push him to the edge, why do I always have a sour face, he said: you have hatred in your heart for my family, you sit at home with the kids while everyone around me sends their kids to daycare (I decided to raise the babies at home for now, until age two, because of all the cases of abuse happening these days). I should stress that I know his family preaches to him about every little thing and he listens to them, and that's how fights start between us. In every fight of ours, I'm the one who tries to meet him halfway and save the relationship, and he, I quote: "Go find yourself another man, that's all I can do. If it doesn't suit you, go find yourself another man who will understand you and put up with you."

While we were talking, I started crying and couldn't stop the tears (both because he said untrue things and because they really hurt). My feet went numb and I called my sister to come because I was truly frightened by what was happening to me. He summoned his cousin, sat with him, and they laughed and talked. He didn't even ask how I was feeling. He left the house and went to sleep at his aunt and uncle's big house. We haven't spoken since. Yesterday I texted him asking him to bring me the car keys, and he answered that I should ask my family to come pick me up. He took the kids' car seats out of the car and put them by the front door. I asked my sister to come get me, and I'm at her place with the kids.

We haven't spoken since. I am so hurt by him. I don't know what to do. Is there a way to save the marriage, does he even care about me?! And he absolutely refuses to go to couples therapy, which is absurd.

I'd appreciate your advice,

G."

Dear G.,

Thank you for writing to me, and for allowing me to address your letter in the column. First of all, let me say that it sounds awfullllllll and dreadful! No one with two children under the age of two can truly be happy (I'm not entirely serious, but you know what I mean). And it certainly isn't easy to keep your sanity when you live in a unit in the family's yard. So yes, we thank the universe for our children, and the option of living in the family's yard is surely very significant financially, but it's still a pressure cooker, and you can truly go crazy.

My first impression is that you two are trapped in a kind of chase, in which you've been pushed into the role of the pursuer and your husband finds himself in the role of the one who flees. I say "trapped" because I don't think either of you wants these roles. Like in a maze, you're trying to find the exit, so you walk down a path that seems right to you, but you find yourselves again and again at the same spot.

When your husband sent his mother to help you with the kids, you felt this loneliness sharply, because it's true that you needed help with the kids, but what you really wanted was a sense of partnership and closeness from your husband. When he sent his mother, you felt exactly the opposite. It was a kind of painful "two for the price of one." You didn't get your husband's personal support, and from your point of view he also "dumped" your mother-in-law on you, even though he knows that in your encounters you're exposed to her criticism of you.

I get the impression that at this point the loneliness that already accompanies you within the relationship became very acute. You're raising two babies alone while your husband is at work, and his extended family doesn't take you and the children into their arms. Following the loneliness came the gloomy thoughts that your husband is ignoring you, and your irritation began to rise (understandably!).

It's also understandable that you wanted to act so you'd feel better, and to close the distance between you. It sounds like you had a feeling that if you only explained yourself better, your husband would see your vulnerability and come closer to you. That's why you initiated the late-night conversation. But, and here's where the mess begins, your attempt to get closer was probably experienced by your husband as judgmental criticism or an unfair attempt to control him.

You heard only the harsh words he hurled at you, but those are probably just the tip of the iceberg. Beneath them were uncomfortable feelings, like a sense of suffocation, failure and helplessness. It may be hard to believe, but there's a good chance your husband also feels he's doing the best he can. From his point of view, he may be thinking that you are, true, burdened and overwhelmed, but that it's your choice to raise the babies at home when you could send them to daycare, and that you leave no room for his voice and his opinion.

He may be heavily invested in his work, among other reasons, because despite the backing you get from his family, it matters to him to put you on your feet financially and get you out of the family yard. It's also possible that you expect him to absorb many of your frustrations when you're together at home, precisely because you don't have much time together, and he doesn't know how to respond to them. So from his perspective, when he sent his mother to help you, it was some kind of attempt to dodge the raindrops. That is, to find you practical support, to protect himself from a situation that stirs up unpleasant feelings in him, and to avoid yet another fight.

But as we can see, this avoidance isn't effective. The fact is you wanted to have a conversation. He tried to avoid it, and it's possible he was truly tired, but he gave in anyway. And indeed, as he feared, while you felt you were exposing your pain, he felt he had fallen into a trap. There's a chance that the thoughts going through his head before he responded to you in the conversation were: "Nothing I do is good enough for her, she can never be pleased, she's too much for me." At that point he told you he's unable to contain you. For you it was a terrible rejection, but for him it may have been an attempt to make you accept his limitations and stop the attack.

This is where the second round of your loop began. When he said that, you felt rejected and insulted. You were hurt to the depths of your soul and couldn't contain your feelings. From the stress you stopped thinking and your body reacted in your place. Your feet went numb. It seems to me that he experienced this acute expression of distress as manipulation, as a melodramatic attempt to force him to attend to you and your needs. That is, the way you tried to convey your suffering to him made him feel deceived and maybe even exploited. And to hold on in the situation he summoned his cousin, and then, to take some air and find a way to survive the situation, he went to sleep in the big house.

I know it's hard to believe, but there's a good chance he did this because he thought sleeping next to you at home would be the worse alternative. Perhaps it would end in violence between you or in separation, and either way it would make it hard for him to function at work the next day. Of course, this is a way of coping that may help him in the short term, but it is very ineffective for your relationship.

This is where the third phase of your loop began. When he distances himself from you to that degree, naturally you too stop trying to bring him closer, and you withdraw to your family. And so two people who were trying to survive a difficult situation find themselves like two boxers, each in his own corner, licking their wounds, while your "coaches" whisper in your ears lines that are meant to strengthen you but in practice worsen the conflict.

So what can you do? You ask him to go to couples therapy but he refuses. First of all, you can show him my answer. Maybe that way he'll see that, contrary to his fears, couples therapy isn't a place where the wife and the couples therapist gang up on the man and "chew him up." Alongside that, I focused my answer on your side (I hope that didn't make you feel judged), simply because we have control only over ourselves, and there's no better recipe for misery than hoping another person will change his behavior.

That's why I recommend that you go to individual therapy yourself. You're a central part of your dynamic, and in individual therapy (preferably with a therapist who has a systemic perspective), you can get help with several points that could improve your situation: 1. You can work on the childhood wounds that open up during your loop, and once the wounds are in better shape, hopefully the pain you feel during your fights will be less severe and will give you more choice about your responses. 2. You can feel the difference between being vulnerable and being hurt. I get the impression that while you think you're managing to be vulnerable around your husband, what you're actually showing him is how hurt you are. And being hurt is often exactly the opposite of being vulnerable. When we show how hurt we are, the other side often experiences it as aggression. Only revealing vulnerability truly brings people closer. 3. And if all these changes don't improve the relationship between you, hopefully individual therapy will help you set boundaries assertively with your husband and his family, in the hope that they will allow him to find another way of positioning himself toward you, or (and I hope it won't be needed) give you the strength to dismantle the whole arrangement.

Good luck,

Amalia


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page