Embracing the "No": When Excessive Positivity Shrinks the Conversation
Updated: Oct 22
A seemingly positive approach is supposed to foster good communication — but sometimes the very wish to avoid confrontation, and the pushing-away of anything negative, blocks the chance for a real conversation. Why "tactical empathy" beats excessive positivity.
One of the privileges of my job is getting to learn from other people's mistakes. Many hours a week, I watch highly intelligent, sophisticated people fail when it comes to communicating with the people closest and dearest to them. Even though these are smart, self-aware people, something about intimate emotional relationships manages to tangle things up — not out of any ill will, but because of common communication patterns that all of us fall into.
The most common mistake we make when communicating with the people who matter to us is ignoring or minimizing the negative side of things — of life, of the relationship, of the person in front of us, or of ourselves.
The reason is simple: it's natural for us to prefer positivity. It's seen as a way of preserving good relationships and avoiding confrontation, but in practice it can amount to a kind of suppression that undermines trust and any real sense of connection. There's also a broader fear of the word "no" — of boundaries, and of the uncomfortable feelings they might stir up. But the truth is that boundaries, set the right way, can build a far more stable, healthy relationship than suppression or rounding off the edges.
It Actually Is a Big Deal
The tendency to minimize negative emotions, to present ourselves in an overly positive light, or to play down what the other person is feeling, comes from that same fear — but it often creates distance instead of closeness. For example, when someone tells us about a hardship, we might respond with something like, "It's nothing, you'll find a new job in no time," or "It's not that big a deal, you're just making a thing out of it."
Statements like that might look innocent enough, but in practice they diminish the experience of the person in front of us. Instead of creating a sense of being heard and held, they convey dismissiveness, even alienation. Minimizing positivity — the kind that tries to paper over feelings or difficulties — is a common communication pattern meant to soothe the other person, but it usually has the opposite effect.
When we say, "It's nothing, you'll find a new job or a new friend in no time," we may be trying to convey optimism and encouragement, but the message that actually comes across is that we don't really grasp the depth of the other person's pain or fear. What they're left with is the sense that we're trying to "skip over" the difficulty, rather than being there to hold it.
Beyond that, there's a tendency to downplay the gaps within a conflict, in the belief that this will calm things down. Sentences like "You're just making a thing out of it," or "If you hear me out, you'll see it's not a big deal," create the impression that we're dismissing what the other person feels or says. Sentences like these produce a sense of disconnection, as if there's no room in the relationship for conflict or difference. But it's precisely acknowledging the differences and the other side's pain that can reconnect us, rather than cutting us off from each other.
What Did I Even Ask For?
Another pattern is presenting ourselves in an overly positive light within the relationship. For example, when someone says, "What did I even ask for? After everything I've done for you (or for the project)" — they're trying to convey devotion and sacrifice. But in practice, it can come across as emotional manipulation built on an imagined debt. Instead of strengthening the relationship, statements like this can stir up guilt or anger in the other person, who feels that what's being expected of them is unfair, or unrelated to the conversation actually at hand.
And finally, there's the dismissal of the other person's feelings of guilt, meant to "free" them from it. Sentences like "You have nothing to feel guilty about, you didn't do anything wrong" may sound supportive, but they often don't let the other person process their feelings authentically. Guilt is an emotion that arises out of a need to make something right, or to learn something, and the moment we dismiss it, we deny the person the chance to go through an inner process.
What all these examples have in common is the good intention behind them. We want to encourage, to soothe, to protect — but along the way, we block genuine, authentic dialogue. Changing these patterns means focusing on learning to listen deeply, and on the capacity to sit with the other person's difficulty without dismissing it or rushing to fix it. That's not always easy, but it's the key to deeper, healthier relationships.

Empathy — But Tactical
These thoughts came to me after listening again to Chris Voss, a former FBI hostage negotiator and the author of Never Split the Difference (published in Hebrew by Matar as Bli Psharot — "No Compromises: Negotiate as if Your Life Depends on It"). This second listen sharpened, for me, just how important it is to acknowledge negativity as a way of creating breakthroughs in relationships — because what is a relationship, if not an endless opportunity for negotiation?
Voss emphasizes that people tend to avoid acknowledging negativity in negotiation or in relationships because they're afraid it will make the problem worse, or hand power to the other side. He argues that this is a fundamental mistake, because ignoring negativity only lets it grow, which breeds distrust or resistance.
People are afraid to acknowledge negative emotions, worries, or negative perceptions because they believe that naming the problem might amplify it. It's natural that I'd be afraid that if I told my partner, "I know you're angry that I forgot to ask about your important meeting," it would deepen his anger; or that a roommate might avoid telling her flatmate, "I know you think I'm not pulling my weight on cleaning the apartment," just to avoid an argument. A manager might avoid telling an employee, "I understand you feel undervalued since you weren't promoted," out of a worry that it will undermine his authority.
But that's a mistake. Negativity doesn't disappear on its own — it gets worse. Facing it directly neutralizes its emotional charge and builds a foundation of trust. Voss calls this "tactical empathy" — demonstrating an understanding of the other side's perspective without necessarily agreeing with it.
If my husband feels neglected because I'm working long hours, a statement like, "I can see you feel lonely because of how busy I am with work," acknowledges the feeling and defuses the tension. It raises the odds that he'll feel seen by me, and that instead of a defensive argument, an opening for a productive conversation will appear between us. If, as a mother, I see that my son is frustrated because I won't let him play PlayStation when he gets home from Scouts in the evening, but I avoid addressing it, my son's anger is only likely to grow.
If instead I dare to tell him, "I understand that it feels unfair to you that you go to Scouts and get 'punished' by not being allowed to play Fortnite that same day, and that it frustrates you that I'm insisting on this" — acknowledging his frustration will help my son feel understood, even if the rule itself stays in place. If an employee of mine asks for a raise, and as her employer I know I don't have the budget for it, ignoring the issue will only deepen her frustration.
Here too, if I manage to tell her, "I understand that you feel your contribution to the business deserves more recognition, and that it's frustrating to feel undervalued," showing that empathy is, on my part, an act that builds trust — even if I'm not able to grant her request for a raise.
From Confrontation to Validation
Since our minds don't live on some cloud — computational or divine — this process has a biological signature. When people feel that their emotions are being acknowledged, the amygdala (responsible for processing threat) calms down, and the prefrontal cortex (responsible for decision-making) becomes more active. That makes them more open to cooperation and problem-solving.
One reason I went back and re-listened to Voss's book is that, despite the obvious differences, his approach to dealing with negative emotions fits remarkably well with the school of emotion-focused therapy developed by Leslie Greenberg. Voss's approach is meant for negotiation, sometimes between people with opposing goals, while EFT is a therapeutic approach centered on intimate relationships, aimed at healing emotions and changing emotional patterns within a relationship.
Voss stays at the level of naming and validating emotions in order to move the negotiation forward. EFT, by contrast, goes deep into the roots of those feelings, helping people process and rebuild their experiences. Despite the clear differences between them, both approaches emphasize the importance of acknowledging and validating emotion as a means of resolving conflict and creating deeper connection.
Voss emphasizes that negative feelings which go unspoken or ignored keep simmering and block progress in a negotiation. Openly acknowledging those feelings neutralizes their power and builds trust. Greenberg, for his part, emphasizes that emotions are the key to understanding and resolving conflict in relationships. Feelings that are suppressed or left unaddressed lead to defensive behavior, while acknowledging them makes connection and change possible.
Despite my instinctive discomfort with the blunt instrumentality of Voss's negotiating approach, and my own pull toward the way EFT offers a therapeutic framework for working through emotional blocks in deep, personal relationships, I recognize a real synergy between them: the way both approaches emphasize the transformative power of naming and validating negative emotions — whether in the therapy room or at the negotiating table. Both Voss and Greenberg agree that avoiding negative emotions only leaves them simmering longer on the stove, while openly acknowledging them creates trust, resolution, and connection.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




