top of page

Does Every Villain Have Hidden Trauma in Their Past, or Are Some People Just Bad?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Oct 20, 2022
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

My good friend told his mother about his new relationship, and her response was, "She'll leave you in the end too." When I suggested to him that she might be suffering from extreme narcissism, M. was adamant: "You're completely wrong. I diagnose my mother with malice."

M. is one of my closest friends. We've been friends since we were 15, and although an ocean separated us for many years, we never really drifted apart. M. spent long years of gray singlehood, punctuated by heartbreaks. Then, two years ago, M. found love — or it found him. Either way, they have a solid, enduring love.

About a month ago, M. gathered his mother, who is on her deathbed, and his siblings, to tell them that he and his beloved were about to get married. His surprised siblings responded with joy and congratulations. His mother, on the other hand, muttered: "Nonsense — she'll leave you in the end too."

Who says something like that to their own child? Even the toughest people I know could fall apart at the thought of their child getting hurt — so what makes a person act in a way that hurts their own child?

When M. told me about that moment, I dug to the bottom of my knowledge pot and scraped up something about the mother's extreme narcissism. "She's like Livia Soprano, Tony's mother," I said, referencing the show we're both especially fond of.

"No, no. You're completely wrong," M. corrected me. "I diagnose my mother with malice."

I laughed, embarrassed and thoughtful.

M. argued to me, not for the first time, that with all due respect to psychologists, not everything is trauma. "There used to be no psychology and psychiatry," he said, "and everyone knew there was such a thing in the world as people who are simply evil."

The Trauma Paradigm

The thought kept nagging at me long after the conversation ended. Is M. right? "There is no such thing as a bad child, only a child who feels bad," wrote Janusz Korczak, and nearly everyone who identifies with the psychologistic position echoes him. Like Jean-Jacques Rousseau, most psychologists today believe that human nature is fundamentally good. But while Rousseau had a political explanation for the rotten character that marks so many people in adulthood, today's therapeutic community more commonly holds the view that people harm others mainly as a byproduct of defensive behaviors acquired under traumatic life circumstances.

According to some Buddhist conceptions too, violent behavior stems from ignorance and anger. "Human beings are not our enemy. Our enemy is not the other person. Our enemies are the violence, ignorance, and injustice within us and within the other person. When we are armed with compassion and understanding, we are not fighting the other person but fighting our own tendency to invade, conquer, and exploit," wrote the monk Thich Nhat Hanh (of the Vietnamese Zen tradition) in his book Anger, published in 2001 — an important year in the history of anger.

I was already about to file my phone call with M. away as a bittersweet anecdote, but my view shifted when I came across the book Stalking the Soul: Emotional Abuse and the Erosion of Identity by Marie-France Hirigoyen, published in Hebrew in 2002, though written about a decade earlier.

Hirigoyen is a French psychiatrist and psychoanalyst who has grown deeply weary of people like M.'s mother, whom she defines as "perverse narcissists" — a concept parallel to malignant narcissism, an extreme combination of narcissistic personality, antisocial behavior, aggression, and sadism.

"Perversion doesn't originate in a psychiatric disorder," Hirigoyen writes, "but in cold rationality and an inability to see other people as human beings. True, each of us may occasionally resort to a perverse maneuver, but it's the repetition and persistence of it that produce a destructive process."

I think about the four months during which my mother was blocked on my phone, during which I was never once compelled to explain to her how it was possible that she'd called me but I hadn't received the call. "In every 'normal-neurotic' person, perverse behaviors surface momentarily, for instance in moments of anger [...] but after the perverse maneuver, some self-examination usually follows," writes Hirigoyen — and a sigh of relief escapes me.

"The perverse person behaves this way consistently," Hirigoyen stresses, reassuringly. "This is his approach to others and to the world, and he will never doubt his own way. Even if his perverseness doesn't surface for a while, it takes only a binding situation, or being required to acknowledge his share of responsibility, for the perverseness to immediately resurface — because he cannot allow himself to be in doubt. People like this can only exist by breaking another person. Humiliating them grants them their sense of self-worth, and through it, power, and they are highly eager to establish this in the eyes of others and win their esteem and approval. They have neither respect nor compassion for the other; any relationship with the other doesn't interest them. To respect the other means to see them as a human being and to recognize the suffering being inflicted on them."

Hirigoyen emphasizes that perverse types tend to repeat their pattern of behavior across every area of life: at work, in relationships, with their own children — stepping on corpses, twisting knives, and rubbing salt into wounds for their own pleasure — yet this "doesn't stop them from deceiving the people around them and passing themselves off as perfectly ordinary people."

Reading the book in 2022 is a jarring experience, because these days, even the villain in a James Bond movie is a victim of severe trauma. That's the paradigm we live in, and if we can't find trauma in the abuser's past, then instead of questioning the paradigm — as we would if psychology were actually a science — we assume the malice must originate in attachment trauma, or in trauma "by omission": that is, trauma resulting from good things that should have happened during a person's development but never did.

Dr. Gabor Maté, a heart-stealer whom I've written about here more than once before, is one of the well-known presenters of the trauma paradigm — though, to his credit, we should note that he uses it not to cultivate supervillains but to reduce the stigma suffered by addicts and improve the ways we treat them.

Does Every Villain Have Hidden Trauma in Their Past, or Are Some People Just Bad? - illustration

On Malignant Narcissism

Beyond the fact that we go easy on bullies, villains, and people who inflict emotional abuse on others, Hirigoyen finds another serious flaw in the trauma paradigm: the suspicious attitude toward victims. (Incidentally, "the trauma paradigm" is a term of my own coinage, though I believe Hirigoyen would have liked it, given how widespread the concept has become in the years since her book was published.)

The suspicious attitude toward the victim has two common manifestations: the first is the "objective" one, which assumes that just as in almost every car accident all parties involved bear at least some "contributory fault," so too in every relationship, each person contributes their share to the dynamic that leads to the harsh outcome. The second manifestation of victim-blaming, and the more extreme of the two, attributes to the victim a pathological tendency to be drawn to abusive people.

As a couples therapist, I immediately check myself: do I too assume that both sides bear equal responsibility for the violence in a relationship? I don't think so. There have been times — rare ones, luckily — when couples came to my office where one of them fit the description of a "perverse narcissist" — even if I didn't know the term back then — and the other was what Hirigoyen calls "normal-neurotic." In those few cases, I stopped the treatment.

Sometimes, the effective way to end those treatments was to tell the perverse partner that he didn't actually need therapy (which, of course, is what he'd thought all along), and that the only problem was his weak, defective partner — while at the same time whispering to the normal partner that I'd recommend they flee this relationship while they still could (and if they wanted to try to survive it — that wouldn't be with my help).

So what about the trauma paradigm — am I ready to part ways with it? I'd estimate that I'm, as they say, "not there yet." I encounter people, up close, who are missing nothing but a hairless cat curled up in their lap to complete the picture of their wickedness. And yet, when I imagine them roasting in the fires of hell for eternity and then some, those fantasies get pierced by imaginings of their difficult childhoods.

Is this even evidence of my own omnipotent fantasy — that if they're broken, maybe they can be fixed, and if they can be fixed, maybe that's my job? Or is it evidence that I've seen the performance so many times, in which the perverse narcissist presents himself as an ordinary person, that I end up believing he's normal-neurotic just like me — and from there, the rest of my mistakes about him unfold?

I don't know. But in a world where we now understand better the severity of the damage caused by narcissistic parents (see the echoes stirred by the discussion of Galia Oz's book about her father), and the severity of the actions of narcissistic harassers in the workplace (credit here goes to the #MeToo movement), I recommend bringing Hirigoyen's provocative thesis back into the conversation.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page