top of page

Why You Married the Right Person

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Aug 8, 2019
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

If you want a happier relationship, don't blame your partner. Use the pain they cause you to find your childhood wounds and heal them. A special interview with psychologist Les Greenberg, part six

One of the most-read pieces in The New York Times in recent years is an essay by the popular philosopher Alain de Botton called "Why You Will Marry the Wrong Person." De Botton explains that we think we chose our partners because we felt they would make us happy, but what drives the choice is the search for the familiar. In our adult relationships, he argues, we try to recreate the feelings we had in childhood, feelings that, for us, are associated with family.

I suspect de Botton's thesis is popular because it fits the narratives we tell ourselves. My clients often say things like, "It's sad that I married someone who turned out to be as indifferent as my father," or ask me, "Could I have picked a critical partner because my mother was like that?" But unlike de Botton, my instinct is to say these are lovely stories and nothing more. Still, until I met the Canadian psychologist Les Greenberg, I found it hard to argue with the pull of these stories.

EFT therapists are notorious for not being interested in stories. Well, that's a bit of an exaggeration: we aren't interested in stories as a text in its own right that holds the secrets of human suffering. According to the emotion-focused approach, the source of deep psychological suffering is usually not in the present but in old wounds that never healed. I wrote about this in the first part of this interview.

This means that the pain of a client who feels her partner is showing indifference, just as her father was indifferent to her, doesn't stem from the behavior itself. Rather, her husband's apparent indifference tears open an old wound caused by her father's indifference, one that never healed properly. The suffering of a man whose wife is critical of him, as his mother was, doesn't stem from his wife's supposed criticism but from the fact that certain behaviors of hers reawaken the ancient pain caused by his mother's critical behavior.

This difference in the explanatory mechanism also shapes our view of the right way to produce change. De Botton encourages his students and readers to adopt a more forgiving, humorous, and gracious view of themselves and their partners. Yet that isn't the conclusion that follows from his claim, which implies that if you want to be happier in your relationship, you should replace your partner with someone who doesn't resemble your parents.

Emotion-focused therapy's proposal, by contrast, is that if you want to be happier in your relationship, don't blame your partner; use the pain they cause you to find your childhood wounds and heal them. Here I'll pause and hand the floor to Greenberg, so he can explain why emotion-focused psychologists don't attach much importance to narratives of the kind I mentioned.

"EFT therapists really aren't interested in stories of this kind. In this context, it's interesting to learn from studies of what happens when there is damage to the corpus callosum, the part that connects the right and left sides of the brain and allows information to pass between the two halves. When that connection is damaged, there is no communication between the left and right sides of the brain.

"In one well-known study in the field, the researcher showed a patient pictures on a split screen. On the right side was a picture of a pile of snow blocking the path to a house, and on the left, pictures of a baseball bat, a hat, and a shovel. The subject was asked to choose one of the three pictures, and in most cases the subjects chose the shovel.

"When the researchers asked the subjects, 'Why did you choose the shovel?' they gave answers like 'Because I really need a bit of physical activity.' In other words, they weren't aware that what drove them to act was that part of their brain had been exposed to the picture of the pile of snow. I think this is a great example of the idea that we spin stories all the time, but those stories don't necessarily reflect the processes that are taking place, and we don't always correctly identify what truly drives us."

Why You Married the Right Person - illustration

How can we get to the real source of the client's pain?

"Because of the split between the narrative and the truth, in emotion-focused therapy we try to go back to the experience the person actually had and help them live it again. If we touch the emotional essence of the experience, we manage to release the stuck negative emotions and the pain that haunt the person and make them react in unwanted and harmful ways, even years later."

At the center of this therapeutic work is a particular memory, a picture of a situation that happened once or repeatedly, perhaps some traumatic event. How is that different from a story?

"We're very interested in reviving an episodic (event) memory, because such a memory has the qualities of a sensory memory. A client expresses it more vividly than the way he tells a story he already knows, or even the way he tells a story he is weaving in real time to explain himself to himself.

"When clients bring up an episodic memory, the kind that revives an emotional experience that was never properly processed, they usually communicate it through a different kind of language. Through it, clients convey real content from the experience that took place in their emotional world, and that is completely different from how they talk about the feelings that arose from those experiences at a later stage, or the explanations the clients gave those experiences in hindsight."

Greenberg's approach focuses on the experience clients went through rather than on a description of the facts. For example, in therapy, a person reenacts an event in which his father told him he had been fired from his job. The emphasis in therapy is not on the information, which may be undisputed, but on how the father delivered it. Was he drunk and emotionally flooded, blaming the son for the firing? Was he depressed and suicidal, handing the child the emotional responsibility for managing the situation? If we let the client get carried away talking about the experience, we won't reach that actual experience. In emotion-focused therapy, we try to focus not on the plot but on the emotional soundtrack that accompanied it.

In other words, you may have fallen in love with your partner because he is as indifferent as your father, but it's more likely that you fell in love with him because he was good-looking, studied with you at university, and thought you were pretty. The fact that you suffer from his indifference doesn't echo a twist of fate, nor Freud's laughter. It simply reflects the fact that when he is indifferent to you, deep pain that your father's indifference caused you is exposed, and that is what's worth working on.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page