top of page

Why Don't Most Adults Draw?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jan 29
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Most children stop drawing once they discover they can't draw realistically enough. A simple three-minute exercise can bring back a little of that lost magic.

Can you draw? How would you react if someone asked you to draw right now? If your profession doesn't involve drawing professionally, chances are you'd refuse, maybe even cross your arms, as if locking your hands shut to make sure they don't grab a marker against your will.

Why does this happen? At what point do we part ways with drawing, letting it become the sole territory of professionals? I've been thinking about these questions for a few months now, and along the way I got lucky enough to stumble onto the work of the important American comics artist Lynda Barry. Her lectures and workshops on the subject have shown thousands of people that you don't need anyone's permission to draw — work for which she even won a MacArthur Fellowship.

Barry, who works with four-year-olds and with college students, and is interested in the encounters between them and how those encounters can cross-pollinate each other, says most children stop drawing around age eight or nine, once they discover they can't draw a nose or a pair of hands realistically enough for their own taste. Around that age, drawing starts becoming the territory of the kids who “draw well.” In that parting of ways, she stresses, we lose an enormous amount.

Because early on, drawing and writing aren't all that different from each other. When we learn the alphabet, we're drawing the letters — we're drawing the shapes that magically represent our name. We aren't writing them. At the start, drawing, like the other arts, is such an important part of a child's development that a parent who notices their child isn't drawing, singing, dancing, or inventing stories or plays might, quite reasonably, worry about it. So why, Lynda Barry asks, when adults stop engaging with the arts, does no one worry about that?

Starting From a "Dirty" Page

Personally, measuring whatever comes out of my hand in terms of “beauty” was probably the main thing holding me back. But the more I let myself go deeper into visual worlds, the more I realize there are far more meaningful measures than beauty. Putting marker to paper (or an iPad pencil to an iPad) has other significant dimensions beyond simply being pleasing to look at.

The first is personal expression, and the second is touching another person. Each of these gets lost in a different way as we grow up, and it seems to me we might be able to reframe how we understand both of them, in a way that could let more people give themselves permission to draw, doodle, illustrate, or whatever you want to call it.

The first, as I said, is personal expression. As adults, I think, we tend to picture personal expression as a process that begins with understanding what we have to say, and continues with formulating the message and expressing it. But that's not the only route. Many artists and writers don't start with a clear, well-defined idea, and don't treat putting it into practice as, well, execution. Very often the process is dialogic — between the paper and the artist, between the hand and the artist, between the pencil and the writer, and so on.

When I sat down to write this column, for instance, I knew I wanted it to deal with the psychological benefits of engaging with art in adulthood, but I hadn't laid out all the arguments in an orderly way beforehand. I trusted that I'd thought about the subject enough, read enough, listened and talked about it enough, that once I started writing, the ideas themselves would carry me forward too, not just the other way around. In a similar way, the hand has a mind of its own, and many artists never start from a blank page — they actually seek out a surface that's a little dirty or crumpled, so something out there can get them talking.

In other words, if you want to enjoy the psychological boost that artistic activity can offer, you don't have to wait for an idea to arrive. You can let your hand lead you. Try it yourself — put a pen in your hand and see what happens. And I actually have an even better idea.

Why Don't Most Adults Draw? - illustration

Catching the Monster

Lynda Barry has an exercise she describes in her interviews. I tried it with my son, who's a serious drawing refusenik, and it worked better than I expected. I know it's a cliché, but I'm telling you: if it worked for us, it'll work for you too. You need at least two participants for this exercise, and it goes like this: each participant scribbles a small squiggle, in any color, on a piece of paper. Then the participants swap papers with each other.

Once each participant has in front of them a piece of paper with a squiggle they didn't make, everyone has exactly three minutes to turn the squiggle in front of them into a monster. After three minutes, everyone stops, and they show each other their monsters.

The next stage is especially funny, and it's also timed at just three minutes. In this second stage, everyone draws their monster's two parents. You'll be amazed at how intuitively the human brain reverse-engineers an answer to the question of what two creatures could possibly have produced the monster in front of you. The part where everyone shows each other their drawings is especially fun and funny.

In the exercise's third stage, again timed at three minutes, everyone now draws their monster as it was when it was small. This delightful exercise completely diverts the brain from the question of “beauty,” partly thanks to Lynda Barry's sheer genius in assigning us to draw a “monster” — by definition, an object that isn't supposed to be pretty.

But it's also in the way the exercise is structured: we're never sitting in front of a blank page with a big task. We start by sitting in front of a blank page with a tiny task (a squiggle or a doodle), and then, once the task grows a little (draw a monster), we're no longer facing a blank page. The exercise's time limit also frees us from the burden of defining the message, and lets us discover that our own hand has a mind of its own.

Letting the Image Go

The exercise is also a good introduction to the second beneficial aspect of drawing — its ability to touch another person. It does this because we do it together, and we respond to each other's drawings not with the usual clichés, but in an experiential, unguarded way. The whole history of the bar we set for ourselves before showing our work to others is rooted, among other things, in Barry's account of a mistake many parents make — one worth noticing so we don't reproduce it and pass it on to the next generation.

She says that when the four-year-olds she works with in her workshops start drawing, the vast majority of parents do one of three things: give the child instructions, gush over everything the child does, or ignore the child completely and disappear into their phones.

Imagine, she says, going on a date with someone, and for the entire evening your date either gave you instructions, gushed over you, or was buried in their phone — what good could possibly come of that? In other words, we're completely absent while our kids are experimenting with drawing, and by being absent, we help entrench mistaken ideas about what role art is supposed to play in our lives.

One of the defining moments in Barry's own development, she says, was a moment when she showed her college teacher a drawing and said about it, “I don't like it.” Her teacher's response was: “That's not your business.” That answer shook Barry's entire worldview, and I'm happy to say that hearing her tell that anecdote shook mine too.

In that counterintuitive response, the teacher was telling her something about the existence of a world of images. That world exists separately from our biographical one. It existed before us and will exist after us. In purely psychological terms, this might be Jung's world of archetypes. Every piece of work that comes out of our hands is a citizen of the world of images. As such, we no longer get to “decide” about it.

It may well have a role to play in the world for whoever ends up looking at it, in a way we don't quite have the ability to predict or understand. As Barry puts it, “we don't have to like how our liver looks for it to function well.” True, it's not a perfect analogy, but if there's one thing Barry is perfect at, it's encouraging each and every one of us not to be perfect, in an effort to help us live lives that are far more whole, joyful, and connected.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page