top of page

Why Do Men React More Severely to Infidelity Than Women?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Feb 7, 2019
4 min read

Most affairs break a relationship apart emotionally, but a marriage has a harder time surviving a wife's infidelity than a husband's. There are several reasons for this, and they point to the need for a change in how we think

Last month, this health section ran a news item reporting that researchers at McGill University in Canada found that men remember experiences of pain more vividly than women do, and as a result are more stressed and more sensitive to pain than women when they return to a situation in which they previously experienced it. The findings are preliminary, but they are certainly consistent with other studies showing that women of childbearing age are less sensitive to pain than men of the same age, which of course makes a great deal of evolutionary sense, since childbirth is painful.

In this column I want to use that study to reflect on the possibility that men's sensitivity to pain, and the tendency toward hypervigilance that follows from the memory of pain, are two of the factors that shape how men and women react when they discover that their partner has had an affair.

Surveys and studies conducted in different countries around the world, and I see this in my own clinic too, have shown that couples trying to recover from an affair face a harder road when it was the wife who had the affair than when it was the husband. Correspondingly, the chances of divorce are greater when the wife has cheated on the husband.

There are many reasons for this. One is that we live in a patriarchal society, and even in the era of #MeToo there is still an atmosphere of "boys will be boys," which means women may suffer less damage to their self-image when a partner cheats on them than a man does when he faces his partner's infidelity.

I'm not saying women would do better to take infidelity more seriously. What I am saying is that some men may be able to understand why their partner developed a romantic relationship outside the marriage. But they internalize society's judgment so harshly that the blow to their self-image, to their masculinity, doesn't let them get past the crisis, even after the emotional rupture has already healed.

Another reason women recover from a husband's infidelity better than men do in the reverse case is that many women attach more importance to emotional experiences than to sexual ones. Add to that the fact that most affairs by married men (as far as we know, of course, since the information we manage to collect is obviously very partial) are in the end mainly sexual, and we get a picture in which the kind of affairs men have doesn't hurt women where they are most sensitive.

Why Do Men React More Severely to Infidelity Than Women? - illustration

What happens when a woman has an affair? There are two possibilities: 1. The affair is only sexual. 2. The affair is also emotional. At this point it's easy to see why the relationship is in trouble either way: if the affair was only sexual, the blow to the male ego and to the man's social image may be especially severe. And if the affair wasn't sexual but emotional, there's a good chance the woman won't want to return to the marriage, because she puts more emphasis on emotional experiences.

In short, even before we factor in the possibility that men are more sensitive to the memory of pain, we know that men are more sensitive to the injury of infidelity. The combination of these things is genuinely dangerous to women, and there is no justification for it! One example is the case of Maurice Azoulay, in which a man was sentenced to 25 years in prison for murdering his wife and her lover after suspecting she was cheating on him with the neighbor. His central defense claim was that the neighbor had provoked him by kissing his wife in front of his eyes.

On appeal to the Supreme Court, the panel of justices considered whether Azoulay could invoke the provocation defense, which would reduce the offense from murder to manslaughter. Court president Aharon Barak accepted the appellant's claim, and wrote in the ruling: "The blood of the average Israeli man, and of the average Israeli woman, may boil when he or she sees a spouse or partner in an act of infidelity."

That is exactly the opposite of what I mean! Many couples face infidelity and affairs and try to rebuild their marriages after crises of trust, so it's important to look at the gender differences in how we approach this complex challenge in a layered way.

Looking at the bigger picture, this is another example of our need for the kind of feminist thinking presented by the psychologist Carol Gilligan, which can help men reconnect with the parts of their personality that they were required to cut off in order to meet patriarchy's terms of acceptance. On the clinical level, it often requires working with the husband's internalized voices that refuse to accept that part of him also wants to forgive, or is able to connect to his partner's vulnerability, to put the children's wellbeing first, or to hold some other moral and emotional complexity.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page