Not Every Problem Is a Failure to Explain: When We Refuse to Accept Someone Else's Choice
Updated: Oct 22
We're convinced that if we just find the right words, our partner, child, or parent will change their behavior. But often, the urge to keep explaining comes from our own difficulty accepting what they're already telling us through their actions
These days, when I barely remember anything anymore, I still remember that one day on the open psychiatric ward at Beth Israel Hospital in New York (it no longer exists under that name; it's since been absorbed into another city hospital). One of the first tasks assigned to us doctoral students was to conduct intake interviews with people who walked into the ward straight off the street, with no formal referral.
I remember a Chinese man in his thirties who sat down across from me and my colleague (we worked in pairs), and no matter what we tried, we couldn't get anything out of him about what had brought him to the ward. We went to our supervisor and told him about the man, who'd come straight from Chinatown (he had at least written down the address), and explained that a language barrier was keeping us from completing what's known as the "intake." "Schizophrenia," our supervisor ruled, without even stepping out of his office to see the man.
We stared at him in disbelief, and he said something to me that has stayed with me ever since: "When it comes to mental health, there's no such thing as a language barrier." He asked us to think of times we'd seen children who didn't speak the same language still managing to communicate with each other, and explained: "People with no cognitive impairments always manage to communicate with one another. Since neither of you has any cognitive problems, if you can't communicate with this man, the problem is probably on his end. And if it's severe enough that a 30-year-old can't get his basic needs across, my money is on schizophrenia. The language difference is just confusing you."
He turned out to be right, of course, and I remember this story partly because it connects to one of the most deeply rooted illusions in human interaction — one that I, my friends, and my patients keep falling back into again and again: the belief that everyone's thoughts and behavior are based on information. From that belief follows the idea that if someone acts against their own best interest (as we understand it), then simply supplying the missing piece of information will make them see the light.
Enlisted in Explaining
In the clinic and in my private life, I see people spend hours hunting for the exact phrasing, the perfect analogy, or the single most airtight, winning argument that will finally bring someone back on track. Take an example that's nowhere near rare enough: a 40-year-old woman who believes that if she could only find a better way to explain to her partner the urgency of her biological clock, he would finally commit to the relationship, instead of insisting that things need to improve first, before he can start a family with her.
For hours on end, she debates the subject with her friends, with him, and with her psychologist, assuming that the guy simply doesn't grasp the linear, unforgiving nature of female fertility, or that he doesn't understand how the negative loop their relationship is stuck in is burning through precious time.
Or take the father watching his 40-year-old son, wondering why this grown man can't grasp a simple boundary like "mind your own business," instead of endlessly meddling in the lives of his adult sisters. The father assumes his son is blind to the friction he's creating, and keeps lecturing him, again and again, about his mistake.
In these cases, and in many others, the starting assumption is that when a person we depend on makes a bad decision, it's because they don't truly understand the situation. So we enlist ourselves for the mission. We explain it again and again, we have exhausting heart-to-hearts around the kitchen table late into the night (or over WhatsApp), but in practice we usually don't manage to move the needle at all. And even when we do, the rebound back to the old behavior is only a matter of time.
Because aside from the rare, innocent case of a toddler reaching for a hot pie for the very first time, adults generally don't get things wrong for lack of information. By the time we reach adulthood, our brains can already predict the taste of most foods before we even put them in our mouths. In the same way, we also understand the costs of our own decisions, even when we go around releasing all sorts of statements that make us sound naive, or like people who just need to be set straight.
The truth is that the boyfriend who won't commit to his 40-year-old girlfriend already knows everything there is to know about the biological clock. And when she wants to drag him to her psychologist so the psychologist can drum some sense into him, she's really using "logic" as a disguise for her own refusal to accept her partner's conflicting wishes. When she hears him say, "we need to work on the relationship first," she translates that into a cognitive failure — he simply doesn't grasp the linear, unforgiving nature of a woman's fertility past 30.

The Other Side Has Already Chosen
Put simply, she'd rather believe the other person is stupid than acknowledge that he's autonomous. In this case, the guy understands the biology perfectly well — it isn't even that complicated. He's simply made a conscious, conflicting choice, but he's too much of a coward to admit it outright.
The truth is that he prefers his own immediate emotional security and his own ambivalence over her timeline. She, and any of us standing in her position, chooses to believe that the other person is blind to the consequences of his actions, because admitting that he sees everything perfectly clearly means admitting that he's looking straight at us and choosing himself. In her case, choosing not to budge.
At bottom, this is nothing more than an emotional barricade fighting fiercely to protect the psychological status quo. In the boyfriend's case, his refusal to move toward starting a family isn't evidence of some failure to explain things properly. It's an active defense mechanism, passive-aggressive and thoroughly maddening, sure, but a defense nonetheless, against his own deep ambivalence about the relationship.
Walking toward the wedding canopy or the delivery room means stepping into a reality he's terrified of, but getting up and leaving would force him to accept becoming an object of hatred to the woman he's abandoning, a woman he's still attached to.
The paralysis, disguised as an insistence on "working on the relationship first," as though they had all the time in the world, functions as the perfect shield. It lets him avoid a shattering emotional confrontation. You can see the exact same architecture of denial in the father whose son keeps meddling in his sisters' lives.
Contrary to what the father believes, the son isn't blind at all. Even if we don't know exactly what's going on under the hood, we do know that he's overinvolved because that involvement is serving some essential psychological function. Maybe it gives him an artificial sense of worth and authority. Maybe it's a distraction from the chaos of his own life. The meddling is his shield against whatever he'd have to feel if he took a step back and actually started minding his own business.
It's Not a "Breakdown" in Communication
So why do we keep doing this, despite all the evidence that it doesn't help? First of all, when we frame the problem as a failure to explain, we automatically grant ourselves (with no proof required) the more intellectually and morally superior position in the relationship. We tell ourselves that we're the responsible, rational adult in the room, patiently waiting for the other side to absorb the insights we've so beautifully packaged for them.
But I think what matters far more is that treating an interpersonal crisis as a "communication breakdown" (how many relationship crises start out labeled "communication problems" and end in a breakup?) gives us the illusion of control. If the other person simply doesn't understand, then the problem is technical, and can, in principle, be solved with better phrasing or a sharper metaphor. It's a frustrating thought, but it's a lot more comfortable than the realization that if they do understand, and still choose not to change, then we're the ones who need to decide whether to walk away from the problem or accept it.
So when we catch ourselves opening someone's eyes for the thousandth time, or scrambling to invent new ways to make them "understand" our point of view, we need to ask ourselves: what is the action we're actually refusing to take? Are we refusing to set a real boundary ("either we start trying to get pregnant, or we separate")? Or are we refusing to acknowledge the problem itself ("my grown son is infantile and controlling, and he's avoiding dealing with his own issues")?
Because if we accept the fact that the other person already has all the information, and still chooses to act exactly as they do, we'll be forced to confront who they actually are, not who we wish they were. We'll be forced to look at their actions, rather than their promises or our own explanations, as the only real indication of their intentions.
Between people who are mentally and cognitively healthy, there's really no need to say things more than once. But giving up the argument is itself an act of mourning, mourning grounded in accepting what the other person is telling us through their actions, and in deciding on our own next step based on reality as it actually is.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




