top of page

Why Do Couples Fight About the Dumbest Things?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Sep 20, 2016
6 min read

The answer is buried somewhere back in childhood.

An evening that could have been lovely falls apart, and you don't even know why. Picture this: you walk in the door, you've been looking forward to the evening all day, you finish up a call, but the moment you look up at your girlfriend and she asks whether you remembered to buy dog food, you already know this evening has gone sideways. From your perspective, the girlfriend, it's not so different. You also got home after a long day — school, say — and then helped a friend move apartments on top of it. You were also looking forward to seeing him that evening, to a kiss, to watching an episode of something together on the couch. But the second he walks in and you see his head buried in his phone, everything comes flooding up at once, and you watch this evening get sucked into yet another one of your exhausting fights. It's demoralizing, because you've already talked about this so many times, tried setting all kinds of ground rules, each of you said what you needed from the other — and yet here's another wasted evening.

The subject, of course, doesn't really matter. Sometimes the fight is about dog food; other times you're fighting about how many hours she spends with her friends; sometimes it's about the way he does or doesn't treat his parents; sometimes the subject is what to do on Saturday; and sometimes, on the surface, it's about the fact that one of you is working too much. But if we could watch you both on a screen, with the sound turned down, we'd see, from the outside, that it's always the exact same fight. Which raises the question: if the subjects don't actually matter, what are you really fighting about?

Leslie Greenberg and Sue Johnson, who together and separately developed Emotionally Focused Therapy for Couples (EFT), spent years watching video recordings of hundreds of couples, and concluded that the fight is always, at bottom, about the relationship itself. In other words, the fight arises whenever we feel that the bond between us and our partner is under threat, and that, as a result, we ourselves are under threat too. That felt threat to the relationship pushes each of us to reach for the defense system we developed in childhood, and the fight is really nothing more than the collision between my defense system and my partner's.

At the foundation of this approach lies the assumption that each of us, already in childhood, developed an emotional strategy that helped us cope with threatening situations characteristic of our family of origin. For example: a child with a stormy, melodramatic, overwhelming mother might develop a coping style marked by a poker face, rationality, and tight self-control in response to her; while a girl with a depressed, distant, listless father might develop a coping style marked by clowning around, hyperactivity, distraction, and nagging.

EFT's starting assumption is that these strategies prove themselves useful in childhood, helping children cope with a felt threat to the bond with their parents, and with a threat to the self more broadly. The difficulty begins once these children grow up, enter a romantic relationship, and keep using those same ancient strategies to try to protect the relationship — and themselves.

Let's go back to the ruined evening we opened with. Say that after a rough patch, our young woman has really been looking forward to an evening with her partner. But when he walks in, at the exact moment she wants to see his eyes light up at the sight of her, she instead sees his eyes glued to his phone. According to EFT, the threat to the relationship she experiences in that moment — her sinking feeling that her attachment needs are, once again, not going to be met — triggers her to immediately activate the ancient strategy she once used to jolt her own father out of his emotional frozenness, and she starts nagging him. In other words, when she asks her partner whether he remembered the dog food, she isn't doing it to annoy him — she's doing it to pull him out of his phone, to connect him back to her, to bridge the distance she feels has opened up between them.

But what's going on for him in that same moment? He, for his part, can see that she's upset, even though she's still trying to hide it. On the surface, she's simply asking whether he brought the dog food, but he recognizes her tone, and he knows it spells trouble for him. Like her, he also senses that his fantasy of a fun evening together isn't going to happen — and worse, that a small hurricane might be about to break out in their rented apartment, dog and all. This threat triggers the coping pattern he once used, as a child, to survive his own mother's emotional breakdowns, and he goes quiet and withdraws into himself. He's not doing this to ignore her, and certainly not to drive her crazy. He's doing it to give her time to calm down, and also to avoid making things worse, because from his life experience, this is a lose-lose situation: if he answers her, he'll get himself into trouble, because he'll never manage to say the right thing; and if he stays silent, she'll just get more upset.

Why Do Couples Fight About the Dumbest Things? - illustration

And what happens to her when he freezes up? Remember her own frozen father? That's right — she simply doubles down on her efforts to thaw him out and pull him closer. The problem is that she does this in a way that only intensifies his desire to disappear and withdraw until the storm passes. The sad result is that two people who, at bottom, simply wanted to enjoy each other's company, and who each did their best to protect the relationship, end up licking their wounds alone, each in their own corner.

The first step in the EFT approach, then, is understanding the couple's specific "loop": what each partner's emotional strategy is, why it made perfect sense way back when, and how it's now leading them both into a dead end.

The better we understand how a couple gets tangled up, the more we can gradually help them find their way out of the tangle. The mechanism for getting unstuck, according to this approach, rests on the assumption that exposing our initial vulnerability creates closeness. In other words: in the first stage, the therapist helps me hold, within myself, my own vulnerable feelings — the sense of being insulted, rejected, abandoned, dependent, sad, weak, jealous, anxious, and so on. This is a critical stage, based on the insight that our emotions divide into primary emotions, which are hard for us to bear, and secondary emotions, which we connect to far more easily, and which are usually the ones we show our partner when we're in defense mode (for example: my partner feels hurt by me, but he can't bear his own vulnerability, so he moves very quickly to expressing anger instead — an emotion he's far more comfortable with).

The next stage is helping me share those feelings with my partner. And after that, the goal is for me to learn to share those feelings with him the moment I feel the initial threat to our bond — before I reach for my metaphorical "gun" and arm myself with my old childhood strategies. As we see in the clinic, each of these stages has the effect of drawing the couple closer together.

The ability to share from a place of vulnerability doesn't develop overnight, and it doesn't come about through intellectual explanation either — it develops through the creation of a safe atmosphere in therapy, through a great deal of empathy and validation, and through gradually building trust within the relationship. These conditions create a gradual calming between the partners, and it's this calm that allows each of them to take the risk of exposing their core pain to the other.

The EFT treatment process lets a couple "practice" this new way of coping, and the goal is to bring both partners to a point where, in any moment of threat or difficulty, they're able to catch themselves in real time. That is, instead of each one loading their weapon and aiming it at the other, they learn to fight their shared loop together, to stay close, and to handle whatever life happens to throw at them.

With the help of therapy, they discover that the problem doesn't actually lie with either of them — that the loop of defenses itself is the real external enemy of the relationship. When the process succeeds, each partner learns to recognize the moment they're being pulled back into those ancient places of hurt and defensiveness. And each partner also learns to reach out to the other, to help them too, so that neither one slides too far down and loses touch with reality — the reality in which the person we love doesn't represent that same ancient threat we experienced in childhood, but is instead welcomed as the separate, loving being who shares our life with us.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page