top of page

What Kind of Relationship Leads to Crisis — and Is It Yours?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Feb 20, 2018
6 min read

There are a handful of relationship profiles. I call them the Oyster, the Ice Cream, the Roommates' Table, Broken Heart (Right Side), Broken Heart (Left Side), and the Pizza

I don't know what love is, but it seems to me the concept covers at least four distinct aspects of intimacy: attraction, belonging, understanding, and warmth. Looked at separately, the first three aspects characterize three different kinds of relationships: attraction belongs to romantic partnership, belonging belongs to family, and understanding belongs to friendship. Warmth and emotional expression are relevant to all the close relationships in our lives.

The link between the different kinds of intimacy and the different character of each type of relationship makes sense once you consider the different survival function each relationship serves. Attraction is critical to a romantic partnership because the survival function of that bond is producing children. Belonging is critical to how a family (as a multigenerational unit) functions, because its evolutionary purpose is caring for the vulnerable — whether children or elders. And understanding is the emotional foundation of friendship, because the purpose of friendship, viewed through the lens of survival, is cooperation — whether that means hunting and gathering, or launching a startup, or raising children.

There may also need to be an inverse correlation between each type of relationship and the kind of intimacy that characterizes it. Between parents and children, for example, physical attraction can exist, and maybe that's even natural at certain stages — but for the family unit to survive, that attraction needs, at other stages, to stay at a low dose. At a high dose, cross-generational attraction within a family destroys the aspect of taking responsibility for the vulnerable. In a similar way, attraction can exist within friendships, and again, maybe that's natural too, but if the attraction runs too high, it can overshadow (for a variety of reasons) the ability to cooperate, and the relationship is likely to either turn into a romance or fall apart. Following this line of thinking, some would say (Esther Perel, no names) that too much belonging or family-like closeness within a couple snuffs out romantic love. In other words, a couple's relationship can hold a sense of belonging as long as it comes in a low dose — but at a high dose, that sense of responsibility kills off desire.

But as an emotionally focused couples therapist, I believe that what's unique about romantic love is that the more fully all the types of intimacy are present in it, the better it gets. In other words, if I feel both attracted and attractive, both understanding and understood, and on top of that I feel a sense of belonging or family-ness — meaning I feel responsible for my partner and also protected by him — then our relationship will thrive. To simplify the picture, here's how I picture the four axes and what the ideal profile looks like:

Of course, none of this is meant as a scientific model — these are just symbols that work as organizing metaphors for the kinds of difficulties many couples struggle with. Opening up the discussion into four separate layers of intimacy is useful when couples present a story or a complaint that seems, on its face, to contain a big contradiction or a confusing ambivalence. These are couples who, say, cooperate beautifully on running the household and genuinely value each other, yet both feel hurt and unimportant to their partner; or couples who have great sex and plenty of affection, and still feel deeply distant from each other, and in pain.

On the face of it, that looks like a contradiction. But when you look at these couples through the lens of the four axes, you can usually see that even these apparent contradictions sort themselves into a limited set of difficulties — specific profiles. I call them the Oyster, the Ice Cream, the Roommates' Table, Broken Heart (Right Side), Broken Heart (Left Side), and the Pizza. These profiles aren't problematic in themselves. As long as both partners agree on the kind of relationship they want, everything's fine — we don't treat people who aren't asking for help. The pain starts when the relationship's profile stops matching the emotional needs of the partners. So where do you fall?

Oyster Mode

If there's a lot of desire between you and a flood of smoldering WhatsApp messages, but your friendship has never really been tested, and you don't think of each other as family, you're in Oyster mode. Maybe you're having a secret affair, or maybe you're hoping you've found the love of your life. You can go right on slurping oysters and sipping champagne with pleasure. The trouble will only start if one of you wants to build real friendship and mutual responsibility, and the other one doesn't meet you there. Your odds of ending up in couples therapy are low, because without a sense of family and without friendship, you won't feel committed enough to the process.

Ice Cream Mode

If you're a couple who feels desire, emotional warmth, and real friendship toward each other, but you still don't feel like family, you're in Ice Cream mode. If this is causing you pain, know that this particular kind of emotional pain doesn't only show up among young couples hesitant to take the next step. You might also be a more established couple trying to weave together a "second chapter" that includes kids from a "first chapter." A conflict of loyalties between the children from a first marriage and the future family you're building can become an obstacle that makes it hard to build a full, harmonious partnership. If you're a same-sex couple where each of you has your own biological children, you may find yourselves facing a similar struggle. Unfortunately, couples like you, in Ice Cream mode, are in a fairly fragile spot, because there usually aren't many outside pressures holding you together. But if you come to therapy, there's real potential to help you.

The Roommates' Table

If your relationship looks, from the outside, like it has everything, but you're walking around with a lot of emotional pain and a sense that something crucial is missing, you may have landed at the Roommates' Table. There's friendly understanding between you, you manage to check off every household task, you share real, substantial responsibility for your lives together, and maybe your sex life isn't even bad — but you're both wandering through an emotional desert, in the deepest sense. Each of you is starving for warmth and affection, and feels like you're only getting crumbs. A relationship like this can benefit a great deal from individual therapy for each of you — or at least for whichever one of you is reading this piece...

What Kind of Relationship Leads to Crisis — and Is It Yours? - illustration

Broken Heart, Right Side

Congratulations — your profile is the single most common one among couples who end up in couples therapy. Couples like you managed to move on from Oyster mode — that is, head-over-heels infatuation — into Broken Heart mode, without ever building real friendship or real understanding between you. You're warm, loving (in the everyday sense of the word), and drawn to each other, but you're stuck in an endless loop that makes it hard to enjoy the relationship the way you could. It's critical to address a difficulty at this stage, because the next stage is a lot harder.

Broken Heart, Left Side

There was attraction between you originally, but repeated misunderstandings and emotional hurts have worn it down. It's hard for you to get physically close to your partner, either because you're afraid of them, or because they come across as endlessly critical, or because they ignore you. If there's still warmth and cooperation between you, you may be holding the relationship together out of family commitment — but in our society, where a couple's bond is seen as one where attraction is essential to its continued existence, sooner or later one of you is going to want more. Which puts you at high risk of breaking up.

Pizza Mode

When nothing is left between you except practical cooperation and family responsibility. Your relationship is heading for a major crisis once the kids grow up, when there's no one left around who needs a lice comb-out and a pizza order.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page