top of page

What Is the Main Problem With the World's Fastest-Growing Approach to Couples Therapy?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 18, 2019
4 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Secure attachment underlies many therapeutic approaches, but it isn't the whole story. Psychologist Les Greenberg explains why establishing identity and attraction is just as critical to a good relationship as feeling secure in the bond. A special interview, part three

Every few years I learn something new that makes me want to refund all my clients. The last time I felt that thrilling, embarrassing sensation of a professional growth spurt was during a month of advanced training with Prof. Les Greenberg, who came to Israel to train therapists in Emotion-Focused Therapy. We talked at length, and I wrote up our conversations in the previous columns, which dealt with how emotion-focused therapy relates to arriving at insight, and with the fact that coaching offers a change in thinking patterns but doesn't produce deep emotional change.

As an emotion-focused couples therapist, I shouldn't have found this training so exciting. The psychologist Sue Johnson, who developed the better-known approach of emotion-focused couples therapy, which places secure attachment at the foundation of healthy couple relationships, was Prof. Greenberg's student and acquired her theoretical and clinical grounding as his protégée. But it turns out that a few things were lost in Johnson's translation of Greenberg's emotion-focused therapy into couples work, and those are what I discussed with him.

What was lost in attachment-based couples therapy?

"Attachment is not love. Secure attachment is often one part of a cluster of ingredients that create a loving bond, but it is not the only factor, nor a sufficient one. The two other critical factors are my sense of identity and the attraction I feel toward my partner. It's true that we want to feel secure in the relationship, and it's true that it matters for me to know my partner is there for me and that I can turn to her when I need support. But I also need her to validate my sense of identity and to see me in a positive light. I need her gaze to fill me with pride rather than shame.

"I work with couples, and often one of them says: 'I know you love me, you just don't see me.' If you work in an approach that makes the level of security in the bond the only critical condition, you have no theoretical tools for addressing this. And that's because it simply isn't true: we need to feel seen. By the way, this is also true of the bond between parents and children. A child can feel very secure and know that his mother protects him, yet he can also feel completely misunderstood, feeling that she doesn't see who he really is.

"The fact that I want the relationship to preserve and build my identity, alongside wanting it to be secure, creates power struggles within couple relationships. I don't think these struggles stem from a need to control others; they revolve around the questions of who leads, who follows, and who is right. This is an example of how my view differs from an attachment-based view, in which one partner's need to be right stems from his insecurity, that is, from feeling unsafe in the relationship.

"In the research-based school I work in, the wish to be right can be based on the need to preserve identity, even if I don't want to feel independent of and separate from my partner. All I want is for my wife to see me as a good person, and to know that if I love playing tennis or riding a motorcycle, she'll validate both my identity and my hobby. That is not an aspect of secure attachment but a separate need, one that a good couple relationship should fulfill."

What Is the Main Problem With the World's Fastest-Growing Approach to Couples Therapy? - illustration

According to attachment-based couples therapy, secure attachment is the base that allows a person, and therefore an infant, to explore his environment. Is that a mistake too?

"It is indeed another mistake. Secure attachment is not the answer to everything, and in my view, a theory that places one motivation or one definition of human behavior above all others can't be right. There must be more than one motivation explaining how we act within relationships, and it's clear that exploring the environment is part of our hardwiring because it is critical to our survival.

"Attachment theory claims that a child will explore his environment if he feels secure, but the truth is that a child will explore it even if he feels insecure. Connecting this to the previous question, I think a secure base is what drives our need to know that our couple relationship will be a safe place for us. But our natural drive to explore also underlies the need for the relationship to shape our identity in a nourishing way."

One of the claims made against Sue Johnson's approach to couples therapy is that a secure bond does not predict a satisfying erotic life. What do you think?

"Sexual attraction is the third foundation on which a good couple relationship rests, together with validation of identity and secure attachment. It is an independent root that cannot be fully explained by the other components. Desire is powerful, and people feel it not only when they feel connected and secure with another person, but in many different situations, even without secure attachment."

Does that mean that when a couple comes to emotion-focused therapy from your school and complains of declining desire, your view is that this is an independent variable that therapy can't influence?

"No. You can definitely influence it in emotion-focused therapy. When people report a drop in attraction, or when they're having an affair behind their partner's back, the reason is often anger at the partner and unresolved feelings. Often, when you touch the root of those underlying negative feelings, the erotic aspect of the relationship improves, because feelings affect sexual desire. But sexual desire, like the need for a positive sense of identity, is still an independent aspect of a good couple relationship."


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page