top of page

What If Polyamory Is Actually a Sexual Orientation?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Dec 6, 2018
6 min read

The couples-therapy world is trying to work out whether polyamory is a problem in the emotional attachment system or a master solution to the ills of monogamy. But both positions may be wrong

"I have nothing against monogamy," Jonathan told me. He and his wife Sarah (not their real names), a married couple in their early thirties, came to my office two and a half years ago and asked me to help them open up their relationship. We laughed at Jonathan's unconventional remark: in a sophisticated, open-minded city like Tel Aviv, it sometimes seems that monogamy is just one more option on the menu. Still, Jonathan and Sarah wanted to know where I stood on polyamory.

"Good question," I said, and told them that open relationships divide the field of couples therapy. The more traditional camp, to which I belong professionally, that of emotionally focused couple therapy from the school of Sue Johnson (EFT), sees polyamory as evidence of a problem in a person's attachment system, which develops mainly in childhood, as he builds his bond with his caregiver.

By EFT principles, the problem lies in the attachment system, the symptom is polyamory, the solution is therapy, and a committed monogamy is a sign of mental health. But the cool kids on the couples-therapy block, led by Esther Perel, turn the pyramid on its head and argue that monogamy is the problem, affairs and infidelity are the symptom, and polyamory, of one kind or another, is the healthy state you can reach by broadening your horizons and acquiring knowledge.

On TV shows such as Wanderlust, polyamory is presented as the most advanced solution to the monogamous syndromes that trouble us all. To many of the people who promote the idea, polyamory is a natural option, just like unprocessed food, which all humans once had access to before everything was ruined by powerful processes of modernization. Like cancer and heart disease, divorce and infidelity are seen as harmful by-products of our unhealthy way of life. Culturally, we're encouraged to go back to nature not only in the kitchen but in the bedroom, too.

"But how do you, personally, feel about polyamory?" asked Jonathan and Sarah, who wanted to know my stance on the matter as a person and not only as a therapist. I admitted I wasn't sure. On one hand, the polyamorous promise (and I'm using the term here in a simplified generalization to mean consensual non-monogamous romantic relationships) of enjoying multiple sexual and romantic partners without casting a shadow over my marriage is normalizing and speaks to my fantasy world, in which, by the way, polyamory is just one of many scenarios. On the other hand, I have no personal interest in polyamorous experiences in reality, just as I have no real interest in having sex in an airplane bathroom, or in making one of the moms from the soccer team my sex slave.

Sadly, even introspection didn't yield a clear answer. I still wasn't sure how to see Jonathan and Sarah's wish to open up their relationship: a sign of flexible, expansive mental health, or an attempt to dodge an attachment problem?

My answers at the time were honest enough to keep Jonathan and Sarah in therapy. Their therapeutic process was completed six months ago, with great success in my view. Jonathan meets other men from time to time, and Sarah has an ongoing relationship with another woman. They're also happy together, raising two beautiful children, and they have great sex with each other.

Even so, getting to know them and other polyamorous couples didn't solve the riddle for me. But now, two and a half years later, I think the problem lies neither in monogamy nor in polyamory but in the way we frame the riddle itself.

What If Polyamory Is Actually a Sexual Orientation? - illustration

In my view, there's a problem with both the "poly" way (that is, Esther Perel's) and the "mono" way (that is, the EFT way) of conceptualizing the subject. Polyamory presents itself as an alternative choice, one that proudly rejects social norms. But if polyamorous discourse interprets this lifestyle as the most advanced solution to a problem caused by an outdated way of life, then that discourse falls into the very same trap of the hierarchical, judgmental worldview it opposes.

At the same time, I find it hard to accept the discourse of emotionally focused couple therapy in this context. EFT declares itself a universal method of treatment, so if Jonathan were a transgender man who had transitioned from woman to man and asked for my help strengthening his bond with Sarah, that would fully meet the EFT standard. But the moment Jonathan and his wife want me to help them strengthen their romantic bonds with more than one person, that's a problem. According to emotionally focused therapy, I should refer them to someone who doesn't practice this approach, or assume they have an unconscious emotional need for a secure monogamous bond and effectively offer them "conversion therapy." In other words, EFT promises to help everyone love whom they want to love, but polyamorous people are left out of the picture.

This theoretical, personal, political and clinical dissatisfaction led me to look for an entirely different way of conceptualizing polyamory. And I think I found one. I believe we shouldn't think of polyamory as an attachment problem, or as a solution to monogamy, but as a kind of unrecognized sexual orientation.

Let me explain before you pounce on the keyboard. I know you can argue that polyamory isn't an "orientation" and isn't focused on "sex," so in principle it can't be a "sexual orientation." But we use the term "sexual orientation" mainly to indicate that a person is attracted to people of the same sex or of the other sex, and so the concept is more layered, as you can see from the T in "LGBT."

I dare say that many of us who are bothered by these issues understand sexual orientation as a concept made up of at least four basic aspects:

1. The biological sex I belong to

2. The gender I belong to

3. The biological sex of the partner I'm attracted to

4. The gender of the partner I'm attracted to

In addition, there are two further central criteria:

1. How I identify sexually. I can, for example, be a woman in gender terms, in a woman's body, attracted to men sexually and in gender terms, but identify as queer.

2. How society treats my sexual identity. Put simply, there's no "S" for straight in LGBT, because a sexual identification as "straight" exposes no one to political or social dangers.

These meta-criteria pave the way for recognizing polyamory as a sexual orientation. Such recognition means adding a fifth criterion to the basic aspects of sexual orientation: the attractive number of simultaneous partners, from my point of view.

Since I reframed the "polyamory question" for myself, I sit in my chair far more comfortably when I work with poly couples. Reconceiving polyamory as a new sexual orientation solves many of the difficulties that challenged me as a couples therapist in this respect.

On the theoretical level, this conceptualization resolves the seemingly unbridgeable tension between Sue Johnson's approach, based on dyadic attachment, and Esther Perel's view that it takes three to tango. As for research, if polyamory is a sexual orientation, we'd do better to develop curiosity about the unique way the attachment system works in polyamorous people than to try to understand the sources of pathology.

On the clinical level, this new perspective calms me. I don't need to market polyamory as a miracle cure for monogamous couples, nor to "convert" polyamorous clients. Instead, just as couples therapists learned to work with LGBT couples, my colleagues and I can learn to work with the unmet attachment needs that exist in polyamorous relationships. On the political level, adding the letter P to LGBT would help one more minority group gain legal protection from discrimination.

Finally, this new conceptualization answers my personal question. Just as I know that fantasies about soccer moms don't indicate that I'm not brave enough to challenge heterosexual norms, and aren't evidence of a flaw in my "straight" identity, so the gap between the place multiple partners can occupy in my imagination and the zero place allotted to them in my life closes and becomes understandable when I think of polyamory not as a problem and not as a solution but as a sexual orientation whose time for recognition has come.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page