What Can the Left Learn From Trump and Netanyahu About the "Charisma Algorithm"?
Updated: Oct 22
Charisma isn't an innate magic trick — it's a psychological formula. Trump and Netanyahu know how to work it. Now the left just needs to find a leader who speaks to emotion, not only to cold logic.
What's unfolding around us sometimes feels like the opening of a dark comic-book movie: a league of the world's villains convening, extremist leaders from every corner of the globe carving up the spoils — which piece of the world falls to Putin, what Trump gets, who gets handed over to China. Humanity itself, ignorant and afraid, stands there waiting to be divided up.
Which raises the sharp question: why do we flock to leaders like these? The answers are surely varied, and we'll keep investigating many of them for years to come (assuming we're not in prison by then). But beyond leaders' ability to cultivate ignorance and feed fear, there's another answer: charisma.
Charisma is, of course, in the eye of the beholder. And yet, to understand that eye — to understand why millions choose to follow one figure and not another — it's worth pausing to ask: what actually is charisma? The word itself was born in ancient Greek, from χάρισμα (charisma), meaning "a gift of grace" or "a divine gift."
The unholy trinity
People tend to think of charisma as a trait belonging only to leaders, but in practice it touches all our lives. Some people feel they don't look good by "objective" standards, and it's precisely the realization that they can project charisma that can shift their whole sense of worth. Others worry they won't manage to stay attracted to one person over time, but looking inward, they may discover that within a long-term relationship, attraction has a lot less to do with looks and a lot more to do with how charismatic — how warm, present and connected — their partner is perceived to be.
In its religious, Christian origin, charisma was considered a power granted to a person from above. In our secular world, charisma is measured along three main axes: how genuinely competent and skilled a person appears, how close, human and well-intentioned toward us they're perceived to be, and how strongly they signal that they're on our side, here and now, rather than distant or self-absorbed.
These axes help explain why Elon Musk is perceived as a cold genius, why Netanyahu manages to project charisma specifically to his own audience, and why Rabin is remembered as a figure who knew how to combine competence with warmth. Musk, for instance, scores high on the competence-and-confidence axis: he's an engineer, an entrepreneur, he builds spacecraft and electric cars, pushing the boundaries of technology. But on the warmth axis, as people say today, "he just doesn't have it." His cool, at times alienating, persona signals that he isn't on our side but on the side of some grand technological vision. The result is admiration without trust or affection.
Bill Clinton, by contrast, is considered a leader who united all three axes almost perfectly: he was politically brilliant, an exceptional rhetorician with impressive maneuvering skills; he radiated a warmth that made him feel close and personal, to the point that even his opponents admitted he made you feel like the only person in the room; and he had a presence that filled any stage he stepped onto. That's how he became one of the most charismatic leaders of the late 20th century.
Barack Obama also managed to combine sharp intellect and complex managerial ability with open body language, humor, empathy and family warmth, alongside a rare presence that turned every speech into an event people could feel part of. Vladimir Putin, by contrast, represents a different formula entirely: high competence and immense presence, but almost zero warmth. His frozen, rigid persona is deliberately maintained as a source of power, and his charisma rests on the image of a cold, strategic ruler.
The magic is in the eye of the beholder
Donald Trump, on the other hand, appears to many to score low on both competence and warmth. And yet he's managed to be perceived as charismatic thanks to a consistent self-presentation as someone who "is on our side and fights for us." In other words, even in the absence of authentic warmth or proven competence, charisma can be manufactured through the illusion of presence and belonging.
Netanyahu in Israel is a clear example of the power of combining warmth and competence — in the eyes of a certain audience. He knows how to appear both capable of leading and understanding of his public's hardships. The warmth he projects isn't universal but targeted: whoever is "inside the camp" gets a deep sense that he's on their side.
Yair Lapid is perceived as scoring high on the competence axis — articulate, experienced, knowledgeable — but his attempts to project warmth are sometimes received as forced, which weakens his charisma. Benny Gantz represents a different challenge: he's perceived as scoring low on both competence and warmth. And finally, Yitzhak Rabin was experienced by many as scoring high on both the competence and the warmth axes, which allowed him to be perceived as a stable, direct, unpretentious leader — and therefore charismatic over the long term as well.
From here we can understand that charisma isn't only innate personal magic, but a combination of three axes — competence, warmth and presence — which, at any given moment and for any given audience, can add up to a different cumulative score. But when we say charisma is "in the eye of the beholder," what we're really saying is that the audience doesn't just judge the leader from the outside — it projects its own emotional needs onto him. Someone experiencing an existential threat will look for a figure who can radiate both human warmth and high competence; someone who feels excluded or shortchanged will look for presence — someone on their side, even if competence or warmth are in doubt.
Which explains why Trump managed to be perceived as charismatic despite scoring low on both warmth and competence: significant parts of the American public saw him as someone fighting for their side. He turned himself into a symbol of "us against the elites." In that sense, the audience "subsidizes," in its own imagination, whatever the leader is missing: if warmth is missing, they can dress him in the image of an uncompromising fighter; if competence is missing, it can be swapped out for the rhetoric of authenticity ("at least he's not a slick politician").

Women of iron and women of ice
But there's a deeper problem hiding here too. The structure of charisma as a combination of competence and warmth works against entire groups within the population. Women, for instance, tend to be stereotypically perceived as high in warmth but low in competence. That's one reason why, in the political arena, they're forced to prove themselves over and over — not just as leaders, but as people who are "truly capable." And the moment they succeed in being perceived as high in competence, they're almost inevitably perceived as cold, lacking warmth.
It's no accident that the nicknames attached to prominent women leaders are "the Iron Lady" for Thatcher, and "the Ice Lady" for Merkel, Hillary Clinton, and Golda Meir too. The very attempt to rise on the competence axis is read as evidence of a low score on the warmth axis. Political or ethnic minorities function in a problematic zone from the outset as well: they're perceived, by default, as "low in competence," and any attempt to emphasize warmth and communal belonging risks being read as weakness. In other words, the charisma map is tilted in favor of the ruling elite.
White men from the elite enjoy a far wider range of motion: they can be both strong and warm, without being penalized for the contradiction between the two axes. You can think of it as a kind of social filter: it's not enough to have personal charisma — you also have to belong to a group that society is willing to grant that title to.
That's why the key to charisma isn't only the combination of competence and warmth, but also the ability to be part of an existing elite while simultaneously radiating human warmth that offers voters a friendly shoulder. This is how we can understand the power of Trump and Netanyahu: both are white men, elitist in many respects — wealth, education, positions of power — but they've managed to build for themselves an image of people who direct warmth toward specific audiences. They speak in a clear "we," allowing themselves to touch, to smile, to signal identification, at least toward their own camp.
Closing the presence gap
If we use the charisma algorithm to say something about the candidates in Israel's next elections, Yair Golan is worth mentioning. He embodies, quite well, both the strengths and the weaknesses of the Israeli left in terms of charisma. On the competence axis, he's nearly beyond dispute: a former deputy chief of staff, with rich security experience, a serious figure who comes across as someone who knows how to lead in extreme situations.
On the presence axis too, he lacks nothing. Golan isn't a "soft egg," unlike many in the current opposition. His direct statements, his assertive body language and his firm stance make him a figure hard to ignore. These two axes, competence and presence, place him relatively high compared to many of his rivals on the left.
And here lies his greatest difficulty too. Golan is often perceived as cold, rigid, even condescending. His controversial statements have reinforced his image as a brave, direct person, but at the same time they've pushed away broad segments of the public, leaving him as someone who speaks almost exclusively to a narrow, ideological core. To succeed in becoming a candidate who can lead not just a camp but an entire nation, he needs to learn to project more empathy, more human closeness, more of a sense that he isn't only fighting for abstract principles but also sees the people themselves.
From here comes the broader conclusion: the Israeli left can't settle for putting forward candidates who are merely talented, experienced or articulate. To produce a charisma that can go up against Netanyahu or figures like him, it needs to put forward a leader — man or woman — who knows how to combine competence with warmth, presence with closeness. That's the central lesson of this map: it isn't enough to be capable or to be right — you also need to look human, to look like you're on people's side, connected to them.
Yair Golan, maybe more than others, demonstrates that gap. If he manages to close it, he could become a significant candidate in the coming elections; if not, he'll remain another strong but distant figure, in a camp still searching for the charisma that will sweep it into power.
But the question of what makes a person charismatic isn't confined to the public arena — it meets us in the bedroom too, and in front of the mirror. People who feel, and perhaps even by "objective" measures are considered, not attractive, thin, wealthy or young enough, can find renewed confidence when they examine their own record and discover that others are drawn precisely to the charismatic energy they project.
And people who worry they won't manage to hold onto attraction over the years may discover that the secret ingredient for erotic tension in a relationship isn't limited to endless novelty, but can grow out of the sense of closeness, warmth and presence the relationship itself produces. In that sense, learning the algorithm of charisma doesn't just help us choose better leaders — it can also help us feel more wanted and more loved in our own personal lives.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




