top of page

Wanted: A Prophet — So We Can Face Our Own Shadow

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 31, 2025
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Jewish identity was built on a fantasy of innocence and a repression of aggression. The shattering of that myth is a chance for real self-reckoning.

In biblical times, the moment we're living through right now would have summoned a prophet. Not one busy figuring out how to turn this or that lemon into lemonade, not holding on through escapism, not choosing to tend to himself instead of his people, and certainly not standing on the cliff behind the bus, pushing it over the edge, passengers and all. This prophet was a person seized by something unbearable: the psychic pain of the people.

A prophet was never a popular figure, one everyone agreed on. He was often a rejected, lonely, even persecuted man. But from the standpoint of social psychology, throughout Jewish history his role was clear: to feel what others couldn't allow themselves to feel. To experience that unbearable knowledge as a kind of revelation, a message arriving from outside himself rather than an idea in his own head, and to deliver to the people and its leadership a clear, cutting message that's hard to escape.

The Israel of 2025 is undergoing a social-psychological rupture of biblical proportions. The war in Gaza continues at an intensity that exceeds what's required for its declared goals, and every clear-eyed Israeli is suffering moral injury over the war crimes being committed in their name. The fate of the hostages — which once marked a moral line the entire nation fell in behind — has been abandoned and turned into raw material for political maneuvering.

The cannibalistic leadership has already finished devouring the flesh of democracy, and is now sucking the bones and licking its fingers. Civic discourse is polarized to the point of collapse, families are falling apart over ideology, and many citizens no longer feel safe at home or abroad. What was once a collective identity built on survival and resourcefulness is now being crushed under the weight of grief, confusion, and a growing sense of moral disorientation. It's no accident that so many say it's "hard to breathe" in Israel.

The Return of the Shadow

Psycho-socially, this is a moment that cries out for a prophetic response. Except the prophetic voice in Jewish culture fell silent long ago — not because it isn't needed, but because of its historical suppression. After the destruction of the First Temple, spiritual authority gradually shifted from the prophets to the priestly class, and later to the rabbis. That shift was also a move from a people that oriented itself through a series of direct revelations (God as a direct manager, calling the people to order through the prophets) to a ritual bureaucracy. From spontaneous truth-telling — which lets you keep a finger on the moral pulse — to institutionalized religion, which naturally starts allocating resources toward preserving its own political power too.

At the psychological level of Judaism as a society, it's important to understand that within this shift, the theological fantasy of being a chosen people, an am segula, also took root and hardened. On one level, this fantasy provided resilience. It preserved identity under persecution. But like any psychological defense, it also came with a price tag: it allowed the Jewish collective to adopt a narcissistic narrative of eternal innocence, always positioning ourselves as the victim and never as the aggressor. The prophetic tradition, which once dared to accuse the people of its own violence, arrogance, and betrayal of the weak, was replaced by a structure that could no longer hold what Jung called "the shadow."

And what can't be held has to be expelled. For centuries, Judaism projected its own aggression onto others. Every trace of cruelty, every lust for control or thirst for power was denied — we recognized it only in the other, and never managed to see it in the mirror. The result was a kind of dangerous moral isolation. For a people so often threatened from outside, this strategy is understandable. But its price is the loss of self-knowledge.

Today, our shadow has come back. Not metaphorically, and not gently. But in full force. Rivers of blood are being spilled — the news from Gaza, the abandonment of the hostages, the contempt for democratic norms. The parts of ourselves we denied are raging like a pipe carrying far more water than it can hold. This isn't only a political problem. It's a psychological and spiritual emergency. The prophetic valve once let us digest some of our own aggression, cyclically converting rage into conscience, grief into clarity — but since it no longer exists, these impulses are erupting without restraint.

Wanted: A Prophet — So We Can Face Our Own Shadow - illustration

A Psychological Reckoning, Please

There's something unbearable about being Jewish right now — not only because of physical fear, but far more so because of the psychic price: the moral injury we absorb as we witness what's being done in our name; the rupture of families who can no longer speak to each other; the rise in antisemitism that leaves us feeling unsafe. But maybe — and this is a paradox worth holding onto — what's unbearable for each of us as Jews may turn out to be an important, healthy turning point for Judaism itself.

Because for the first time in centuries, we're being forced to confront the parts of our identity we long ago projected onto others. Now we're seeing our own capacity for cruelty, for indifference, for blindly joining a cult of violence. For generations, the narrative of being a "chosen people" protected us from the need to reckon with ourselves. But now that defense has broken.

We can't dodge the images from Gaza forever. This still isn't Russia, and Israelis aren't North Korean subjects. Who exactly can we blame for abandoning the hostages? And the assault on democracy? It isn't coming from outside — it's coming from within. The past two shattering years are years in which we, as a Jewish society, are meeting our own psychological structure.

Painful as it is, this may be the beginning of something more whole. Israeli-Jewish society can use this crisis to conduct a psychological reckoning, not only a moral one, of the kind Germany carried out after World War II. We're being forced to confront our national fantasy. A thousands-year-old theological myth, one that suppressed the collective's psychological complexity, has crashed with tremendous force, sending shockwaves around the world, and is now bringing to our shore a tsunami whose scale of destruction we still don't fully grasp.

But perhaps out of the ruins we can begin to build a more mature Jewish identity, with healthier defenses — one that contains both light and shadow, that develops an ethic as a brake on the use of force (instead of a victimhood that justifies it), one that carries an honest self-assessment of what we're capable of, and from which responsibility follows too, toward the weak and toward the other.

Although many are having spiritual experiences right now — in dreams, in visions, or through chemical means — the prophet probably won't return in bodily form. But his role is needed now more than ever. He'll reveal himself in art, in writing, in therapy, in the voices of those willing to speak truth not only to those who hold power, but also to speak truth to the people: that our pain isn't meaningless, and that we still have a chance at redemption. But not if we keep lying to ourselves and believing that all this destruction and violence is being forced on us from outside. Only if we dare to see ourselves as we actually are, and understand that the raging golem is us.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page