top of page

Want Better Health and Better Relationships? Get to Know Gratitude for Your Good Luck

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
May 13, 2018
5 min read

Our minds tend to shrink the role luck plays in our lives. A prayer of gratitude is a way to correct that distortion

Every May I find myself thinking about life and death. The reason is both mundane and mystical at once: my father, a wonderful man, died the day after Lag BaOmer, which that year — ten years ago now — fell on May 24. My father spent his earliest years in the home of his grandfather, who was the head of a Mea Shearim yeshiva. My father's parents left the ultra-Orthodox world, left Jerusalem, and lived a religious-nationalist, middle-class Jewish life in Ramat Gan. My father left religious observance, but he never left God. In the last decade of his life he wrote a great deal about Jewish law, trying to find a way to make it relevant for Israelis in the 2000s. So every May I also find myself asking questions about Judaism, and about faith. I myself experience my Jewishness mainly as belonging to an intellectual genre — as if Judaism were some kind of filter, paranoid and tragicomic, through which I view reality. I also feel my Jewishness as a shared fate with Jews across generations and places around the world. But faith? I don't understand what that is. Which is why I was so surprised to discover that a prayer of gratitude is, in fact, a rational act.

As a couples therapist and also a family mediator, the philosophy that guides me is an existentialist one. For the purposes of this piece, I'll flatten that philosophical outlook into five hard facts we all have to contend with: 1. No matter how great or famous we become in our lifetime, eventually, after we die, we will be forgotten. 2. Nothing external to us has the power to give our lives meaning. 3. Even when we're very close to other people, there's always an unbridgeable gap between us and them. 4. No one is responsible for our life except us. 5. Life isn't personal.

So how do we escape these unbearable conditions? Some people have faith. I chose love. Our relationships with the people close to us, here and now, are the only solution to these unsolvable questions. That's why, in my work, I try to bring couples and family members closer together. But to do that, I don't need faith. Instead of faith, I felt, I have experience. I also don't need prayer, I thought — I have books. So I was surprised to discover, while reading the wonderful book by Nobel laureate economist Prof. Daniel Kahneman, "Thinking, Fast and Slow," that there's at least one point where rationality and faith meet: the prayer of gratitude.

In his book, Kahneman describes various cognitive biases that characterize our thinking. One of them is that "the human mind struggles to deal with non-events" (p. 224). Kahneman describes the way we understand Google's success story, and demonstrates how the fact that we can analyze the story in hindsight makes us imagine that the company's success was inevitable. In reality, he stresses, the people at Google had an enormous amount of luck. Had they not had that luck, the story could have looked completely different. Luck, Kahneman argues, always gets less credit than it deserves. Along the way, luck does all the grunt work, but afterward, when the glory stories get written, its role shrinks drastically.

Want Better Health and Better Relationships? Get to Know Gratitude for Your Good Luck - illustration

How does that connect to prayer? Let me explain through a small family story. This past winter I traveled with my daughter to Paris for her bat mitzvah trip. When the plane took off, I told myself how lucky we were not to have been delayed at the airport. When we landed in Paris, I was glad our suitcases hadn't gotten lost along the way. When we arrived at the friends' apartment we'd been lent, I thanked my good luck that we'd made it to the right address and that the key actually opened the door. The rest of the days went the same way. The trip was wonderful. It really was a honeymoon of sorts. And between coffee and croissants I noted to myself, joyfully, that she wasn't sick, that I hadn't lost my wallet, that my phone hadn't broken, that the child who'd stayed home in Israel wasn't sick, and so on and so on. We were happy, but I asked myself whether this gratitude toward luck wasn't some neurotic, irrational, unnecessary symptom.

Luckily, I'd brought Kahneman's book along on the trip. And when I read the chapter "The Illusion of Understanding," which discusses our ungrateful attitude toward luck, I was surprised to discover that my compulsive gratitude throughout the trip had actually been the most rational thing to do. It's ignoring our good luck that is, in fact, the irrational act. And from there I understood that a prayer of gratitude is an entirely rational matter. A prayer of gratitude is, in effect, a correction of the cognitive distortion that makes us minimize the weight of the good luck that has fallen into our lives. And what people of faith have always known, numerous psychological studies have demonstrated in recent years: people who tend to feel grateful enjoy better physical and mental health, and better relationships.

In the last years of his life, my father revived the "Zichron Baruch" synagogue in the Noga neighborhood of Jaffa and went to synagogue every day. I don't know exactly what he was careful to thank his God for. Right now, on a quiet Saturday night, as I write this piece in my living room, I'm thanking my good luck that the driver who ran a red light this morning across Rothschild Boulevard managed to brake ten centimeters short of me and my child; I'm thanking it that my husband landed safely in the Maldives, where the waves are wonderful, just as he always dreamed of surfing there; I'm thanking it that my children are healthy; that my youngest fell asleep beside me on the couch, his long legs draped over me, asking before he dozed off, "Mom, what are you writing?"; that my oldest is in her room, from which we pulled out seven extra-large garbage bags today, full of plastic junk from China and keepsakes better left unmentioned; that it looks like we can finally take the Christmas lights out of the reinforced safe room (I'd tried to give it a warmer look); that I have work I love, which lets me see up close the purity of other people's hearts; and I'm thanking my luck for being born to a father like mine, for whom faith and rationality were like the walls of a swimming pool — the ones you push off from for momentum, but also lean on afterward to rest.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page