top of page

Threads Coming Apart: What Happens to a Relationship When We're No Longer on the Same Side of the Map

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 10, 2025
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Ideological struggles are breaking friendships, families, and couples — but sometimes changing the shape of a relationship is exactly what saves it.

Zohar, 42, divorced and a father of two, hasn't seen Dana and Michal in three weeks. The three of them used to be inseparable — best friends, talking several times a day, traveling together, sharing an apartment in their twenties, going through divorces, losses, and loves together. But ever since the judicial overhaul began in Israel, something in the friendship cracked, and eventually broke. Dana and Michal started going out to protest with the flag every Saturday night, went up to Jerusalem to demonstrate outside the Knesset, signed petitions, and sent around links to critical op-eds. Zohar, on the other hand, supported the government's initiatives. "The legal system here is corrupt anyway," he used to say. Dana called him "dangerously naive," and he called her a "condescending leftist." The friendship deteriorated, bit by bit.

Ruti, 66, is married to John — an immigrant from the United States, seven years older than her, who came to Israel in the 1970s. They raised children together, built a successful business, and in recent years also cared together for Ruti's ailing mother, who lives with them. But ever since the overhaul broke out, something flipped. Ruti started going to demonstrations, joined protest groups, gave talks, volunteered. John, by contrast, was frightened. His childhood as a Jew in the American Midwest is engraved in him. He grew up with the sense that Israel is the insurance policy for Jews everywhere.

Over the past two years he's grown steadily more entrenched in his views — becoming a firm supporter of Bibi, in his words, "the only leader protecting us." Ruti sees this as moral blindness rooted in John's inability to understand Israeli society. He sees her behavior as the smugness of someone who's never experienced the terror of belonging to a minority. John told me in an individual session: "I always knew there wasn't much passion between us. That was fine, because she was always there, she understood me and accepted me — even when I was the 'nerdy American,' especially when I had no family in Israel. Now that's gone too. What's left?"

Oren, 38, a successful freelancer, also feels like he's falling apart. Oren supports almost his entire extended family financially, but for two years now he's been locked in an ongoing battle with his parents, siblings, sisters-in-law, and their children. Every Friday dinner, every birthday, every discussion in the family WhatsApp group bleeds quickly — a political development, a siren, a mention of the hostages, a demonstration, a military operation, even the cost of living — all of it ignites a new conflict. Oren has started to run away — he doesn't show up to dinners, travels abroad a lot (when there are flights), and settles for adding an emoji to things written in the family group. He loves his family — but no longer feels part of it.

Hidden Threads

The word "relationship" is on our lips constantly, in almost any social, romantic, or family context, but we tend to use it very generally, as though it were a single uniform structure. In practice, every meaningful human relationship is made of three threads, which are really three basic needs: the sense that we're drawn to the other person and draw them to us, the sense that we're both protected by our partner in the relationship and protecting them, and the sense that the significant other in the relationship understands us and we understand them.

You can think of these aspects as wheels on a bicycle. If only one wheel exists — that's a unicycle, a vehicle suited to riders with excellent balance. If two wheels are present — the relationship rides well, and can get anywhere. And if there are three wheels — like a tricycle — the relationship not only travels far, it does so comfortably, with the ability to enjoy the scenery and feel a sense of security — like riding through a park, or in a horse-drawn carriage.

But not every aspect matters equally in every kind of relationship. In a romantic relationship, the feeling of mutual attraction, of being drawn to each other, isn't a luxury. It isn't only a physical or sexual need — it's a deep emotional need to feel wanted and alive. Even if there's security — mutual assurance and the knowledge that we back each other up when the storm is raging all around — and even if there's partnership, meaning a high level of understanding, if the thread of attraction is missing, something in the relationship misses a critical aspect of the deep inner world of desire and longing. In a romantic relationship where there's no sense of attraction, it's very hard to sustain emotional intimacy over time.

In a family relationship, by contrast, the critical component is the sense of protection. Family is the place where we're supposed to be safe. The place where we're protected when we fall, when we're confused, when we're alone. Because a family is a hierarchical system, these feelings aren't distributed equally across the whole life of every relationship within it — parents need to protect their children up to a certain age, and only from an older age do children protect their parents. But either way, without the commitment to mutual protection — even if there's understanding, even if there's humor and dialogue, and even if there's attraction, not in the sexual sense but in the sense of admiration, being captivated, marveling at family members' attractiveness — the central emotional experience of familyhood is damaged.

In friendship, the critical thread is understanding. A friend is someone who understands us without our having to explain ourselves from scratch every time. They're the ones we start telling something to, and partway through the sentence they already know what we mean. They don't always agree with us, but they see us fully, and let us be who we are. They're the ones who laugh and delight when we once again do something so typically us, who are charmed and impressed by the places where we differ from them. We turn to each other for advice precisely because of that difference. So when the sense of understanding in a friendship is shaken, the friendship loses its quality.

Threads Coming Apart: What Happens to a Relationship When We're No Longer on the Same Side of the Map - illustration

Optical Fibers

When two of these three needs exist within the same relationship, a fiber is created. That is, the two sides are no longer connected by just one thread, but by several threads woven together. A fiber like that is far stronger than a relationship based on meeting only one need. If, between me and my partner, both attraction and a sense of security exist side by side, even if we don't always share a common language, our relationship will be good and stable. If, between me and my sister, both mutual protection and deep understanding exist, then both we and the people around us will probably see and experience it as an especially good sisterly relationship, one that can hold us up in hard times.

In Ruti and John's case, this was a long-standing marriage that rested mainly on a sense of understanding and acceptance. They raised children, built a business, supported an aging parent, but real attraction never really existed between them, at least not from John's side. When the understanding disappeared, as a result of the political rupture that placed them on opposing sides, the marriage's basic instability was exposed, and the whole relationship became shaky to the point of unraveling.

In Oren's case, with his family, this is a family relationship in which the central component — the sense of protection — has been completely worn away. Oren, who for years was the main source of support for his family, no longer feels emotionally safe around them: every gathering has become an arena of confrontations, judgment, and accusations. Even if there's still appreciation for him, and maybe even some understanding from some of his relatives, the basic feeling of being protected and loved has been lost. Oren withdraws, avoids, goes quiet — because the family is no longer a safe place for him.

A Flexible Relationship

By contrast, Zohar, Dana, and Michal managed to preserve their relationship precisely by changing its nature: from a friendship structure based on understanding, to an almost family-like structure, based on mutual protection. Instead of disappearing, the bond between the three of them was reshaped — less intimate, made up of fewer conversations and more actions.

The three of them still eat Friday dinners together, still travel with the kids on vacations together, still bring each other food when someone's sick. The relationship became family-like in the most basic sense — not necessarily biologically, but functionally: protection. There's no longer a sense of deep understanding, and certainly no ideological reciprocity — but the wish to protect one another remains. Zohar, Dana, and Michal moved from a friendship (I understood you, you understand me) to a family bond (I'm looking out for you, you're looking out for me).

In a period like the one we're living through right now in Israel, when so many threads are tearing or seem about to tear, there's value in asking ourselves not only which needs exist in each relationship and which are missing, but also whether this is really a permanent structure — or just a stage. It's possible that some of the changes in our relationships are temporary, an expression of the enormous pressure we're living under, and of a sense of uncertainty that's also undermining our ability to understand ourselves, the other person, and what we're going through.

After all, we don't really understand exactly what's happening either. Some of us wander around in a persistent fog, others search for certainty at any cost, clinging to one truth, one feeling, one opinion — sometimes out of a deep need to restore a sense of control for ourselves. Sometimes the inner conviction that "I'm right," that "I see clearly," is a kind of compensation for a much greater inner chaos.

But it's precisely in a state like this — where our minds are under attack, our hearts are flooded, and reality is changing from day to day — that maybe we should speak with fewer exclamation points, and agree to leave more question marks in place. Maybe the clarity we long for can only be rebuilt if we temporarily give up the need to feel certain. Let's remember that sometimes, understanding someone means agreeing not to fully understand them right now. And if we can hold onto that doubt for a moment without it swallowing us, if we can encourage that same doubt in the other person too, there's a chance that, in time, we'll be able to regrow some of these threads.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page