The Truth, the Whole Truth: The Most Important Step in Rebuilding a Relationship After an Affair
Recovering from infidelity means healing both the emotional distance and the loss of trust. But even if the emotional gap can be bridged, the breach of trust can be lethal to the relationship
One of the central questions on the minds of couples trying to rebuild their relationship after an affair is: "How long will this take?" It's a good question, for at least two reasons. First, this is a hard and painful process, during which difficult truths — sometimes hidden for many years of the relationship — come to light, and it requires touching extremely sensitive psychological territory.
The second reason it's such a good question has to do with cases in which the partners begin to rediscover each other romantically, emotionally, or sexually. When both partners want to fight for the relationship, they often grow close again with a speed and intensity they haven't experienced in years. Suddenly there are endless conversations, maybe a lot of sex, and something good and powerful is happening between them. And yet there's also a sense that something is broken — and in these cases, the contrast between that closeness and that brokenness can be demoralizing, raising the question: "Will we ever actually get past this crisis?"
The point I try to convey to couples in this sensitive, painful situation is that the gap between the place of closeness and the place of brokenness is entirely natural — and even though it feels unbearable, they shouldn't despair over it. The fracture exists because recovery from infidelity runs along two separate axes: the attraction/rejection axis (or closeness-distance), and the trust/distrust axis.
The amount of time it takes to move from one pole to the other is very different on each of these axes. If the partner who strayed wants to stay in the relationship and rebuild it, recovery along the attraction/rejection axis tends to happen fairly quickly. There are several reasons for this, the main one being that when we feel our partner is drawn to us again, it affects us immediately. That said, the betrayed partner also knows that their own attraction to their partner isn't consistent either, because movement on the attraction/rejection axis within a relationship is inherently dynamic.
The betrayed partner knows that they themselves don't always behave in ways that are attractive to their partner, and that they too are sometimes drawn to other people. So when emotional or physical closeness starts to redevelop between partners after an affair, the relationship can move relatively easily from the pole of rejection to the pole of attraction.

That sounds good — except that this movement doesn't speed up progress along the trust axis. Trust is built very slowly, through many small, gradual tests that, even at the start of the relationship, took a long time and were made up of countless moments. There's no reason to think that rebuilding trust after an affair will take less time than it took the couple to trust each other in the first place — if anything, it's reasonable to expect the process to take even longer.
"The most critical period for rebuilding trust is the period right after the affair is discovered" — Esther Perel
Another thing worth considering is that, unlike the betrayed partner's ability to understand that their partner was drawn to someone else, the betrayed partner is often unable to understand how their partner managed to lie to them for so long — and can't imagine themselves being emotionally capable of breaching their partner's trust in a similar way.
That's precisely why the hardest element for the betrayed partner to recover from is what happened during the period between the moment the affair was first discovered and the moment the whole truth finally came out. This is a critical window, in which — unfortunately, and usually not out of malice — something I call "the second hit" often occurs (named for terrorist bombings made up of two devices planted in the same location). During this sensitive period, the crisis is already out in the open — the affair has been discovered. As far as the betrayed partner is concerned, if the other side doesn't tell them the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, there is no forgiving that. They believe that at this stage, the partner who strayed has no excuse and no mechanism of denial they can hide behind to explain a conscious, devastating breach of trust.
Partners who strayed often don't understand what's so problematic about the fact that it took them time to reveal all the facts, because from their point of view, the gradual unfolding of the story had to do with being in a chaotic state, being afraid to hurt their partner, and so on. They feel their betrayed partner is fixating on small details, because the betrayed partner won't let go of questions like: "How is it that you told me you weren't in contact with him anymore, but it turns out you saw him twice more after I found out?" or "How is it that you told me you only kissed, and then I found out you slept with her too?" or "How is it that you told me this relationship lasted six months, and then later told me it actually started two years ago?"
These questions are supposed to be utterly insignificant compared to the original affair — but they aren't. The reason is that they touch on trust. I'll also note that a sub-category of this breach of trust is the various ways the betrayed partner feels violated: it can be physical, territorial, sexual, mental, or financial, but in most cases that sense of violation hurts the betrayed partner far more deeply than the bare fact that their partner was emotionally and physically drawn to someone else. The painful point the betrayed partner may struggle to let go of might be: "But how dare you pay for her with our money? / Take him to our hotel? / Talk to her about me?"
In other words, contrary to what we might assume, it isn't the degree of sexual consummation in the outside relationship that determines the extent of the damage — it's the degree of the breach of trust, which can be a genuine indicator of how difficult the recovery is likely to be. My advice is this: if you strayed, tell your partner as quickly as possible everything they want to know, and in doing so, avoid the "second hit" that can be utterly devastating to your relationship. And to both sides I want to say this: the gap between your emotional or physical closeness and the gap that still exists between you around trust is entirely natural — and even though it's frustrating and painful, don't despair. Keep trying to reconnect.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




