top of page

The Therapy Is Working, So Why Are the Couple So Sad? Three Notes on Couples Therapy

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Aug 4, 2022
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

After the shock of all the "emotional pus" that comes out in the first sessions, something starts to shift for the better. The couple begins to understand the roots of their tangle — and then the crisis hits. Three stages that show up in almost every couples therapy process, and how to get through them.

Psychological therapy is a huge adventure, full of frightening, moving moments and dangerous turns. Couples therapy is different from individual therapy, and in some ways seems simpler, since most of the drama plays out between the partners rather than between patient and therapist. But of course the therapist is there too, which sometimes turns couples therapy into a situation where three people are stuck in a burning tower, trying to find a way out together.

Every couple is its own universe, and so is every therapist — but it seems to me there are a few things that recur often enough in therapy that recognizing them as typical, natural, almost universal moments can ease things for couples, and maybe even for the therapist.

1. The Crisis After the Initial Improvement

The start of couples therapy is usually hard. Despite the initial optimism that comes from the couple finally doing something active for their relationship, the beginning often brings "all the pus" to the surface. Couples often leave their first couples-therapy sessions stunned and aching, as if their skin had been peeled off.

Usually, after a month or two, something shifts for the better. Working within an emotion-focused therapy approach, the couple begins building a conceptual map together with the therapist that helps them understand where exactly they get tangled up. For the first time, they understand that the way each of them handles problems in the relationship is what sets off all the alarms in the other. That understanding can be discouraging, but there's something optimistic in it too, since the couple starts to realize they have some real influence over why their relational dynamic isn't good enough.

At this stage of therapy, this new understanding often produces a real behavioral improvement between the partners — and then comes the crash! A short while after the improvement, the couple typically arrives at the clinic and sits down on the couch looking stunned and disappointed. One after the other, they start describing how frustrated they are that, despite all the progress, they've slipped right back into one of their painful "loops."

This is the moment to tell them to take a breath. To normalize the crisis itself. To make clear to them that the very same defense mechanisms and emotional fortifications that got their relationship into a bad place also helped each of them protect themselves. Our defense strategies may hurt the relationship, but in the moment, they mask our emotional pain. From the moment a couple enters the therapeutic process, they start shedding those defenses — but the process isn't complete or stable yet, so the couple finds themselves in a dangerous spot: already quite exposed, but still inside a space that isn't fully safe yet. Naturally, that stage will include moments of crisis.

The second reason to normalize the crisis is that the couple has reached an intellectual understanding of how they trigger each other, and of the way out of the loop. But intellectual understanding, however important, can only help us suppress some of our instinctive mechanisms some of the time — it's no substitute for the deep emotional work that will let us actually hold our feelings so those defense mechanisms don't get triggered at all. So, as disappointing as it is, even the most committed couples need to know it will take time before the crises become less acute, with longer stretches between one and the next.

The Therapy Is Working, So Why Are the Couple So Sad? Three Notes on Couples Therapy - illustration

2. The Grief That Follows a Real, Meaningful Change

This is one of the phenomena I recognize most in successful couples' processes: the partners manage, for the first time, to do the very thing they hadn't been able to do up until that moment. Maybe it's the usually avoidant partner, who suddenly manages to shed his shell of indifference and maybe even sheds a tear. And that tear completely melts the aggression of the pursuing partner, who reaches out and draws closer to him, gently and lovingly.

Or maybe it's a couple who, for a very long time, has been trying to dig themselves out from under the ruins of an affair, and now, for the first time, the partner who caused the hurt manages to actually let themselves feel the pain of the partner who was hurt — in a way that makes it clear to both of them that the one who caused the pain will do everything in their power to make sure that pain never has room in the relationship again. Or maybe it's something else entirely, something that belongs completely to that particular couple, and only they truly know how hard they worked trying to get there, and now, finally, succeeded for the first time. And then, suddenly, the sadness arrives.

I call this sadness "the placenta of change." Just as birth isn't complete until the placenta leaves the womb, this grief is a natural, necessary part of the birth of change between a couple. I understand it as grief over the closeness that was missed. When our attempts to get closer fail, it's deeply discouraging — but there's something almost anesthetizing about that despair, in a way. We can tell ourselves it was simply impossible, and that maybe it wasn't really our responsibility anyway.

But when we finally manage to do something right in the relationship, it suddenly becomes clear that, in some sense, it had been within our reach the whole time. That sense of sorrow over what we missed in our relationship until now, over the lost time, over the unnecessary heartache — that matters to me. And even though it's tempting to encourage the couple to focus on the positive side of the change (which is obviously very real), there's real value in validating that sense of sorrow over what was missed, because it can serve as an extremely useful compass for the rest of the couple's journey.

3. When a Breakup Is a Therapeutic Success

Many couples assume that, from their couples therapist's point of view, a therapeutic success means bringing them to a state of happy coupledom. But the truth is that for many therapists, success in therapy means a state in which both partners have laid down their weapons and can now understand, together, just how capable they are of meeting each other's needs. Of course we're in this profession because we love love, and it's moving to watch both partners shed their defenses, move closer to one another, and discover that each of them really can give the other what they need. But sometimes that's not what happens. The couple decides to separate — and that's okay too. That's also a success.

So when is a breakup a therapeutic failure? When it happens without our ever managing to stop the loop. When the couple keeps battering each other within their negative loop, in an endless escalation, and one of them cuts things off because they've simply "had enough" — that's an undesirable outcome from a therapeutic standpoint.

But it's important to understand that, in much the same way, a couple who stays together because one of them decided to give up on their own needs isn't a success either. One special case worth mentioning here is couples who leave therapy after learning to get a handle on their loop and stop the escalations. From a therapeutic point of view, the therapist will often not yet feel satisfied. From where we sit, we're looking for a shift in the basic stances each partner brings into their interactions, and for them to learn new ways to hold and share their pain. But for some couples, for one reason or another, that second floor just isn't realistic. Sometimes that, too, is a therapeutic success. The only difficulty is that I don't know of any rule that can help us tell the two situations apart.

Recommendations

Podcast: Kevin Rose

I love listening to entrepreneur Kevin Rose's podcast. He's a substantive, unassuming interviewer. He doesn't show off like Tim Ferriss, and he doesn't repeat himself like Andrew Huberman, and I always learn something new from his interviews. Here are three specific episodes I especially enjoyed.

"How to Live to 100," with Dr. Valter Longo

In this episode, Kevin talks with a researcher of the "Blue Zones," the places where people live longer, healthier lives than the rest of the world. One principle I've adopted since listening to this conversation is this: any behavioral or dietary intervention should be judged not only by its short-term effects, but also by the question — what risks should I be weighing if I keep this change up for decades? Because, as Longo says, even if people started taking cocaine, it would probably show improvement on a few metrics in the short term.

"My Crazy Probiotic Experiment," with Colleen Cutcliffe, PhD — Pendulum

I touched briefly on the promising probiotics from the company Pendulum in my piece on supplements. This was the episode where I was first introduced to them. I learned a lot, not just about the probiotics themselves, but also about Colleen Cutcliffe's impressive entrepreneurial way of thinking.

Kelly McGonigal — Author of "The Joy of Movement: How Exercise Helps Us Find Happiness, Hope, Connection, and Courage"

I felt an unusual degree of kinship with Kevin Rose's next guest, a woman who describes herself as suffering from existential anxiety, except when she's exercising. My own situation isn't as severe as hers, but I too have come to realize, over the years, that I don't actually love exercise — I simply need it to feel okay in life. The interview is packed with insights and fascinating little nuggets of information. I especially loved, for instance, the fact that our brains link forward motion with progress in the psychological sense — which is why some of the beneficial mental effects we get from exercise aren't only mediated by the hormonal signals we already know about, but also by other, more immediate, unconscious processes of this kind.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page