The Prince and Cinderella, Twenty Years Later
Movies convince us that love erases class differences between partners, but in reality class differences deeply affect a couple's bond and can sabotage it
What do the romantic films Titanic, Dirty Dancing, Beauty and the Beast, My Fair Lady, Pretty in Pink, Pretty Woman, and Cinderella have in common, besides being perfect viewing for the approaching Valentine's Day? Quite a lot, actually. They all share one central theme: romantic love's battle against class differences.
And what separates these films from reality? In Hollywood, love always wins, and that's where the discussion of class differences ends. In cinematic love stories, nothing can derail romantic love. All the differences between the partners, in their style, in the upbringing they received at home and in school, in their tastes, are presented in the movies as a matter of choice, and in any case the heat of love quickly evaporates them.
These films usually end with one of two possible resolutions. In the first, the woman gets a crash course in manners and etiquette, and thanks to her natural grace, and the fact that she is more impressive than the other women of her own class, she is welcomed into the upper class. In the other, the two partners move toward each other and find a middle spot where they can stand together.
The problem is that we know such movies are fantasies, but we aren't clear on exactly which part is the fantasy. Few of us think clearly about the fact that these films' unmistakable message is that class differences can be erased the way waves wipe out a line we've drawn in the sand with a stick. In the fantasy version, once the heroes have overcome the class differences between them, those differences vanish without a trace.
But where is the movie that shows us the lives of Cinderella and the prince ten years on, when the prince feels like continuing to sail his yacht, and Cinderella figures that if he's not going to work, he can at least take care of the kids, while the prince thinks, "Wait, then what do we have all these servants for?" And what about Julia Roberts and Richard Gere? What happens when his parents want to leave him an inheritance but fear his common wife will squander it all, and so insist on putting the money in the grandchildren's names? Now that is a movie I'd like to see.
I pondered this topic at the lavish wedding feast of the Maharaja family of Jaipur, which I wrote about in my previous column. I saw there that, contrary to the Hollywood myths, and also contrary to what is customary in Israel, in the social context of that wedding hardly anyone seems to even consider marrying outside their socioeconomic class.

At first glance, for a couples therapist who comes from a culture that is avowedly less class-conscious, sticking to one's class looks restrictive. But there is another side to it: marriage within the same class inherently narrows the differences between partners, and so eases the burden the relationship has to carry. Everyone knows how much to spend and on what, how to celebrate a birthday, whether to save for a child's university education, whether to buy him a car, and also what is appropriate to say in a museum, which restaurants to go to, which summer camp to send the kids to, and so on. But all of these are superficial matters. The effect of social class on a relationship doesn't stop at questions like whether it's vulgar to vacation at an all-inclusive hotel, or whether it's ethical to live off your parents' money without working.
From my perspective as a couples therapist, there are two other fascinating, far more significant things. The first is that class differences within a couple are not absolutely or clearly defined. In the movies it's simple: he's a businessman and she's a prostitute. In life, though, the picture is more complicated. In Israel, for example, there are many aristocracies: the party aristocracy, the money aristocracy, the intellectual aristocracy, the bohemian aristocracy, the Iraqi aristocracy, the Haifa aristocracy, the Jerusalem aristocracy, and so on. It never ends. Like a story from Greek mythology, every little island has its own king. It brings a smile, this preoccupation with class affiliation among a rejected Jewish minority, which leads us to imagine a concept like a "Ramat Gan aristocracy." Besides, when people marry across class lines, meaning between these aristocracies, it isn't always clear to an outside observer which partner lives upstairs in the relationship and which one sleeps on the servants' floor.
The second interesting point is how class standing within a relationship shapes the emotional strategies partners use to secure the emotional conditions they want in the relationship. I have written here more than once that, from the standpoint of emotionally focused couples therapy, the main strategies belong either to the pursuing-and-criticizing family or to the withdrawing-and-retreating family.
There are deep psychological explanations and evolutionary explanations for these differences, but I think that choosing to pursue or to withdraw is also tied to one's sense of class security within the relationship. In many cases I see that the partner who belongs to the lower class, in the partners' eyes, not mine!, is the one who tends to pursue and criticize the other. Correspondingly, the partner whose class standing within the relationship is higher tends to cope by disengaging and pulling away.
This difference becomes a bit more understandable when we think about it in terms of power: anger is an empowering emotion. So it makes sense that someone who feels weak protects himself with anger. The powerful partner, on the other hand, may fear using anger lest he do too much damage to his partner, and so chooses distance.
If my hypothesis is correct, it also explains why, in an era when more women are climbing the class ladder through work, more women are coming to therapy who regulate themselves emotionally by sinking into work, sports, or some other form of disengagement, that is, in a style that until recently was considered distinctly masculine.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




