top of page

The Bartender and the Emotional Triangle: Stuck Between the People We Love

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Apr 17, 2025
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Sometimes our good intentions to help within relationships end up locking them in place instead. In those moments, the bravest thing we can do is stop listening

Micha (a pseudonym), a man in his sixties, comes to see me every so often, whenever our schedules line up. But even though the timing of our sessions changes, the content stays remarkably constant. Every time, he tells me again just how hard he works to mediate between his grown children. He has three, but in recent years most of the difficulty has centered on two of them — his eldest son and his youngest son. The eldest constantly complains to his father about the youngest.

"I understand him," Micha tells me. "He's worried about him. The older one is already settled, and it bothers him that the younger one is drifting around with no direction, not studying, not working. We also have to help him out financially. The older one never got nearly as much support from us as the younger one has."

Micha says he's constantly "on the line" between the two brothers: trying to calm the older one down, passing the message along to the younger one, mediating between them whenever the younger one starts avoiding the older one (which is understandable), and reining in the older one when he lashes out too harshly at the younger one (which is also understandable).

Round After Round

But the more Micha goes on telling me about the family dynamic, the more clearly a picture forms in my mind: a dim, American-style bar. Micha is the bartender. And his eldest son? He's the regular — walking into the bar night after night, sitting down, ordering the same drink, and launching into a complaint about his younger brother: how he's wasting his life, what a shame it is, how he's ruining himself. Micha, like a good father, pours him drink after drink, shows understanding, and sometimes shares his own worries too.

And it isn't only the eldest son who shows up at Micha's bar. His second wife is a regular there as well. She keeps coming back to him about the tangled relationship between her and her daughter from a previous marriage. The daughter, Micha tells me, leans on her mother far too much for help with the grandchildren, floods her with demands, and doesn't consider her mother's own needs. In the metaphorical bar, Micha's wife takes a seat, orders a drink of her own, and while she drinks, Micha hears all about the fights, the mutual hurt, the difficulty setting boundaries, and the frustration. She asks him to back her up — to tell her when she's right, when she should bend, and when she's allowed to say no. There too, just as with his sons, he tries to help.

In practice, neither the relationship between his sons nor the one between his wife and her daughter is getting any better — they're stuck, tense, and loaded with unprocessed emotion. Micha, I suddenly realize, is a classic bartender — someone who stabilizes several relationships in his life through his listening ear and his relentless readiness to "help," but who, in reality, only locks them in place, never truly letting them develop. He absorbs everyone's tension, lets them offload their anxiety onto him, but in doing so he only cements the triangles rather than allowing any real movement within the relationships themselves.

This is a living example of what Murray Bowen, the founder of family systems theory, called an "emotional triangle." Bowen believed that the most stable unit in any human relationship isn't the dyad — a bond between two people — but the triangle. The reason, he argued, is that dyads are inherently unstable. There are always emotional shifts, gaps in how invested each side is in the relationship, and tension born of those gaps. And when anxiety or discomfort rises within one of these dyads — that is, when one side can no longer bear the gap — a "triangulation" mechanism kicks in almost automatically, pulling a third party into the picture. Sometimes that third party is someone one side turns to for balance and a listening ear, as in Micha's case. And that's how a triangle gets built.

Micha's son and his wife turn to him as a third party — not necessarily because they mean any harm, not at all — but because they don't know how to manage their relationships with the younger brother or the daughter directly. Micha becomes part of a system that perpetuates the distance between the two brothers, or between mother and daughter, instead of repairing it.

The bartender atrophies the dyadic relationships. In other words, not only does he fail to help — he actively prevents change. He lowers anxiety within the dyads in the short term, but at the cost of stalling their development. Instead of the people in the relationship learning to deal directly with each other, a third party helps them just barely hold on inside the relationship as it is. But nothing fundamental changes. Real growth will only come once the bartender pulls himself out of the role, once Micha stops being the go-to person, and dares — gently and lovingly — to send whoever comes to him back to the source. "Talk to him." "Sit down with her." "Did you actually tell her that?"

The Bartender and the Emotional Triangle: Stuck Between the People We Love - illustration

An Escape That Keeps It All in Place

The idea appeals to Micha, but it also shakes him. It's hard for him to get used to the notion that refusing to take part in an emotional triangle isn't an act of abandonment but one of maturity — that someone who truly wants to help sometimes has to know when to stop listening, not out of coldness, but out of a deep wish to free the relationship from its frozen structure and let it breathe again.

But the emotional triangle, as Murray Bowen stressed, isn't only a structure that lets two people offload their anxiety onto a third party — sometimes it also works as a mechanism through which two people preserve an illusion of closeness. In other words, Micha and his eldest son are also triangulating around the youngest son. And Micha and his wife are triangulating around her elder daughter as well.

Seen this way, Micha's younger son isn't only an object of worry — he's also the one quietly providing a psychological service: he lets Micha and his elder son grow closer to each other without either of them ever really being exposed. Without doing anything active at all, he stabilizes their dyad. Instead of Micha and his eldest son talking about whatever gaps exist between them (political differences, these days, for instance), or the residue of Micha's divorce from the son's mother, or fears about growing old, or unmet needs — they talk about a third person instead. The younger son is "the problem," the reason they meet, talk, and connect at all.

In much the same way, the relationship between Micha and his wife also gains something from her preoccupation with her daughter from her previous marriage. His wife comes back to him again and again out of frustration with her daughter — how much she demands help with the grandchildren, how hard it is to set boundaries with her, how much emotional energy she drains from her. Micha listens, tries to help, offers advice — and returns, again and again, to the same subject. And meanwhile, what's happening in the marriage between the two of them? Not much. Not much gets exposed, not much gets shaken loose, not much changes.

His wife's daughter becomes not only a challenge but also a familiar, safe focal point they can keep circling back to, instead of entering a genuinely intimate conversation — the kind that would require them to talk about themselves: about how they're each coping with the changes that come with age, about identity crises tied to a decline in professional standing, about conflicts of loyalty between two families that surface as disputes over money, and, more broadly, about fears, needs, and hopes.

So when Micha frees himself from the role of bartender — he won't only be allowing his sons to work things out between themselves, and his wife and her daughter to manage on their own — he'll also have to step back into his own relationships all over again. Suddenly, he'll have no way of sidestepping the conversation with his eldest son — there won't be a third-party problem to talk about instead; it will just be the two of them, with everything that might bring up. In the same way, he'll meet his wife not only as someone who needs his support against her daughter, but as a partner — with needs, with feelings, with complexity.

Micha didn't only fall into an emotional triangle out of good intentions and blindness to its dangers. He also chose it, or at least stayed in it, because somewhere along the way he sensed, or discovered, that the role held certain rewards for him too. A bartender has an excellent relationship with his regulars, without ever needing to expose himself, and without ever having to absorb any direct criticism. The bartender and the customer feel deeply connected without either of them ever truly being exposed on a personal level. And that's understandable. We all do this sometimes. The question is: once we recognize the dynamic, are we willing to take the hard but liberating step — to hang up the black apron, and walk out of the bar?


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page