top of page

Sorry, I Have ADHD: When a Label Becomes a Shallow Comfort

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Oct 10, 2024
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

A diagnosis like ADHD can offer comforting validation for our behaviors and choices. But what happens when it's just an external label slapped onto a problem that needs deeper investigation - or the wrong diagnosis altogether?

A good friend recently sent me an interesting video. In it, a coach explains why people with ADHD struggle to make social plans. Her theory: these people are more sensitive to environmental demands, so they experience more stress when someone tries to set something up with them. She also points out that social plans come bundled with sensory stimuli that can feel overwhelming for people with ADHD.

The coach makes an interesting point: the uncertainty over what your mood and energy level will be on the day of the plan. This, she argues, is why the initial reaction to a social invitation is usually negative - even when it's a beloved friend whose company you actually enjoy.

My friend sent me the video to try to explain why the two of us find it so hard to make plans together. In peacetime, I'm someone who more or less knows where he'll be on a Tuesday a year from now (and if there's something I don't have information about, it's probably because it isn't that important to me). My friend, on the other hand, is capable of texting me on a random weeknight to ask if I feel like grabbing a drink - a spontaneous question whose answer was probably no even back when I was a childless PhD student.

My reaction to the video was different from what my friend expected. I was willing to grant that the experience it described did resemble his. At the same time, I concluded that attributing the difficulty to ADHD doesn't actually offer a satisfying explanation - and may not even be relevant to the woman who made the video.

First, because the answer "you're like this because you have ADHD" carries a high risk of being tautological - it's circular, without much real explanatory power. Second, because it may simply be wrong: plenty of people with ADHD don't experience the difficulty described, while others who do experience it have plenty of other reasons for it.

Which brings us to the heart of the matter: what actually matters, therapeutically, is understanding the emotional difficulty that causes a positive event - a loved one asking to spend time together - to trigger psychological discomfort severe enough that we resort to procrastination just to avoid facing those feelings.

The Curious Case of the Reaction

I've already written, in an earlier column, about the "strange reaction" - a response that doesn't fit the situation it's responding to. A strange emotional response can show up in different forms: laughing during a painful experience, an oppressive sense of guilt where there's no real reason to feel it, deep sadness following only mild discomfort, an inability to feel joy when something we wanted actually happens, or numbness in the face of something moving.

The core premise of that column - and of this one - is that these responses matter precisely because they hint at deep emotional processes that aren't visible from the outside, and that examining them is meant to uncover the feelings behind them.

From the perspective of Emotion-Focused Therapy (EFT), my friend's reaction to attempts to make plans with him is a textbook "strange reaction." That mismatch, between the trigger and the response, points to deeper emotional processes that aren't immediately visible.

Even though the invitation itself is positive, it triggers an emotional response tied to past experiences or unresolved conflicts. It has nothing to do with the event itself, and everything to do with the resemblance between the current event and past events that led to uncomfortable feelings - feelings that, at the time, couldn't be dealt with effectively.

If we try to understand the "strange reaction" purely as a byproduct of his ADHD, we miss out on the investigation and processing of the deeper emotional block sitting at the root of it. By examining the specific emotional discomfort the invitation stirs up in him, my friend could identify exactly what's being activated.

Did similar situations in the past bring harsh emotional reactions from the people around him, or other negative experiences? Simply acknowledging the pain and processing these maladaptive core emotions can, on its own, reduce their intensity. Beyond that, by focusing on these feelings in Emotion-Focused Therapy, it becomes possible to replace them with emotions better suited to the actual trigger. In other words: instead of feeling stressed when a friend suggests getting together, he could come to feel excitement or curiosity instead.

Sorry, I Have ADHD: When a Label Becomes a Shallow Comfort - illustration

Under the Printing Press

That said, it's easy to understand why the short video my friend sent struck a chord with him, and with other viewers too. It offers a clear, simple explanation that delivers both validation and a sense of comfort. Attributing the problem to ADHD provides a label that can help people who have it feel understood. When someone hears that their struggles are part of a recognized, well-defined condition, it eases feelings of shame or self-blame.

Still, while an ADHD explanation can be a useful starting point, it's important to understand that it shouldn't be the endpoint of the psychological investigation. Oversimplifying misses the real complexity: ADHD can genuinely affect social interactions, but labeling a behavior simply as an ADHD symptom risks flattening the problem far too much.

People are complicated, and behaviors usually arise from a combination of factors - emotions, past experiences, and psychological patterns. When we lean on a specific diagnosis alone, it can foreclose the exploration of deeper emotional layers that may actually be the real source of the problem.

What's more, when we stop at the diagnosis, we risk staying stuck in the same patterns. ADHD may explain the behavior, but it doesn't necessarily offer tools for dealing with the deep emotional causes that make that behavior so hard to change. Real growth comes from understanding the emotional and psychological roots of the problem, not just its surface symptoms.

A diagnosis like ADHD can be an important insight, but it should be used as a gateway to deeper investigation, not a final answer. It can open the door to questions like: "What do I feel when someone asks me to coordinate plans?" or "What fears or anxieties might be hiding behind my stress?" That kind of inner inquiry can lead to a deeper understanding of ourselves, and to the ability to develop more adaptive emotional responses.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page