Since My Brother Started "Intermittent Fasting," He's Become Unbearable — and I'm Worried About His Mental Health. What Do I Do?
Imagine someone close to you adopts a health regimen — physical or mental — that turns into an obsession, takes over their life, and threatens the stability of the rest of the family too. A response to a worried reader's letter, signed D.
Dear Amalia,
My older brother (closing in on 60) and I work together in the family business. We see each other almost every day, and he's essential to the company. Our families are close too — we live not far from each other and see a lot of one another.
My brother has struggled with his weight his whole life. I think he's developed an eating disorder over the years — but that's not actually his main issue. He meets a lot of the criteria for borderline or narcissistic personality disorder. In any case, over the last six months he's adopted "intermittent fasting," and even though he feels good physically, I think he's genuinely losing it emotionally. Fights with him have gotten much more intense, and he's become unbearable to be around. His drinking has also gotten worse.
I'm worried there's something almost contagious about his obsessive focus on food, and that it's having a bad effect on other family members, especially the youngest ones. He keeps making the fasts stricter and longer, and there's no way to even raise with him the possibility that this method might be harming him psychologically. I'd love your perspective on this.
D.

Dear D.,
Good for you for caring so much about your brother. It sounds like, difficult as he apparently is, you genuinely care about him. You're trying to find a way to stay close to him, and it also matters to you that he himself is doing well. Of course, I don't know your brother, and I can't determine whether he has narcissistic or borderline personality disorder — but it's clear you've thought this through carefully, and there's probably good reason for your sense that he's dealing with some disorder of this kind, one that shows up as dramatic, extreme behavior patterns that are often out of proportion to the situation at hand.
The situation you're describing is difficult on several levels: your brother feels that after many years — maybe a lifetime — of disordered eating, "intermittent fasting" finally solved the problem for him, while you sense, probably correctly, that this method — eating only within a narrow window of hours and fasting the rest of the day — is actually just the latest phase in his long history of eating disorders.
It's understandable why your brother is holding onto this eating method so tightly. While for some people (myself included) it's a mentally unbearable experience, many others find it easier to stick to a categorical rule like fasting than to spend every waking hour wrestling with questions like whether to eat, what to eat, and how much. The constant need to make decisions about something this sensitive wears them down, and "intermittent fasting" completely relieves them of that responsibility: during the hours they're not supposed to eat, they simply don't eat at all; and during the hours they're allowed to eat, they eat whatever they feel like. That way, they get to be "on a diet" without the complicated part, as far as they're concerned.
But there are people — and your brother may be among them — who struggle somewhat with impulse control. People like that tend to react impulsively when they're in distress; some kind of defensive "mode" kicks in and handles the problem for them. When they experience emotional pain, they can become very aggressive, sink into self-pity, or numb the pain using various anesthetics.
In psychological treatment, we work with people in this situation through mindfulness practice, sometimes journaling, and often we'll recommend medication — and in any case, we try to take a multi-system approach that helps strengthen the connections between the prefrontal cortex and the more evolutionarily primitive parts of the brain, which tend to be more impulsive. This work looks a lot like the work we do with people trying to free themselves from addiction.
Make Your Case, Without a Head-On Confrontation
Now we can start to understand why "intermittent fasting" can be dangerous for people with the kind of emotional defense patterns your brother has. In fact, this approach works against the very direction they need to move in to make progress. The problem is twofold: first, because intermittent fasting doesn't encourage the connections between the brain's planning, organizing part and its survival-oriented part — precisely because it frees the person from the need to make ongoing decisions about their diet. And second, because intermittent fasting can end up allowing unrestrained eating during the hours when eating is permitted — that is, it can actually increase impulsivity.
In cases where alcohol consumption of the kind you described is also involved, intermittent fasting genuinely seems to add fuel to the fire. All of this becomes especially difficult given that the fasting rewards your brother physically, through weight loss, and mentally, since he experiences prolonged fasts as an achievement that proves his strong character.
What can you do, as a family? Not a huge amount. I'm no miracle worker. You, of all people, know how hard it is to influence your brother's behavior — but I can mention a few approaches that might be worth trying. First, try not to get swept up in his hysteria, and make sure you yourselves stick to a different way of eating.
Check whether your brother is open to incorporating some elements of mindfulness into the eating itself. Various Buddhist approaches, for instance, recommend not eating too much, but also not arriving at meals starving. Likewise, a moment of gratitude or centering before eating, putting phones aside, and so on, can make a meal calmer and less "binge-like" in character.
While I'd recommend not opposing the fasting head-on, and respecting the fact that your brother genuinely feels good as a result of it, you're absolutely allowed to point out to him the things that are making life harder for the rest of you: the fights, the drinking, the effect on the grandchildren.
We're not meant to be in a constant state of snacking
Try sticking to the facts in a non-confrontational way. Point to scientific findings about how hard it is to sustain a method like this long-term, and about the preference, for certain people, for a more moderate solution. If your brother himself has some doubts about continuing the fasting, scientific considerations might help give him a way to climb down from it.
Along the way, it might be worth offering your brother other kinds of support, to shift the focus away from eating entirely. In other words, it's possible that the secondary gain he's getting from the whole family being preoccupied with his eating has become too rewarding for him to let go of easily, and it might be worth just leaving that be. Instead, you could start meditating yourself, or practicing yoga, or begin going to therapy, and share with him the positive effect that's had on you.
Either way, I understand that life with your brother is hard, and full of frustration and disappointment. Mostly, I can affirm your own insight here, encourage you to hold firmly to your own self-care, and agree with you that when people choose a particular way of eating, they need to take into account the psychological side of that diet too, not just the physical one.
Recommendations
Article: Mushrooms and Mood
"People who took low doses of psilocybin, the active compound in psychedelic mushrooms, over the course of a month, showed a greater improvement in mood and mental health than control-group subjects who didn't take psilocybin." That's roughly the headline of an interesting study published in the major scientific journal Nature. The rest is worth reading yourselves.
Health: A Hot Drink in the Morning
I've written here before about how cooling your core body temperature matters for good sleep, but I haven't mentioned that the reverse is also true. Warming the body helps us wake up, which is why a hot drink in the morning helps you wake up even if it doesn't contain caffeine. So if you're trying to cut back on caffeine, or you just don't feel like coffee because the kind you have at home isn't great — don't skip the hot drink because of that. Simply warming your core body temperature will help you wake up, based on the same principle that explains why you sleep poorly when it's too hot at night.
Icon: Hannah Gadsby
If you're not familiar with this Australian creator-writer-performer (and comedian too, even though that's gotten a bit complicated to say about her these days), I recommend looking her up and finding her specials on whichever of your millions of content providers. And the more groundbreaking the special, the more you should brace yourself for a punch to the gut.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




