top of page

Silence Speaks: How Our Unspoken Past Shapes Our Children's Minds

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Sep 19, 2024
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

From flinching in an elevator to being over-critical, we pass on far more to our kids than we realize. Here's how our unprocessed traumas and experiences shape the next generation — and, as always, awareness is the first step

Liron (all names in this piece have been changed), 40, was in a serious accident as a teenager, riding a motorcycle without a license. He never told anyone close to him about it. Today, his ten-year-old son has declared that he himself will never get on a motorcycle — and Liron is baffled. "I don't even understand how he arrived at that conclusion," he tells me. "I've never once talked to him about it."

Shonit, 50, always knew her father had had affairs outside his marriage. But when she tries to explain how she knew that as a child, she can't point to anything concrete. This despite the fact that she can name several of her father's girlfriends and even visited some of their homes. She never heard about these relationships from anyone else, and she never caught anyone "red-handed," as the saying goes.

These stories aren't unusual. They illuminate a phenomenon that's both fascinating and unsettling: the wordless, intergenerational transmission of information. We tend to assume that only what's said explicitly affects our children, but reality is far more complicated. Only a small portion of a family's stories ever gets passed down as an explicit narrative. Many events — traumas and secrets chief among them — find quiet, indirect routes into the next generation.

There's nothing mystical or supernatural about this. Parents unconsciously pass their traumas and biases on to their children through a wide range of subtle behaviors, emotional patterns, and even body language. These sketch out a mental map for the child of what's permitted and what's forbidden, teaching them, wordlessly, what feels emotionally safe and what feels dangerous.

It's worth taking a closer look at some of the ways this transmission happens.

Emotional Overreaction

Say I grew up in a turbulent household, with emotionally unstable family members, where every minor issue turned into a raging fight. Even if, as an adult, I consciously decide not to tell my kids about my difficult childhood — trying to protect them — the trauma still finds ways to make itself felt.

I might react with extreme anxiety or anger to small conflicts between my children, a response wildly out of proportion to the situation. In doing so, without saying a single word about my past, I pass down to the next generation my own intense aversion to confrontation.

A different parent, with a similar background, might take the opposite approach — avoiding conflict altogether. Their children may learn from this that expressing anger or disagreement is inherently bad, and develop a pattern of suppressing their own emotions. Either way, the parent's unprocessed trauma shapes the children's emotional world, without either side being aware of the process.

Overprotectiveness

Back to Liron, who opened this piece. Beyond the motorcycle accident, he grew up amid neglect and a lack of any real supervision. Those experiences still haunt him, even though he never talks about them. As a result, he does everything in his power to make sure his children never end up in the kind of dangerous, frightening situations he found himself in.

But what looks to him like concern and protection can be experienced by his children as suffocating and restrictive. Even without ever hearing about the nights he wandered the streets as a child, or the harm that came to him, Liron's kids read his body language — the excessive worry, the restrictions on their independence.

Wordlessly, they learn that the world is a dangerous, threatening place. Liron means to create a safe environment for them, but the result can be the opposite: children who grow up anxious and afraid of the outside world, without either them or their father understanding where those feelings actually come from.

Negative Worldviews, Paranoia, Excessive Criticism

Yaron grew up with two narcissistic parents who experienced the world as one long insult. When his parents divorced, his mother threw herself into her career and neglected any emotional connection with her son. His father remarried and poured all his energy into his new family. From every angle, Yaron felt rejected and inferior, while at the same time being steeped in the hostile, negative way his parents talked about the world — both of them forever feeling they weren't given enough respect, and that they were surrounded by unworthy people.

As a result, Yaron developed a deep distrust of the world and the people around him. He doesn't talk about it openly, and even sees himself as a fairly positive person — but in family therapy it became clear just how consistently, and how powerfully, he had been passing those negative messages on to his own children.

Through body language, tone of voice, or avoidance of certain situations, Yaron taught his children to be suspicious, to doubt, to see danger around every corner. It's a striking example of how a negative worldview can travel from one generation to the next, even when the parent has no idea they're doing it.

A parent who grew up in an environment of excessive criticism may find themselves permanently on guard, endlessly scanning for potential threats. That heightened vigilance can create a tense household atmosphere — and, through it, pass the trauma on to the next generation.

Silence Around Feelings

Sometimes it's silence itself that speaks the loudest. A parent who grew up in an emotionally distant or repressive environment may avoid conversations about feelings altogether. That behavior sends children a powerful message: that expressing emotion is somehow improper, or unsafe.

In Hili's family, for instance, the subject was always changed whenever anyone mentioned her paternal grandfather. Only years later, in therapy, did Hili begin to dig into that silence — and uncover a devastating family story: her grandfather had been a sexual abuser.

Silences like these aren't rare in families. They can point to affairs, children born outside a marriage, addictions, illnesses, and more. Children, even without knowing the details, feel the tension and learn that certain subjects are off-limits. It's another form of intergenerational trauma transmission, one that can profoundly affect their emotional development.

Recycled History

Sometimes it's precisely the behaviors that look most positive that end up transmitting our unprocessed traumas. A parent who experienced poverty or financial instability as a child, for instance, might drill the importance of hard work into their children to an extreme degree — pushing them to work to the point of burnout, dismissing the value of rest and leisure, and drawing a direct line between self-worth and professional achievement. Their intention is to make sure their children never go through what they went through, but the result can backfire.

Instead of feeling secure, the children may develop a sense that they're never doing enough, that rest is a waste of time, and that their worth depends solely on their achievements. Or, conversely, they may develop a sharp resistance to hard work altogether, as a counter-reaction to their parent's insistence.

We also pass our unprocessed traumas on to our children when we react with disproportionate intensity to their mistakes. If we grew up as "parentified" children, carrying the family's entire burden of responsibility on our shoulders, we may have been terrified of making mistakes as kids, because every error carried far-reaching consequences. If we don't do the work of healing those wounds in our own personal history, we risk handing our children a fear of failure.

Instead of nurturing resilience, they may develop a fear of taking risks or trying new things — even if we've never once told them explicitly that "failure is a bad thing." Even when we don't actually believe that ourselves, we can still pass on that emotional inheritance without ever examining it.

One of the most powerful vehicles for wordless transmission is our own body language. A biography of a famous director who grew up in New York in the 1950s describes a formative childhood memory: the boy rides an elevator with his mother, and when a Black man steps in, he feels his mother's grip on his hand tighten. Without a single word, the mother transmitted a powerful racist message to her son.

In much the same way, our everyday behaviors send messages to our children. Obsessively checking that the locks are secured, physical discomfort when strangers or certain people get close, an outsized reaction to a driver tailgating us on the road — all of it teaches our children how we perceive the world. Wordlessly, they learn whether the world is a safe place or a dangerous one, whether people deserve trust or suspicion, and how to react to different situations — all without us necessarily being aware of the messages we're sending.

What all these examples have in common is that they illustrate how much of what our children know about us rests on far more than the words we've actually shared with them. The traumas we carry — some of them passed down through generations — and our biases don't need to be spoken aloud for our children to be exposed to them. They can come through, and do come through, in our behavior.

If we don't come to terms with our own traumas and take ownership of them, they can end up shaping our child's worldview and emotional responses without our ever having had a single explicit conversation about it with them. Awareness of these processes is the first step toward breaking the cycle of intergenerational trauma transmission, and toward building healthier relationships with our children.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page