Projecting in Public: What Our Comments Say About Who We Are
Updated: Oct 22
From accusations of money laundering to arguments about culture in wartime: an analysis of the comments on a food article reveals the deep emotional burnout in Israeli society
A newspaper recently ran a piece about a new fish and seafood restaurant at the renovated Dolphinarium complex in Tel Aviv. As I read through the comments on the article, I realized they offered a fascinating window into the mechanism of psychological projection — one of the phenomena unique to human beings that sets us apart from animals.
Psychological projection is an everyday phenomenon. We see it when we're speeding down the highway and complain about other drivers cutting us off, when we're anxious about our own appearance and criticize how others look, or when we're struggling to cope with the war and criticize how others are coping with it — eyeing someone outside our marriage, then turning around and accusing our own partner of being unfaithful.
Psychological projection is a defense mechanism in which a person attributes to others feelings, thoughts, or impulses they cannot or will not recognize in themselves. This mechanism operates unconsciously, and serves to protect one's sense of self from internal conflict or uncomfortable emotions, like guilt, anger, or anxiety.
Although most of us function perfectly well without ever being aware of the ways we project onto others, understanding this mechanism can meaningfully change our emotions and patterns, and in turn improve our close relationships. When we recognize our own projections, we can begin dealing with the feelings we've been suppressing instead of denying them. It also allows us to avoid making false accusations of our own, and to develop empathy toward people who accuse us — understanding that their accusations really reflect their own feelings.
So let's look at how the comments written under an article about the restaurant "Chakuli" reveal the way different readers project their own feelings, thoughts, and inner perceptions onto the article itself, onto the journalist who wrote it, and onto the restaurant.
"How many animals do you have to eat to feel satisfied?"
The author of this comment is using the article as a stage for voicing deep frustration with society as a whole. They experience society at large as consumerist, uncaring, and harmful to the environment, and seem to feel disconnected from a culture that enshrines material pleasure at the expense of moral values. The comment is projective in the sense that the restaurant itself obviously isn't the real culprit, or the true object of the frustration — it's simply a symbol of what the commenter sees as destructive human behavior.
"Why all the unnecessary bootlicking of dictator Huldai?"
This comment reflects deep disillusionment with the political system. The anger directed at [Mayor] Huldai likely stems from a loss of trust in local government and frustration over the absence of solutions to the city's problems. For this commenter, mentioning the mayor becomes an opportunity to vent frustration with the political system as a whole — projecting that anger onto the article and its author.
"Doesn't that dissonance bother you? Children are dying while you write about seafood and sunsets"
The commenter is voicing an inner conflict here about the legitimacy of enjoying life during a time of national crisis — a thoroughly understandable feeling. Instead of dealing with his own personal guilt, he projects it onto the journalist, who becomes, in his eyes, a symbol of insensitivity.
"If we give up on culture and beauty, what are we even fighting for?"
The reality is the same, but this commenter's approach is different: instead of guilt, they hold onto culture as a source of meaning. The struggle to preserve routine and hope amid the chaos — which deserves real credit — comes through here as a defense of the article, which for this commenter symbolizes the justification for going on living a normal life even in a time of crisis.

"I hope you didn't risk your own money on this terrible bet"
Personal financial anxiety finds expression here as feigned concern for the entrepreneurs. These commenters, themselves caught in economic uncertainty like so many of us, struggle to see a new business venture as an act of courage. Instead, the restaurant's storefront becomes a mirror reflecting their own financial anxieties back at them.
"A non-kosher restaurant is an endangered species"
This commenter reveals anxiety about the standing of their community within Israeli society. Feeling that their culture is being pushed to the margins, the restaurant becomes a symbol in a much broader struggle over identity.
"Money laundering! Money laundering!"
This accusation reflects a sense of helplessness in the face of economic reality. With no evidence to back it up, the accusation rests on a gut feeling that something isn't right. Frustrated by the injustice they see all around them, the commenter turns the restaurant into a symbol of corruption and a lack of transparency.
"This place will do well, because the prices are affordable and there's real demand here"
In this case, the commenters are projecting onto the restaurant their own need for a sense of order and control. They latch onto simplistic economic models that ignore the chaos and the sheer number of variables mentioned in the article — and all around us. In predicting the restaurant's success, they're projecting onto it their own wish to find a "formula for success" that would resolve their broader sense of uncertainty.
Taken together, these comments paint a troubling picture of a society in ongoing crisis. They reveal a deep exhaustion with the constant state of emergency, one that shows up as emotional burnout and heightened criticism. The fact that even an article about a new restaurant can stir up such intense emotion speaks to just how deep this crisis runs.
The comments reflect a society grappling with deep political and social rifts, financial anxieties, and an ongoing sense of insecurity. They split the Israeli public between the despairing and the optimistic, between escapists seeking refuge in aesthetic experience and activists demanding change.
Sustained exposure to trauma and conflict seeps into every corner of life, to the point that even online comments — never exactly the pinnacle of culture to begin with — are sinking to a new low of toxicity. Perhaps that is the most troubling testimony of all to the state of the Israeli psyche right now.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




