Our Anxiety Has a Role to Play Right Now. This Is Not the Time to Silence It
Updated: Oct 22
The current crisis is reshaping my relationship to anxiety. It's no longer just an overly sensitive amygdala reacting to personal stressors, but a cry in response to an existential threat. This current wave of anxiety shouldn't be dismissed, shamed, or maybe even treated at all. It will pass once the danger - from without and within - passes
Gila (not her real name), 75, started taking anti-anxiety medication after the war broke out. Gila is the daughter of Holocaust survivors, and despite everything she's been through in her life, this is the first time she's ever needed medication. And of course, Gila isn't alone. As Israel recovers from a terror attack of unprecedented scale, a wave of anxiety is sweeping the nation. But that wave doesn't only need to be soothed. It can also be seen as an opportunity to question the way we, as a society, relate to anxiety.
The massacre, the terror and the cruelty, on a scale never seen before, have left an indelible mark on Israel. Anxiety in the country has risen palpably. At the same time, this response also exposes deep biases in our society. Historically, segments of the population more inclined to express their anxiety openly - such as women and children - have been negatively labeled. Anxiety is seen as a sign of weakness in our patriarchal culture, driven by our machismo.
This social ethos, which stems partly from a reaction to antisemitism - and even from internalizing it, along with a post-traumatic aversion to showing fear - has long dictated our collective attitude toward anxiety. A lack of fear developed as a counterweight to global antisemitism, which despised the "weak Jew," a contempt we all internalized and turned against ourselves. These processes reinforced a national narrative in which showing fear, and later anxiety, is seen as weakness. We strove to be a nation of strength, and along the way we deepened our contempt for vulnerability.

Protective Anxiety
On a personal and professional level too, as a psychologist, this wave forces me to confront the way I've related to anxiety over all these years. In my work with people suffering from anxiety, I mostly focus on reframing their anxiety - from a character flaw or apparent defect, to understanding anxiety as a natural, if uncomfortable, health issue. Year after year I explain to patients that anxiety indicates their brain is on high alert to threats in reality; a heightened alertness created by genetics or by exposure to certain events in their personal past. In therapy, we try to teach the brain to experience the world as frightening but not dangerous. But does it still make sense to keep working in that direction?
The current crisis is reshaping my relationship to anxiety. It's no longer just an overly sensitive amygdala reacting to personal stressors, but an adaptive cry in response to an existential threat. This current wave of anxiety shouldn't be dismissed, shamed, or maybe even treated at all. It will pass once the danger - from without and within - passes. And perhaps until then, we need to go on being afraid. Right now, the voice of anxiety is a critical voice.
Anxiety can be understood as a refusal to become accustomed. A refusal to grow accustomed to the fact of the hostages, to the images of the hostages. A refusal to grow accustomed to sirens. To sending children to school while risking their lives and their mental health. A refusal to grow accustomed to dead soldiers, to the deaths of civilians on both sides. To the ceaseless droning in the sky. A refusal to hear that droning as a sound that protects me. A refusal to forget that I'm in danger. Anxiety is also the voice of resistance.
It's clear that the challenge is to balance important anxiety against excess anxiety, a rational response to real dangers against anxiety that paralyzes our ability to respond. We need to guide patients in how to harness anxiety as an engine for alertness and preparedness that increases their chances of survival, while addressing the excess parts that impair functioning. But as mental health professionals, we need to be very careful not to silence it to the point where its message can no longer be heard. The treatment of anxiety has changed, and it's no longer just about managing symptoms. Changing our cultural narrative around fear and anxiety is part of the response we all owe, as a society, to those who are anxious.
The recent terror attack and the war that followed require us to reconsider our relationship with anxiety. We need to move from seeing it as mere weakness to recognizing anxiety as a complex, and often protective, emotion. In this turbulent period, recognizing anxiety can become part of our national resilience, rather than detracting from it. It's time we honored all aspects of our emotional responses, especially those that have historically suffered from negative labeling.
In our patriarchal and militaristic society, where strength is worshipped and fear is scorned, the current crisis demands a reassessment of anxiety. Its dual role becomes clear: on the one hand it's a symptom requiring treatment, and on the other, it's the voice of caution in the face of danger. We need to recognize that the anxiety we feel today isn't merely a psychological reaction; it's a survival instinct. Populations prone to anxiety are an important and inseparable part of our national psyche - their vulnerability is a strength that enabled survival in other historical periods, as can be seen in the early departure of those who were anxious enough to leave Nazi Germany in time.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




