top of page

Need Help? Empathy Isn't the Whole Story

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 25, 2019
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Empathic listening is an important tool in therapy, but it isn't effective enough, says psychologist Les Greenberg, who explains why clients also need guidance to get out of their stuck places. A special interview, part four

The American psychologist Les Greenberg, the father of Emotion-Focused Therapy, was deeply influenced in his clinical and theoretical development by Carl Rogers, about whom I have written extensively in the past. In recent years, the Rogerian element that Greenberg seems to have made his banner is the importance of therapeutic presence.

He believes it means offering the client empathy and unconditional positive regard, together with an attitude of mental openness. The latter allows him to contain the client's experience and take it in without judgment, in a way that lets him grasp whatever the client brings with them at any given moment.

Another component of therapeutic presence, according to Greenberg, is the therapist's self-awareness, through which the therapist uses his or her own body as a kind of barometer, or GPS, that makes it possible to echo what is happening in the client's inner world and respond accordingly. So when therapeutic presence is fully in place, the therapist conveys two messages to the client: one is "I hear you," and the other, no less significant, is "I'm open to whatever you want to express."

In Greenberg's EFT, therapeutic presence reflects the ideal of the therapist's openness to the experience unfolding in the room at this very moment, and the importance of a deep connection with the client. In an article he wrote on the subject, Greenberg explains that therapeutic presence means being with the client far more than treating the client. The term underlines the fact that the therapist's role is not to observe the client or peer into his or her psyche, but to be open to the client's experience gently, compassionately, and without judgment.

Therapeutic presence reflects therapists' willingness to be affected and moved by their clients' experiences while at the same time keeping their own center and their ability to respond in a way that is attuned to the client's experience and needs. When this ideal is achieved, we therapists are in touch with the client's experience and with our own, and are also able to understand what is happening between the client and ourselves.

Still, there is at least one major difference between EFT and the Rogerian approach: in emotion-based therapy, the therapist not only tracks the client with deep empathy, but also guides the client to look at his or her feelings and deepen them, in a way Rogers would never have accepted. The fourth part of my interview with Greenberg is devoted to this difference:

Why isn't Rogerian empathy a sufficient therapeutic tool?

"In the Rogerian view, the therapist should focus on what the client says and must not influence or guide the client. The problem is that this is impossible. When two people meet, they automatically begin to influence each other. So I think that at the root of the difference between EFT and Rogers lies the understanding that it's impossible to avoid influencing another person, all the more so in the encounter between therapist and client.

"But the difference between the approaches goes deeper. Empathy in its Rogerian sense, meaning the therapist's focusing on the client without guiding, isn't effective enough, which is a pity. If the client is with me in the room and is looking for a way to feel better, and I know which path this person needs to travel for that aspiration to be realized, it makes sense for me to steer them there.

"My knowledge doesn't come from knowing better than the client what the client feels, but from knowing how to help people connect with their deepest emotions and process them effectively, which in the end will help them feel better. So the bottom line, I think, is that for EFT empathy is a necessary condition, but empathic tracking of the client's feelings in the way Rogers established it is simply not effective enough."

Need Help? Empathy Isn't the Whole Story - illustration

Can you give an example?

"Let's imagine we're sitting in a room with a client who feels anger and sadness. And suppose that, as the therapist, I notice that the client is stuck in his anger a little more than in his pain. If we stick to pure Rogerian empathy and only track his emotional process, he'll stay stuck in anger for a long time. By contrast, the moment an EFT therapist notices the client's sadness, she can also draw his attention to it. Once she does that, the client can begin to connect to his sadness more explicitly as well. An EFT therapist guides her clients by helping them focus on the emotions that arise in them during the therapeutic process, and builds with them the emotional process and what can be learned from it."

When Greenberg talks about guiding the process, he doesn't mean interpretation along the lines of "You say you're angry at your mother, but I assume that unconsciously you're sad." Nor is he talking about guiding the process in a way that takes the focus of the room somewhere else, in the style of "You say you're angry at your mother, but we both know this anger only gets you into trouble, so let's see how you can control it the next time you meet."

The guidance is something else entirely: when a client says "I'm angry at my mother," but I notice that he looks sad and sounds sad, I can draw his attention to that and say, "You know, I hear that you're angry at your mother, but when I look at you it seems to me that maybe you're also a little sad. Is there something in that?"

Greenberg explains that the Rogerian position, according to which empathy is the necessary and sufficient condition of the therapeutic process, misses two important things: "First, the client needs not only empathy but also validation, or affirmation. Within a close relationship, people also need validation of their identity, as we said when we talked about couples therapy. Second, clients also need gentle guidance.

"Both of these matter in therapy just as much as they are vital in parenting. As a parent you know you have to spot the spark of interest in your child's eyes so that the spark can grow into a flame of curiosity. In other words, in order to realize the potential within me I need someone to see that potential, and if I'm stuck but want to get unstuck, I need someone who sees me and understands the process I'm going through to help me focus on the right thing."


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page