It's Time for Our Brains to Wean Themselves Off Shallow Theories
Updated: Oct 22
Sociobiological theory tries to find simple explanations for complex human behavior, but it leans on vague concepts and perpetuates genetic determinism. Some critical remarks on the interview with Dr. Liat Yakir
In a festive interview published this week in Haaretz, the human behavior researcher Dr. Liat Yakir reheated theoretical leftovers several decades old, sprinkled on a few fashionable popular spices ("women need to wean themselves off alpha males, and we need to learn to make love"), and served them to us as the main course of the holiday meal.
Here is a selection of the confident pronouncements scattered throughout:
Love = oxytocin
What's true of peacocks is true of guys
Our genes make us marry one type of person and cheat on them with another type
Infidelity is evolutionarily programmed into us
Genetic differences make Asians tradition-oriented, as opposed to whites, who seek thrills
Biology is what causes sex in a relationship to fizzle out quickly
Dopamine and serotonin are the forces that drive human culture
Feminism goes against biology and ruins our sex lives
Antidepressants and anti-anxiety medications make food and relationships redundant, because they let us feel nutritionally and sexually satisfied without the real thing
Taking apart each one of these claims separately is a lifetime project, and I don't think this interview deserves too much time. Still, since silence may be taken as agreement, and since, from reading the comments on the interview, I sensed that many people feel a need to draw some line against this propaganda, it's important to me to place the conservative sociobiological worldview presented in the interview in a somewhat critical context.
If Yakir's claims sound as though they came straight from the 1980s (assuming Hitler will waive his copyright), it's because sociobiology in this simplistic version stuck to the sole of our research with the publication of the book "Sociobiology," written by the racist researcher Edward Wilson in 1975. The criticism of sociobiology is not new at all, but it turns out that I'm already old enough to say that some people apparently still haven't learned what some of us have already managed to forget.
For the benefit of those unfamiliar with the subject, I'll note that sociobiological claims like those made in the interview are part of a set of political positions that often rest on statements in the style of "There's nothing to be done, that's just how it is!", which make no attempt to explain contradictory findings. For example, if antidepressants make the need for food redundant, why do about 25% of those who take them gain weight, and many report increased appetite? And how do you resolve the contradiction between portraying whites as more thrill-seeking than conservative Asians and the centrality of traditional and modern prostitution in large parts of the Far East?
Sociobiological spokespeople have always relied on vague concepts ("education and culture have a major influence on testosterone levels") and a supposedly scientific map of the world ("sex, belonging, community, children, food, power, and control: all of these cause the release of serotonin and dopamine, which are the hormones that make us feel good"). But this theory is full of holes like a sieve ("Infidelity is part of universal programming in animals," the interview says, but it might be worth noting that animals don't cheat, if only because they never commit to a monogamous relationship at any stage).
This sociobiological variation ignores the complexity of the individual human consciousness (the "psyche"), or the consciousness made up of many individuals ("culture"), and relies on genetic determinism. It implies alignment with social norms.
In these days, as we mark two years of the #MeToo movement and mourn the murder of yet another woman by her husband, we need to understand that even if the interviewee avoided saying so explicitly ("The female is oriented to look for an alpha, and suddenly she looks at men and says they're too nice, because they bring her flowers on the first date"), it still implies that male aggression is a genetic matter that can't be challenged, because it is useful for reproduction and attracts women. Accordingly, sexual assault against women and the murder of women are a biological reality beyond our control, and we simply have to accept them.
Let's not even open the discussion of how this theoretical simplicity produces analogies between ants and humans in a way that celebrates the most predatory capitalism, and of what adherents of this approach think about the intellectual capacity of people of African descent.

Science has advanced a great deal since Wilson and the criticism of him, and although the study of animal behavior has progressed enormously, no basic genetic explanation has yet been found into which one could fold the explanations for the behavior of all living creatures, or even of mammals. Technological developments that allow brain scanning occasionally reveal correspondences between emotional states and brain activity, but genetic research hasn't really identified genes responsible for one behavior or another.
We still can't get rid of the cultural glasses through which we ask scientific questions, and certainly not of those we use to read the answers we get. On the contrary, as science develops and multiplies, it turns out that what is being revealed is not human nature but the nature of sociobiology as an approach, and its being an efficient mechanism for producing shallow claims about human nature.
Anyone interested in the subject will find plenty of reading material online. For in-depth reading, I recommend the writings of the evolutionary anthropologist Sarah Blaffer Hrdy, herself a representative of sociobiological thinking in a far more sophisticated and developed version, who published the important book Mothers and Others. Hrdy wrote about the implications of patriarchal values for scientific findings, and about how the conclusions (surprise, surprise) support the existing power relations in patriarchal culture. In Hebrew, you can read the modest and fascinating book by my good friend Prof. Zvi Triger, "Crimes Against the Patriarchy," and of course there is always something to learn from Carol Gilligan ("Joining the Resistance").
Allow me to quote a criticism of Wilson and company's thesis that I especially liked, voiced not by militant feminists but by an evolutionary researcher named Georgy Koentges: "The theory (in this case the reference is specifically to Richard Dawkins [A.R.]) is a fantasy. There's no such thing as a good or bad gene. It's not that simple. Genes function differently in different contexts, and each such context yields a different survival-fitness value for the individual or the group.
"Late in life, Darwin said he regretted not calling his theory 'natural preservation' instead of 'natural selection,' because the fact that certain genes are preserved over generations doesn't prove they are good. A simple human example is someone with the perfect set of genes for walking on two legs who might die young because he jumps off a cliff. In the same way, many things survive in our biology for no useful reason, like nipples on men. They are 'bystanders' of other important processes. They stem from basic genetic processes that in the other sex are absolutely vital to our survival as mammals."
So what are the alternative theories? The amount of information contradicting the claims made in the interview is so large that I can't present it in an orderly way. Sarah Blaffer Hrdy discusses, among other things, the supposedly scientific myth of hunter-gatherers, which sits on the shoulders of the supposed myth of women's instinct to nurture versus the male instinct that drives men to go out and hunt. Hrdy shows that cave findings prove that in certain places men and women engaged in procuring food together, and while they were foraging, hunting, and gathering, other men and women stayed behind to care for the offspring of the whole tribe or group. That is, men and women were responsible for the survival of offspring who were not genetically their own! They apparently hadn't read Wilson and company, and so they cared about other people's children.
What about sex? What's wrong with the idea that a man oiling his Ferrari turns on 50% of the population? One research-based model offers a far more complex and serious way to understand human sexuality. It is a scientific model popularly known as the "gas and brake theory," which describes two neurological processes whose synthesis dictates our level of sexual arousal. It was developed by the researchers Erick Janssen and John Bancroft, of the Kinsey Institute, in the late 1990s, and as science progresses, the big picture seems to be even more complex than their model.
Here is the explanation, anyway, as I understood it thanks to the sex educator Emily Nagoski: two systems operate in the brain, one is the "gas pedal," which accelerates our sexual arousal, and the other slows it down. These systems are like two radars that constantly scan the environment. The accelerating radar detects every piece of sex-related information: a woman in a low-cut top in an ad, a look from someone on the street, and even a holiday interview in Haaretz whose headline includes the word "infidelity." If it picks up enough signals, we get turned on. The slowing radar, by contrast, scans the environment for threats. If it picks up enough signals, it makes us button up. In both cases the signals are external and internal alike, ranging from "the kids aren't quite asleep yet," through "I'm dead tired" and "I have to put away the groceries," to "I'm fat."
For us to be in the right mood for sex, the signals picked up by the horny radar need to outweigh those picked up by the conservative radar. The road to a better sex life doesn't require writing sexy WhatsApp messages, wearing uncomfortable underwear, or buying a flashy car. Research shows that problems with desire or satisfaction are usually related to an overly sensitive brake pedal. According to the research, women are quite into sex, if they aren't disturbed. That is, a man showing us his Ferrari will affect his wife's sexual desire, especially if he drives to pick up the kids from their activity and, while they're at it, fills the trunk with groceries from the supermarket, thus letting her rest, or write her doctoral dissertation in the afternoon and be less tired in the evening.
Another example of the complexity of human sexuality relates to the phenomenon called "arousal non-concordance." About three decades ago there was a research trend to "prove" that deep down, women enjoy porn. The proof was based on the fact that when women were fitted with tampons containing electrodes and shown porn films, they told the researchers the images repelled them. But, aha! The electronic tampons revealed the truth: the subjects' vaginas were often wet. Supposedly conclusive proof of sexual arousal.
Is there only one way to look at this study? Here too, serious credit goes to Nagoski, who pointed out that the response of our genitals is an automatic response that is not enough to indicate how much we enjoy something. It's exactly like my mouth watering when I'm about to bite into food, even if it's reheated leftovers, to help my body digest it.
That is also what happened with prehistoric women who were victims of sexual violence. Those whose bodies knew how to prepare quickly for violent penetration in response to any sexual information, regardless of their emotional state, had a higher chance of surviving the assault. That is, there is a big difference between the fact that some piece of information is sexually relevant and its being sexually attractive or repellent. Paradoxically, such findings often come precisely from sociobiological research, which can enrich the scientific discourse on sexuality precisely when it points out that the discourse and the knowledge it is based on are far from clear and unambiguous.
These are only small examples, but they are enough to remind us that when we send back to the waitress the reheated leftovers of the brutal genre of sociobiology, we aren't rejecting science as a whole, or even sociobiology as a whole, but only the reductionism that presents itself as the emissary of pure science, bearing no responsibility for the social destruction it encourages. We also reject the portrayal of its opponents as hysterical people who can't cope with the hard facts, or as militants who can't cope with the fact that "there's nothing to be done, that's just how it is!", instead of coping with the hard fact that there is no scientific datum whose meaning is detached from its research context.
An exemplary illustration of the fact that there is no research question that doesn't reflect some ideological position is Carol Gilligan's doctoral work, which became the book "In a Different Voice." When Gilligan studied psychology, it was well known that female development, particularly along the axis of the development of moral consciousness, didn't meet the "standard" of human psychological development. Gilligan dared to scratch the surface and discovered that the developmental scale against which women were compared was based entirely on the psychological-moral development of white men. Gilligan's revolutionary move was in exposing the hidden ideology that had formulated the research question and given birth to the scientific facts. As Gilligan said in an interview with Haaretz: "My book asked: if women's voices are different, is the problem with the women or with the theory?"
But even after I've cut up the interview with Dr. Yakir and made sukkah decorations out of it, that is, presented this collection of nonsense in scientific perspective (lucky Shakespeare wasn't aware of the existence of oxytocin), it's important to me to place the question of burnout in a broader philosophical and intellectual context. In the past I wrote here about the American relational psychoanalyst Stephen Mitchell, and about his inspiring thinking, which touches in its deep side on Buddhism and in its light side on Esther Perel, because it doesn't let us expect tomorrow to be like yesterday or treat our partners as a given.
According to Mitchell, falling in love is not a fantasy. That is to say, falling in love is indeed a rare and powerful magic. Precisely because love is such a strong and shaking experience, Mitchell argues, it arouses dependence and helplessness in us and puts us in a fragile, needy position. If thanks to my beloved I feel as though I've won a prize, then he can also take that prize away from me and cast me down from Olympus to earth, to suffer there in loneliness.
This fear is often unbearable. The authentic, existential knowledge that there's no way to guarantee that my beloved will always love me, and that he won't prefer someone else over me or break my heart in some other way, can be torture. This is the stage at which the real fantasy in the relationship develops: the fantasy that our partner is completely familiar to us, stable and predictable.
That is, all those traits that together are called "burnout" are actually a product of our imagination. Dependence on the beloved partner arouses so much terror that we work at diminishing him in our own eyes. The more we develop negative fantasies about him, the safer we feel. If the conquering, sensitive, smart, attractive man I fell in love with leaves me, I'll be broken and shattered. But if the domineering, balding, loser, boring nudnik who lives beside me leaves me, that's already much less bad.
This is the answer of Mitchell, Nagoski, and other researchers to Wilson and his spokespeople, who don't die but are merely replaced, and an example of how science, psychology, and philosophy part ways with the sociobiology presented in the interview. I thank the many readers who sent me corrections and illuminating comments, and I agree that you needn't accept this answer either, since it too is surely too simplistic relative to reality. But I think I've gone on long enough, and I've said in many words what I wanted to say simply: human beings are not mice. Human sexual pleasure is not explained by counting the orgasms of mice in a cage. I also dare to say that in long-term monogamy the initial feeling of love is the truth, and it is burnout, which the interview seeks to present as an established fact, that is the dangerous illusion, one that uncritical studies, which clearly project onto their subject of study the patriarchal values and the biased starting assumptions of the researchers, may turn into a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




