top of page

Is Your Partner Suffering From Depression? Here's How to Help Them

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jun 17, 2018
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

In couples therapy, depression is treated as a shared enemy of the relationship rather than one partner's problem, which is why the solution is joint work

Hila and Liad, a couple in their forties with two children, are at the very end of their rope. Hila has been suffering from depression and post-traumatic stress for years, and despite periods of improvement, their relationship is now at a low point and seems to be heading toward separation. Hila isn't alone: in recent weeks the successful designer Kate Spade, the beloved chef and television personality Anthony Bourdain, and before them the popular and admired DJ Avicii, all died by suicide — cases that have pushed the heavy toll of depression back into public awareness. In the therapy room, the hard question hovers: how can Hila and Liad's marriage survive her depression?

Depression is a serious illness of enormous scope, exacting a heavy emotional, physical and financial toll on individuals, families and society. But here I want to focus on the couple as a unit. The internet is full of advice — some of it excellent — for how one partner should cope with the other's depression: don't withdraw from a depressed partner, don't try to cheer them up, do ask about suicidal thoughts, maintain boundaries. These things can help, but from the perspective of emotionally focused couples therapy, such advice is less effective than an approach that treats depression as a shared enemy of the couple.

Depression and relationship distress often go hand in hand. The explanation is that symptoms like irritability, reduced motivation, a diminished ability to derive pleasure from life experiences, and reduced sexual arousal, are all present in depression and can weigh down any relationship. A difficult relationship can likewise harm both partners' emotional state. But at a deeper level, there may be a more fundamental connection between depression and relationship distress. Both, very often, contain a historical component of attachment injury — a term used in emotionally focused couples therapy (EFT). Attachment traumas in childhood and adolescence are a risk factor for developing depression at the individual level, and they also sit at the foundation of the operating system behind the negative loop we get caught in as a couple.

One of the basic ideas in emotionally focused couples therapy is that in childhood, each of us develops emotional strategies to soothe ourselves in situations where an important bond — usually with a parent — feels under serious emotional threat. The two prominent strategies are avoidance and pursuit. Avoidance is a kind of emotional shutting-down and withdrawal meant to calm the anxiety stirred up by the emotional threat, but which looks, on the surface, like indifference. Pursuit, by contrast, is a kind of over-closeness and an attempt to eliminate the emotional threat, which looks, on the surface, like nagging or criticism.

Is Your Partner Suffering From Depression? Here's How to Help Them - illustration

Because these strategies worked well in childhood, we keep relying on them in adulthood too, whenever our most important emotional bond feels under threat. Except now the bond is with our partner, not our parent, and often what worked in childhood actually complicates things in the present. That is, the very action we take to stabilize the relationship and reduce the intensity of the emotional threat is exactly what sets off all the alarms in our partner. Unfortunately, what our partner does to stabilize the relationship sets off all our alarms in turn — the more the pursuer pursues, the more the avoider senses danger and withdraws further. But the more he tries to calm things down in his own way, the more indifferent she feels he is, and the harder she pushes to shake him out of that indifference. Both are trying to improve the situation, and the situation keeps getting worse. This is the basic negative loop that most struggling couples are stuck in.

Now let's take this loop and map it onto how Hila and Liad are coping with Hila's depression. From the start of their relationship it was clear that Hila suffered from depression. Liad tried to cheer her up and improve her mood, but his efforts bore no fruit. Liad secretly began to develop resentment and anger, and felt guilty about that, so he kept up, outwardly, his efforts to encourage Hila. Hila sensed a disharmony between the visible layer of Liad's actions and words and his true feelings, and the result was that she felt more and more rejected and alone. That feeling of rejection fed her depression and further reduced the effectiveness of Liad's efforts, until at some point he, too, began to suffer from depression.

With the help of an emotionally focused perspective, I try to help Hila and Liad see that they're getting tangled up precisely out of a wish to get closer to each other and improve the situation. It pains Liad to see Hila suffering, and he offers solutions, but Hila has no capacity to be helped by them. The result is that Hila feels Liad is frustrated with her, even contemptuous of her at moments. The truth is that Liad, for his part, felt bad about failing to help her, and tried to focus on his own life and on their children precisely in order to limit the damage to the relationship. But Hila experienced that choice as him pulling away, which made her feel even worse, even lonelier and more worthless. The result is that both Hila and Liad feel lonely and disconnected, even though they both had good intentions, and even though both are trying, each in their own way, to achieve what's best for the relationship.

The pattern Hila and Liad are caught in is typical of couples coping with depression. EFT therapists see this pattern, not the depression itself, as the real enemy of the relationship. In other words, from the perspective of emotionally focused couples therapy, the problem isn't located in Hila. The depressive illness Hila suffers from is the shared enemy of both partners. Once they manage to cooperate in fighting this shared enemy, and understand how their negative pattern operates, Liad will feel capable and positively effective again, will be less frustrated, and his need to withdraw from Hila will shrink. As a result, Hila's sense of loneliness will lessen, which will have a positive effect on her depression. As her depression weakens, Liad's sense of competence will strengthen, and his willingness to move closer to her will grow. In this way, gradually, the couple's negative loop can turn into an upward spiral, and the gloomy skies can clear — at least a little.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page