Is the Hunt for Desire Ruining Your Sex Life?
Updated: Oct 22
A model that lets couples think about sex in terms of motivation rather than desire alone can open up new options for them
"What food cuts women's sex drive by 90 percent? Wedding cake."
The sheer number of jokes invented about the loss of desire in marriage says a lot about how much sadness the subject stirs up. Even though many couples hesitate to talk about it, it's one of the main reasons people end up in couples therapy.
Different couples therapists look at erotic life through different lenses. Esther Perel, for instance, stands out for arguing that improving communication between partners doesn't necessarily improve their erotic life at all. On the contrary, Perel claims (and her bestselling books are easy enough to find), closeness and friendship between partners can actually extinguish sexual fire. Sexual fire needs oxygen, and finding oxygen within a monogamous relationship is, in her view, the real challenge.
Sue Johnson, who developed the EFT approach for couples (a topic for another post), takes a different view. She believes couples get into trouble in bed the same way they get into trouble in the living room or the kitchen: they struggle to move from vertical to horizontal with any joy precisely because they rely on behaviors that were originally meant to protect the relationship and protect themselves from being hurt within it. But those very behaviors end up causing more hurt on both sides. So the challenge, according to EFT therapists, is to help partners expose their vulnerability to each other. From that point, the relationship can improve across the board — including sexually.
Despite the differences between these approaches, it's theoretically possible to connect each of them, in its own way, to the question of separateness in a relationship. Many couples therapists would agree that sexual difficulty in a relationship is tied, on one hand, to a fear of merging with the other, and on the other, to difficulty experiencing oneself as a separate, distinct entity from one's partner.
But before we choose a therapeutic approach to help us mess up the sheets a bit more, a little of what's called "psycho-education" — giving information based on current psychological research — can help us see the biological-psychological process we call desire in a different light. That different view can bring immediate relief even before any therapy begins. But to get there, we first need to demolish the Masters and Johnson myth of desire.
Masters and Johnson developed a model we might call the "flight model." According to this model, the first stage of a "normal" sexual process is each partner's self-awareness of the sexual desire that arises in them toward the other. In other words, if I'm a woman with "healthy" sexuality, then according to this view I have sexual fantasies about my partner even when we're not in bed or in a sexual situation, and I long for sexual closeness well before sex is even on the table.
According to Masters and Johnson, after this stage comes, in sequence, a stage of physiological sexual arousal centered on genital changes. In other words, after my fantasies, I become aware of sexual changes happening in my body. Then comes the sexual activity itself, ending in orgasmic release.
Despite how revolutionary it was, and the huge contribution Masters and Johnson made to the study of sexuality, the model they proposed for healthy, mature sexuality in a relationship is problematic. The problematic part we'll focus on here is the fact that, according to this model, "ideal" sexual activity is built from clear, separate stages, with no overlap between them, that lead into one another in an order that can't be changed.
Here's why this model is called the "flight model": to fly to some country, I first need to know I want to get to that country (let's call it "Orgasmia"). Second, I understand the only way to get there is by flying. Once I've bought the ticket, checked in at the airport, and taken my seat on the plane, a chain of mechanical events I have no control over begins, ending with the plane landing at another point, and me arriving at my destination.
The "flight model" reigned supreme for decades, and enlisted the best film directors in its service, who produced envy-inducing scenes of mutual, unstoppable sexual desire ("Last Tango in Paris" and "A Walk in the Clouds" — despite how odd it is to mention these two films in the same breath — are prominent examples from both sides of the Atlantic, though of course there are hundreds of examples in between, to the point that the phrase "Hollywood cliché" applied to them has itself become a cliché).

But over the last fifteen years, scientific evidence that contradicts this view has been piling up, and in its place a different model has been proposed, one we'll call here the "meal model." Anyone who wants to dig into the research itself is welcome to read Rosemary Basson, who has written extensively on the new model of female sexual response (the terms "flight model" and "meal model" aren't taken from the professional literature — they're offered here as images to make the different models more accessible).
According to the "meal model," just as we don't sit down to eat only after fantasizing about food and then feeling physical hunger, we also have a whole range of motivations that drive us to move sexually closer to our partner. Women in particular may be drawn by a wish to deepen emotional closeness with their partner, improve their quality of life, strengthen their self-image, feel more attractive or feminine, and also, no doubt, to reduce the guilt and anxiety that come from thinking their sex life as a couple isn't satisfying enough. I might want to have sex as a way to boost my partner's self-image, to head off the possibility that he'll sleep with someone else, or simply to show him love.
This sounds like a clear, simple description, but it sometimes meets resistance from people hearing it for the first time. Many couples feel that swapping the idea of "desire" for "motivation" suggests something about their sex life isn't authentic, natural, or "normal." If I'm connecting to my motivation in order to have sex, instead of being swept along by a wave of desire, I might end up seeing myself as manipulative. People whose relationships are truly good — I might think — have sex all the time simply because they're "in the mood" for each other, nonstop.
But anyone who thinks this way is probably torturing themselves for nothing. Studies that looked at the experiences of thousands of people show that sex doesn't accelerate from zero to sixty the way many of us believe. For exactly that reason, it's worth comparing the process of sexual closeness to the process of getting ready for a meal. Both the need for food and the need for sex are instincts, and yet we recognize many different ways of enjoying a meal: sometimes I'm truly starving and have to eat something just to quiet the physiological need, but very often I can eat even when I'm not hungry — out of enjoyment of company, intimacy, or celebration, or because the way food is presented and the care put into it awakens my desire to eat. In other words, we know that "appetite comes with eating" — so why not accept that this is also true of sex?
None of this is meant, heaven forbid, to endorse sexual aggression of the "you want it really" variety, or "when you say no, what do you really mean?" Nor is it an attempt to legitimize the way women may objectify themselves within a relationship, treating their own sexuality as a commodity. On the contrary, this is a model that doesn't aim to be normative, in the sense of setting behavioral norms — it aims to more accurately describe the subjective sexual experience of many women (and men). Precisely because of that, it has feminist potential.
In other words, the fact that this model claims women and men don't need to give up various parts of their sexuality in order to fit the "flight model" resonates with the Carol Gilligan school of feminism, which sees feminism as a shared struggle of men and women, side by side, against patriarchy. In this case, one could argue that patriarchy is expressed through the particular, twentieth-century standard of "proper" sexuality.
On the other hand, it's clearly not quite accurate to say that "appetite comes with eating" either. Sex in a relationship is more complicated than a plate of falafel. We're not alone — there's another person beside us, and the relationship between us and that other person is already a third entity, with its own history and dynamics. Life experience shows that our sexual need doesn't display — at least not for many women and men — the same independent stability regardless of social and emotional context that our need for food does. In other words, I'm likely to be hungry every day, no matter how much stress is in my life or how tired I am, but that's not necessarily true of my need for sex.
And yet, even when it comes to psycho-social difficulties around sexuality (as opposed to medical difficulties), the "meal model" can help us understand the obstacles standing between couples and good sex better than the "flight model" can. That's because the very fact that there are many ways to stir up appetite also means there are many things that can ruin it: if the place I'm sitting down to eat in is neglected and dirty, the salad is floating in old oil, cockroaches are running across the floor, the waiter is ignoring me or being condescending, it's already too late in the day for me, I'm tired or stressed, the people next to me are talking on the phone, or cars outside are honking terribly loudly — every one of these things can kill my appetite.
In other words, a great many things can turn me off sexually: first and foremost, the relationship with my partner, but also if I'm afraid of pregnancy, of sexually transmitted diseases, and of course if I fear for my physical or emotional wellbeing — these will create significant disruptions to sex. Add to that everyday worries (how will the child do at the new daycare? what about the spreadsheet I still haven't finished going through?), and mix in, for the sake of the example, worries about my own sexual functioning and my partner's — and the outcome isn't promising.
It's important to stress that even though this model focuses mainly on female sexual response, men also suffer from believing their sexual appetite is supposed to be large and stable regardless of their emotional state, the state of their relationship, their age, or the stage of life they're in.
The "meal model" differs from the "flight model" in that it makes clear the stages of sexual arousal aren't distinct — there's overlap between them — and it has another explanatory advantage: it lets us think differently about the other end of a sexual encounter between partners, meaning how sex is supposed to end. In the "flight model," it's clear the plane is supposed to reach cruising altitude and then land at its destination — namely, "Orgasmia." If one partner doesn't "finish," the mission has failed. So under the old view, which defined the existence of sexual fantasies and sexual longing before intercourse, and orgasmic release, as necessary, independent stages of the sexual process, far more couples — especially women — were seen as suffering from sexual dysfunction.
It's clear, then, why the "meal model" offers more diagnostic flexibility on this point too: whether we want to talk about a feeling of fullness, or pick dessert as our analogy for the end of a meal, satisfaction with the meal isn't necessarily measured by orgasm, but in relation to the original motivations that drove the couple to have sex in the first place. If our goal was emotional closeness, or a boost to self-image, the sex will be judged a success if it helped us get there. In other words, some people love finishing with a cheese platter, some absolutely need chocolate, and some don't need dessert at all with every meal.
It's hard to grasp this as long as we understand sex in a relationship through the "flight model." Why did you warm up the engines, make all that noise, and wake up the whole neighborhood, if not to land? But if we're willing to broaden our perspective and also examine the motivations for sexual closeness, it becomes easy to understand how, say, a greater sense of emotional closeness can be a wonderful, satisfying feeling at the end of a sexual encounter.
Of course, none of this is meant to belittle women's need — or anyone's need — to have the sexual experience they actually want. It's only meant to free both men and women from trying to measure up to a model that, despite its scientific appearance, probably doesn't capture reality accurately, and needlessly makes many men and women feel broken.
In couples therapy, the psychological advantage of the updated "meal model" over the classic "flight model" is enormous. The main reason is that as long as we think of sex as governed by the level of desire each of us happens to feel, we're powerless. Desire is experienced as something that arrives from outside and takes us over — Cupid's arrow striking us — something you either have or you don't. As long as a couple lives under the shadow of the "flight model," and sees their sexuality as driven by the presence or absence of desire, there isn't much a couples therapist can offer.
But motivation is an entirely different matter, because it's a realm where a great deal of change is possible. The "meal model" lets the couples therapist and the partners understand that part of the process of growing sexually closer involves getting to know one's own motivations and one's partner's. From there, each therapist works in her own way — whether through Esther Perel's method or through EFT — to nurture those motivations in ways that help the bedroom door lock quietly a little more often.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




