top of page

Is That Really What You Feel? What the Inner Gaslighter Does to Us

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Mar 21, 2024
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

They spend their whole lives chasing outside approval and validation for what they feel and the decisions they make — in their careers, in raising their kids, even in their workout routines. Who are the people walking around with an "inner gaslighter," and how can we actually help them?

Rona (a pseudonym, like every name in this piece), 36, moved to Israel from England and started a family here. She grabbed her young twins and flew to her parents' house in London on the very evening of October 7. For the first few months, Rona had no doubts at all about the decision she'd made — but lately, she's started to second-guess herself.

On one hand, she's afraid to come back to Israel as long as there's a real risk of war breaking out in the north, and for as long as the war in Gaza drags on. On the other hand, she can't make peace with her own choice, because an inner voice keeps attacking her, telling her she's overreacting, being strange, and failing to show the same resilience as her friends still in Israel.

Shani, 50, mother to three daughters ranging from nine to eighteen, spends most of her free time either taking her daughters to various therapists and consultants, or in her own sessions with those same professionals. Shani consults psychiatrists, psychologists, occupational therapists, coaches, and financial advisers. When she isn't consulting a professional, she's frequently consulting her parents, her siblings, and her friends instead.

Daniel, a 27-year-old actor, regularly asks his therapist whether the decisions he's making are the right ones, what she would do in his place, whether she thinks he's correctly reading the behavior of the people in his life — and whether his workout and eating plan is actually good for him.

Rona, Shani, and Daniel are all three suffering from a psychological pattern that schema therapy calls the "inner gaslighter." As I've explained here before, the term gaslighting comes from the name of an early-20th-century play, later adapted into film several times, in which a husband manipulates his wife into doubting her own grip on reality, trying to convince her she's losing her mind. From there, the term came to describe any situation where one person uses psychological manipulation to undermine another person's trust in their own reality testing, and in their own inner voice.

Behavior like this, directed at other people, tends to show up in people with narcissistic personality disorder, and, for slightly different reasons, in people with borderline personality disorder too. But as in the three cases above, it can just as easily play out entirely inside a single person, between them and themselves.

The Other Person Must Be Right

In schema therapy, the term "inner gaslighter" refers to a form of internal dialogue, or an inner voice, that undermines a person's confidence in their own feelings, thoughts, and perceptions. A critic like this living inside our own heads can make us doubt our own experiences and our own grip on reality. It's a form of self-sabotage that keeps us from trusting ourselves and our own instincts — which usually leads to confusion, low self-esteem, and difficulty making decisions.

Rona, for instance, can't decide whether to stay in London or come back to Israel — even though her friends, her family, and her own therapist all tell her it's a perfectly legitimate choice either way. And yet she can't let herself off the hook. Her difficulty trusting her own gut on this is itself evidence of her inner gaslighter at work, repeatedly making her fear that her own read on reality is somehow broken.

Shani is endlessly chasing outside validation from her long list of advisers, driven by a deep fear of making the wrong call. Her constant need for outside approval reflects the inner turmoil going on in her head, and the self-doubt nagging at her — the telltale signs of an inner gaslighter.

Daniel, too, doesn't trust his own way of weighing the pros and cons of decisions about his career. In sessions with his therapist, he struggles to actually listen to himself, and instead keeps searching for the one piece of advice that will let him feel secure in his decision, and in his own emotional reactions to the negative dynamics in his life. For example, a friend once promised to help him rehearse audition lines — then flaked. Daniel was hurt by this, especially since he'd helped that same friend in similar situations before, but he equally struggles to give himself permission to simply feel hurt. He needs someone outside himself to tell him it's okay to be hurt in a situation like that.

Daniel's problem isn't seeking outside advice or opinions in itself — that can be a genuinely useful part of making a decision — it's how excessively he relies on them to settle internal matters, like his own feelings.

The Voice of the Inner Catastrophizer

As a therapist, I can tell you it isn't always easy to spot an inner gaslighter at work. Very often, people struggle to make decisions because of a different inner voice: the catastrophizer. In emotion-focused therapy, that voice has its own name — in Hebrew, roughly "the dreader." Our inner dreader gets us, for example, to read every ordinary setback as a catastrophe — far worse than it actually is. It's an exaggeration of the odds of failure, disaster, or negative consequences. Often, the dreader isn't satisfied with just warning us about some looming danger — it also tells us we're too weak to handle it.

For example, someone with an active "dreader" voice discovers they owe money to the National Insurance Institute — and immediately spirals into a dreadful loop of thoughts: "Even if you manage to pay off this debt, it just proves you can't actually manage your own finances, which means there's no chance you'll ever feel financially secure; what would you do if the debt were bigger than this? You'd have to pull your kid out of summer camp; you're not saving enough as it is, your job isn't stable, things are hard enough already, maybe it's better to move the money out of Israel, or at least buy foreign currency — but then again, maybe now isn't the time, maybe it's better to wait for the shekel to strengthen..." and on and on, forever. Anyone with an active inner dreader knows just how hard it is to stop that tune from playing — but it's a different tune from the inner gaslighter's.

If Rona were dealing with an inner dreader rather than an inner gaslighter, she'd be stuck spinning out catastrophic scenarios (if I go back and a war breaks out up north, maybe I won't be able to leave again; Hezbollah's rockets will knock out the power grid, flights will stop coming in, even ships won't be able to leave). Instead, her inner gaslighter turns its fire on her (why am I so neurotic and messed up?).

If Daniel were dealing with an inner dreader, every audition would come wrapped in thoughts like "I'm going to blank on my lines, my career is over"; any small disagreement with a friend would send him spiraling into "that's it, I've ruined everything, he'll never want to talk to me again." Instead, his inner gaslighter makes him doubt himself and his own feelings: "Is this friend really treating me badly, or am I just being too sensitive? Maybe it's normal for him to flake on me even after I've helped him so much, and I'm just overreacting?"

Internalizing a Parent's Version of Reality

Very often, a struggle with an inner gaslighter points back to a childhood spent in the shadow of an especially difficult parent — one who routinely gaslit the child, and repeatedly dismissed that child's feelings, thoughts, and view of the world. When parents consistently deny, question, or minimize their child's actual experience ("If you don't want me to get angry, then stop being so annoying"), the child learns to doubt their own version of reality, which can, in turn, grow into a full inner gaslighter. Growing up in an environment that gaslights us leaves us with mixed messages about what's actually true or false. That inconsistency creates a basic uncertainty about whether we can trust our own judgment, and our own memories.

Rona, for instance, grew up with a father who had borderline personality disorder, and a mother who denied his condition entirely. When Rona was a child, her father would sometimes be seized by anxiety and go sleep on the rug in her room, next to her bed. Rona's mother treated this with total indifference, and on the occasions when Rona voiced her own discomfort with the arrangement, her father would call her cold, unfeeling, and ungrateful.

When Daniel's mother used to walk around in her underwear and bra in front of his friends when he was a kid, he was deeply embarrassed by it. When he told her how embarrassed he felt, she didn't change her behavior at all — instead, she mocked him for being "uptight" and for "picking such square friends."

Shani's parents used to take advantage of her father's long business trips to spend time abroad together, sometimes bringing her older brother along on the family trip too. Shani would be left home alone with a nanny, while the whole family acted as if there were nothing at all wrong with that: after all, Shani was in good hands, the nanny took care of all her needs and drove her to her activities — and if Shani struggled with the arrangement, that was proof enough that she was being infantile and spoiled.

In that sense, the inner gaslighter can be understood as an internalized version of the gaslighting parent — a kind of survival strategy from a time when falling in line with the parents' version of reality was the only way to secure emotional or physical safety. Which is exactly why identifying the effects of a gaslighting parent is such a crucial step toward healing. In therapy, people like Rona, Shani, and Daniel can come to better understand how experiences like these built these destructive patterns in them in the first place; from there, they can gradually build trust in themselves, develop the ability to validate their own feelings and experiences, dismantle the influence of the inner gaslighter, and move toward making decisions — and forming a sense of self — that's genuinely their own.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page