"I'm Ashamed of You, You're Pathetic": How to Quiet the Inner Voice That's Killing Us
Updated: Oct 22
Relentless criticism, constant comparison to people who are "more successful": our inner voice torments us, hurts us, and gets in the way of processing our emotions properly. Emotion-focused therapy has an exercise that helps clients understand how this mechanism works - and how to take it apart.
We all have an inner voice that torments us. Well, maybe not all of us - psychopaths apparently don't have one. But everyone else has this inner voice, which measures our performance against a set of standards and values, and most of the time shows us just how far we fall short of its expectations.
For some people, that inner voice is especially harsh ("Gross, you call that washing your hands?"). For many others, it focuses on comparison to other people ("Shame on you - how is it that your sister manages to save for retirement and you don't?"). Either way, this voice torments us and causes us pain.
In emotion-focused therapy, it often turns out that this inner voice is getting in the way of the client processing their emotions properly. There are various tells for this, but the clearest one is when the client is very preoccupied with what they "should" do, "should" feel, or "should" want. Our inner critic is very fond of the words "should" and "shouldn't."
In this kind of therapy, the therapist places an empty chair facing the client and asks them to move back and forth between two chairs - one representing the critical voice, the other the part that absorbs the criticism. The exercise begins in the "critical" chair: the client sits in it, looks at the spot where they were sitting before, and tries to picture themselves sitting there. At this point they're asked to begin verbally attacking themselves the way the critical voice attacks them in daily life, or in a specific situation they described earlier in therapy.
The therapist encourages the client to give their critical voice full rein - even, deliberately, in its harshest form. At this stage, the inner critic hurls statements at the client like "I'm ashamed of you," "You disappoint me," "You're a failure," "You're no good at anything," "You're pathetic," and so on. The therapist helps the client distill the critical part's harsh message, and also sharpen exactly how that part feels toward the client in this context. For example: "You're a failure and I despise you," or "You're weak and I'm ashamed of you."
This difficult exercise serves a double purpose. On the cognitive level, it matters enormously that the client begins to understand that these are things they've actually been saying to themselves for years. On the emotional level, the goal is to stir up indignation in the part experiencing the attack. Once the aggressive message has been distilled, the therapist guides the client to move to the second chair and look at the spot where they sat while playing the critical part.

At this stage, the therapist asks the client to connect with the physical sensations that arise in them in the face of the critical attack they've just experienced. Often, the client will say they agree, or maybe disagree, with the critical voice's statements - but the therapist's job is to help the client set aside orderly thoughts and focus instead on the physical experience the critical attack stirs up in them.
When the client turns their attention to this, they usually begin to feel discomfort in the stomach, tightness in the chest, difficulty breathing, and above all, pain in various forms. Now the therapist guides the client to address the critical voice directly and describe the physical sensations that arise while being attacked this way. Afterward, the therapist encourages the client to feel and express what they need while feeling so attacked.
The client may need acknowledgment from the critical voice, comfort, encouragement, space, faith, compassion, or some combination of these and similar things. After the client expresses their needs, the therapist guides them to move back to the critical chair and respond, as the critical voice, to what the client said and to the needs they expressed.
In most cases, the process doesn't end there. In the standard emotion-focused therapy process, at this stage the therapist guides the client to respond, on the one hand, spontaneously - but on the other hand, to notice and make room for any resistance the critical part has to the request. The therapist legitimizes the critical voice's right to push back against the client's request with acknowledgment and compassion - and even to keep causing the client pain. This move can seem strange, and may even run against therapeutic intuition, but the goal is to reach the root of the pain and allow for a genuine transformation of it.
"You can't leave a place until you arrive there," says Leslie Greenberg - and in order for the critical voice to be replaced with self-compassion, you first have to arrive at the place where the critical voice lives, touch the damage it causes, and feel the pain.
After this difficult stage, the therapist brings the client back to their regular seat and again encourages them to reconnect with their pain and confront the critical voice with the pain it causes. As before, the therapist encourages the client to direct their requests to the critical voice. The more tangible the connection to the pain, the greater the chance that the next time the therapist moves the client to the critical chair, we'll witness a meaningful softening in the critical voice toward the client.
Therapy sessions like this are highly dramatic, and can branch out into various experiential exercises, with the critical voice's chair sometimes occupied by a terrifying voice that fills the client with horrifying visions of awful things that might happen to them. Other times, the chair may be occupied by a figure from the client's life with whom they have unfinished business. But despite the branches and the personal nuances specific to each client, the optimistic fact is that, done properly, in most cases you don't need to walk this path very many times to achieve meaningful improvement - and to weaken, sometimes permanently, the critical voice the client has suffered under for so many years.
Recommendations
Book: "Kach Lehisha'er La'olam" ("This Is How You Stay in the World"), by Yona Elon (Tesa Neshamot, 2018)
Yona Elon's writing/life journal will inspire and give faith to anyone for whom words help make sense of themselves and of existence. In therapy sessions, I often feel just how enormous the drama of life's small moments really is - the victories and defeats a person experiences against themselves, against others, against the elements, as reflected in a conversation with a bank teller, a walk against the rain, waking up early in the morning, a conversation with a family member. Elon's writing is a lucid, luminous example of that drama.
Sleep: Magnesium L-Threonate
I take three different kinds of magnesium every day, and each has its own thing going for it. Some are absorbed better, some less so (which is sometimes actually desirable, since poorer absorption can, for instance, be good for digestion). But one of the types most important to my quality of life is magnesium L-threonate, because taking it before bed improves my sleep. This is a relatively new recommendation in the medical world, and as always, ask your doctor before taking any supplement - but personally, I've experienced a significant improvement in my sleep quality with it.
Fitness: Coconut Water as a Sports Drink
Most of us don't actually need to hydrate in any special way when we exercise - our activity usually isn't intense enough to require it. Still, sometimes working out is so unpleasant that a drink with a bit of flavor and sweetness is simply nice to have. Standard sports drinks have plenty of downsides I won't get into here. Instead, I've found that if you dilute it with plenty of ice, coconut water (the kind now common in every grocery store in Israel) can work as a sports drink in many cases, since it has enough sweetness for the psychological effect, and most varieties also contain a range of salts, especially potassium, which can suit people who work out.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




